It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
ShadowWulfe: Why not offer the OS or whatever is required to emulate it as an item to buy with the rest of the games being a kind of "DLC" for the OS/emulator? (you can't buy the games unless you have the OS or something like that, however the current DLC system works)
avatar
Darvond: Because it runs on a separate architecture entirely.
Uhh, what's that got to do with anything?

To me it seems that he was simply suggesting a way of fitting it to GOG's business model. If you sell a Kickstart-Emulator package as the game then you can sell all the Amiga games as 'DLC' for the emulator. Makes sense to me.

I don't see how the architecture comes into it, it's not as if he was suggesting installing the OS directly onto his PC.
It's not a problem technically. Would work just as easily as DOS games in DOSbox. Licensing stuff would be the bigger problem. I've played a lot of Amiga games in UAE without any problems, mostly games I played with an Amiga 500 back in the day.

You can even emulate disk loading sounds and get an USB replica of the old Competition Pro joystick to go with it :D
I would totally dig it and buy some games if GOG could do it.

Edit. And please! Don't plant those new Amiga ideas in my head. I've been toying with the idea of getting a nice hardware and a new AmigaOS :D Just because I can and I'm a tinkerer.
Post edited November 29, 2013 by Daliz
avatar
SirPrimalform: To me it seems that he was simply suggesting a way of fitting it to GOG's business model. If you sell a Kickstart-Emulator package as the game then you can sell all the Amiga games as 'DLC' for the emulator. Makes sense to me.
Yes, from a technical standpoint, it's absolutely doable, even easy.

The real problem is in the licensing issues and the deals that would need to be worked out to get through them.

Come to think of it, there might be some technical issues after all. I'm thinking about save games here. That won't be an issue with all games, but in some cases it will be.

Also, there's the matter of pricing. In some cases, it will probably be necessary to bundle some games together to reach a "value" that people will be willing to pay $6 for.
avatar
SirPrimalform: To me it seems that he was simply suggesting a way of fitting it to GOG's business model. If you sell a Kickstart-Emulator package as the game then you can sell all the Amiga games as 'DLC' for the emulator. Makes sense to me.
avatar
Wishbone: Yes, from a technical standpoint, it's absolutely doable, even easy.

The real problem is in the licensing issues and the deals that would need to be worked out to get through them.

Come to think of it, there might be some technical issues after all. I'm thinking about save games here. That won't be an issue with all games, but in some cases it will be.

Also, there's the matter of pricing. In some cases, it will probably be necessary to bundle some games together to reach a "value" that people will be willing to pay $6 for.
As I understood it, the problems in licencing it were incompatible business models (GOG only selling self contained packages and the fact that the Kickstart owners selling it as something you buy once and then use for all games. If GOG included the Kickstart ROMs with game then you'd be buying them again with every game. Using the DLC model that GOG now supports means at least that problem is solved...
Or you can simply dump the Kickstart from your own Amiga and transfer it to your PC, or buy it somewhere else like Cloanto. Or you already have the kickstart file. GOG shouldn't even need to worry about licensing the kickstarts. You either need Kickstart 1.3 for OCS games and Kickstart 3.1 for AGA games.

The main problem is configuring WinUAE for the specific games (which shouldn't be a problem for anyone that is used to using WinUAE.)

WinUAE is updated regularly as can be seen here:

http://eab.abime.net/showthread.php?t=69953
Post edited November 29, 2013 by ancalimon
Or GOG could just sell the Amiga games but people would have to get WinUAE of buy Amiga Forever elsewhere.

Question is only, how many would just buy the games without reading "YOU NEED AN AMIGA EMULATOR TO RUN THIS GAME", and then complain that the game doesn't work?
Highly doubt it. The jackasses own amiga aren't letting Kickstart Roms to be legally sold. Too bad for them. Id look at paying for amiga games, not the actual Kickstart ROMS though. It would be akin to buying Windows 3.1 or having to BUY DOS. No. F..... NO
avatar
itchy01ca01: Highly doubt it. The jackasses own amiga aren't letting Kickstart Roms to be legally sold. Too bad for them. Id look at paying for amiga games, not the actual Kickstart ROMS though. It would be akin to buying Windows 3.1 or having to BUY DOS. No. F..... NO
I think you can sell all kickstart roms upto 3.1 (which is the latest "physical" ROM)

Kickstart Roms are the core of Amiga operating system and there is no free alternative like DosBox.

They are like the BIOS of the Amiga.

Amiga ROMS are the things that makes an Amiga run.

Since they are copyrighted you would have to either buy them or an Amiga that comes with them.
Post edited November 30, 2013 by ancalimon
Kickstarter roms are not a blocker anymore, Cloanto has negotiated rights to sell them, so they can be negotiated here too.

Sure, it's an extra hurdle over clearing rights to the games themselves, and the licensing might require us to buy an "amiga pass" or similar if we don't own the roms or contribute to slightly higher prices for amiga games.

The real remaining hurdles are:
* probably even moldier/oldier rights negotiation to clear up who can OK the sale of these games from circa 1990. (remember a lot of amiga houses went under)
* A bunch of additional technical work on GOG's part in order to sell them, for unknown sales figures.

I still want it to happen.