It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I got both FreeSpace 1 and 2 in the Xmas sale and so far I've really been enjoying the first game. However, I don't have a joystick, only my 360 controller.

For the most part this works well enough, but being an older game it uses DirectInput, whereas the 360 controller is XInput, and this causes a minor issue. The right analog stick only works on the vertical axis, which the game picks up as the RX axis and used for rolling the craft. Now obviously it is a little strange to be using an up and down motion to roll the craft left and right, so I'm looking for a way to re-map the axis.

I've tried Xpadder but that doesn't support mapping an axis to an axis (it only maps functions to button presses), so the closest I've got is to map the left and right movement of the right analog stick to keyboard roll left and right, but this loses the analog advantage of varying roll speed.

I've heard of Pinnacle Game Profiler but haven't tried it. It would appear from the website that it should be able to remap the axes but I don't know much about the program.

So, has anyone tried it before and is there anything I should know about it?
This question / problem has been solved by tinyEimage
Have tried MotionJoy? It lets you use your regular gamepad and emulate x360, ps3, ps2 controller with it. Also Pinnacle is a nice tool that allows you to remap every button. And the profile section covers almost every game. There is nothing special to say about it really because it does what it does and it works well with motion joy.

Although it doesn't have freespace 1 profile, so try it out for freespace and see how it works out for you
http://pinnaclegameprofiler.com/game-profiles/f
Post edited January 01, 2014 by Zurvan7
I realize MENSA isn't breaking down my door so this opinion doesn't carry much weight, but the thought of playing either Freespace game with anything but a mouse + keyboard makes my head spin.
avatar
Zurvan7: Have tried MotionJoy? It lets you use your regular gamepad and emulate x360, ps3, ps2 controller with it. Also Pinnacle is a nice tool that allows you to remap every button. And the profile section covers almost every game. There is nothing special to say about it really because it does what it does and it works well with motion joy.

Although it doesn't have freespace 1 profile, so try it out for freespace and see how it works out for you
http://pinnaclegameprofiler.com/game-profiles/f
MotionInJoy takes controllers and remaps them so that they are detected as 360 controllers, so I'm not sure what it would do to map my 360 controller to itself.

I've given Pinnacle a try as it has a 20 day trial, and I'm a bit disappointed. Yes it has lots of functions, but even the FreeSpace 2 profile shows that to get the right stick left and right to roll left and right it has to map them to the keyboard buttons, so losing the analog rolling.

I also tried to get Pinnacle to work for X-Wing Alliance which has the same roll left and right issue (it really is just that the right stick is detected as the DirectInput RX - for rotation - along the vertical instead of the horizontal) and even Pinnacle's DirectX overrides don't fix it. For X-Wing Alliance I would also want to lose the triggers as the Z-axis and make them into digital buttons instead so that I can get rid of the annoying Z axis always reverting back to the centre position giving 50% throttle.
I've only played with the joystick on FS2 but does the source port fully support the 360 controller? If so, he could just get the Freespace 1 campaign for it and play on that.
avatar
Shaolin_sKunk: I've only played with the joystick on FS2 but does the source port fully support the 360 controller? If so, he could just get the Freespace 1 campaign for it and play on that.
Well, I've already completed the first two acts of the game, so only act 3 and the Silent Threat expansion left. Has Silent Threat been created for the FSOpen port?
Perhaps x360ce could help?
I've never tried it though so I don't know.
avatar
korell: Well, I've already completed the first two acts of the game, so only act 3 and the Silent Threat expansion left. Has Silent Threat been created for the FSOpen port?
There is a remake, yeah, called "Silent Threat Reborn" though it seems to be improved in some ways and also extended a bit. Don't know how important the authentic experience is for you and I've only played the original version so I don't know how it compares really.

It's not overly long though so at this point you might as well just plow through what remains of Freespace and Silent Threat.
Post edited January 01, 2014 by Shaolin_sKunk
avatar
korell: snip
JoyToKey should be the answer. I haven't really tried it myself yet, have only taken a quick look at its capabilities but my brother, who is not tech-savvy at all, has used it to use a XInput joystick with DirectInput games so it should be a pretty easy thing to achieve. From what I've seen the tool recognizes XInput controllers as such and allows you to map the input to DirectInput commands.

I'm not sure yet whether it supports "expansion" the way MotionInJoy does (which is necessary for correct diagonal movement, else you won't be able to reach the "corners").
A little more researching and it seems the only way (at least at present anyway) is to use GlovePIE and PPJoy. GlovePIE grabs the XInput instructions from the 360 controller and outputs them as DirectInput instructions to a virtual joystick via PPJoy. Then you have to get the game to read the virtual joystick as the input device and to ignore the 360 controller.

