Firebrand9: [see direct quotations below]
Seriously, I either need to figure out the BB Code or GoG needs forums that allow for easier quotes. Just, damn, man. XD
----
"The cheapness of the AI can be offset with good level design including architecture and supplying adequate health to the player. If the difficulty level you're playing on doesn't give you enough health, ratchet down the difficulty level. That's what it's there for. You can't blame the game for your unwillingness to do this."
It's not a matter of the difficulty setting relative to enemy/player health and enemy damage, this is purely related to how these games function at their core. It's problematic at best when the player must take extra shots at the enemy because of the auto-aim feature or mouse sluggishness, this is something that only knowing the level really well and being unduly over-prepared for can help remedy. It's a more serious issue when point blank shots or direct shots with nothing interfering with hitting the enemy do not register all of the damage that they should. I've encountered this a number of times from Duke Nukem 3D to Shadow Warrior to Blood, however I find it to be the most problematic in Blood.
Should the player ratchet down the difficulty to overcome a legitimate mechanical issue? No, they certainly shouldn't and the criticism is something the player should appropriately level. With that being said, should the player ratchet down the difficulty for an enjoyable play session? Yes, they should. Left 4 Dead 2 is a great example of this, where core mechanical errors make playing on Expert less than satisfying even though the player has the skill to play it. Examples that come to mind are homing Tank rocks, hit-box issues (even when playing Offline, Single Player), terrible Survivor AI and other issues.
The game should not have to be ratcheted down in difficulty to be enjoyed but if they want to enjoy the game they need to be willing to work with the problems the game gives them. I play these games at the medium difficulty setting because of the game's issues not my ability and this allows me to enjoy these games despite the criticism I level.
"While later FPS games such as Quake required and enabled greater precision, I never felt like I couldn't control the character in any Build games. On the contrary. I felt like an electrocuted cat running across velcro. Probably the reason you couldn't find much criticism for the games is that 1. They're awesome, to this day 2. Games to compare them to only came out, for the most-part, after and 3.
Your personal preference flies in the face of what most people think of them. IE - You fight the game more than play it based on your criticisms. Most other people don't seem to have these issues with it, myself included."
Three points.
First, don't do what seem to be personal attacks such as the lines I emphasised with italics. That seems like a personal attack, however if that wasn't your intention I'd ask you to be a bit more careful with your wording in the future. Use terms like 'seems like' to indicate that you may be reading something wrong or into a given argument, allowing your argument to retain strength in case you are wrong and also allowing you to not fall into (or incite) mud-slinging.
Second, these games are indeed awesome. Like I said, I played the absolute hell out of Duke Nukem 3D and Shadow Warrior in high school. It seems to me that the reasons for not finding the criticism that I've levelled, even at the time, is in part because folks were more interested in lambasting the content without attempting to understand the content. 'You can kill strippers in that game, it promotes violence against women!!!' While you can do that, yes, it's not encouraged by 3D Realms and the game punishes you for doing so. How? It spawns extra enemies. Lesson of the day: shooting strippers will cause alien hordes to come pwn your ass. The other part is likely that they were caught up in the new technology of other games like Quake.
Third, I'm glad some people don't seem to have an issue with controlling their character in the Build Engine games. Perhaps this is because they've gone through the .cfg files and tweaked them or perhaps it's how the software runs relative to their own software/hardware configurations. Whatever the case, what I've noted is likely not just a personal issue but instead a real issue that some players were able to easily navigate on their own through a combination of tweaking the game, their play, or both. The Build Engine games are not games that the player can just blast through, rather they exemplify the Latin phrase which translates to 'hasten slowly'...because if you don't you're going to get your head blown off very quickly. The problem is that a player can do just that and still encounter mechanical issues that force them to play the game's mechanics more than playing the game, which is what you aptly describe as "fighting the game".
I hoped it was clear from my OP that these issues take away from but do not deplete my enjoyment of the Build Engine games. These games do possess real problems and they are certainly worth playing because, as you've said, the games are awesome. I don't think we should forget either of those points.