Seems like way too much effort and it isn't guaranteed to work for all games.

So, all in all, as Pinnacle really wouldn't do what I was after any differently to Xpadder, I'm going to stick with Xpadder. No analog rolling, but well, that is only a minor control and digital turning will do (though isn't ideal).

As for X-Wing Alliance I can map the right stick up and down to accelerate and decelerate, freeing up two more buttons on the controller which is very much needed as I've found no way of getting the game to ignore the Z-axis on the triggers.
avatar
tinyE: I realize MENSA isn't breaking down my door so this opinion doesn't carry much weight, but the thought of playing either Freespace game with anything but a mouse + keyboard makes my head spin.
Agreed, I also used the numpad for large movements, the mouse for finer movements.
Ooh, looks like someone is working on something that will address this very issue. It can be downloaded and used at present but I think they are still trying to get their drivers signed so that it works on 64-bit Windows without disabling the test for signed drivers.

http://evilc.com/joomla/articles/9-code/autohotkey/1-ujr-universal-joystick-remapper
Well, an update on this situation.

FreeSpace 1 main campaign, I managed it through using my 360 controller with the roll axis on the right stick the wrong way up, but I did use Xpadder to map the correct way to digital roll via the numpad keys. It also meant I could add a vibration to the afterburner button which was a nice touch.

That said, the control wasn't ideal as aiming was a little off at times, and the Silent Threat expansion was just seriously annoying me on the first mission, which I just couldn't do in time.

As such, FreeSpace 1 got uninstalled, and I moved onto FreeSpace 2, for which I'm using FS2Open 3.7.0 and the MediaVPs. Have to say, it looks great. Oh, it doesn't offer any improvement in support for 360 controllers. It seems to still be DirectInput, not XInput, so the wrong axis mapping still carries over.

So, tried playing FS2 with the 360 controller but something wasn't quite right, so instead I tried the mouse for aiming. Had to move the sensitivity up to the max but once that was done it does give a nice steadier and easier aiming experience. Because of that I then unplugged the controller, removed all the key bindings for the controller and set up the mouse to play, learning many of the targetting, weapon and thrust keys. To aid just that little bit more I also set up a GlovePIE script to enable me to use the two extra buttons I have on my mouse, one of which when held makes my left/right motions with the mouse roll instead of turn, the other to cycle secondary weapon firing rate.

So yes, I've now moved to a mouse and keyboard control system. Going to have to give tinyE the solution as first to say mouse and keyboard :P. But all the different programs, Xpadder, MotionInJoy, Pinnacle, Joy2Key, just aren't set up to do what I need without using an additional program such as PPJoy to set up a virtual DirectInput device to map to, and PPJoy doesn't have signed drivers for 64-bit yet meaning I'd have to disable the signed driver requirement, but two programs and this just seems like too much work for such a simple requirement.
avatar
korell: So yes, I've now moved to a mouse and keyboard control system. Going to have to give tinyE the solution as first to say mouse and keyboard :P. But all the different programs, Xpadder, MotionInJoy, Pinnacle, Joy2Key, just aren't set up to do what I need without using an additional program such as PPJoy to set up a virtual DirectInput device to map to, and PPJoy doesn't have signed drivers for 64-bit yet meaning I'd have to disable the signed driver requirement, but two programs and this just seems like too much work for such a simple requirement.
I agree that a joypad - XInput or otherwise - is the worst way to play FreeSpace. Not even a dedicated DirectInput pad like the F510 makes it any better. Without a proper joystick, mouse & keyboard is definitely the way to go.

Mind you, a proper flightstick with three-axis movement and a dedicated throttle beats out mouse & keyboard for me.
Gradually managed to download the various FSPort files in order to be able to play FreeSpace 1 in the FreeSpace 2 game using FS2Open, and it does look very nice with the high res graphics. Only intending to play The Silent Threat expansion, though, being as I finished the main campaign in the original engine.

Anyway, that first mission that was giving me so much trouble is really easy in the port. Is it some change in AI or something, because of it being in the FS2Open engine? Or is it that I'm using mouse and keyboard? Or that I've learned more over time like the auto-targetting? Maybe it is all of the above? But yes, managed to get through over half of Silent Threat in one sitting. Very pleased. Once done I'll return to the FS2 campaign.