It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
ET3D: I think that the main reason these games don't look that good is their age. Games designed 5-10 years ago had to work with primitive graphics cards by today's standard.

I imagine that if people recreated these games as Star Citizen mods for example, they could be made to look better than the show.
Yeah, that crossed my mind. Hope to see some talent take the initiative sooner or later. I just don't think IFH and TBP have managed to capture the essence of B5. I'd appreciate a heads-up if there's anything else going on.

avatar
jamyskis: Indeed. Even Star Trek: The Next Generation in 1987 had better CGI than Babylon 5 and, back in 1993, it was obvious even then that Babylon 5's effects were made on a much lower budget and with a much less competent team. I've seen some awesome stuff done with Lightwave on the Amiga, but Babylon 5 wasn't among it.

B5's strength was in its writing, which overcame the poor effects and some fairly wooden acting (and overacting). The main cast (O'Hare, Doyle, Boxleitner, Furlan, Katsulas, Jurasik, Carter, Mumy, Furst, Christian) were good, but almost all of the secondary characters with a few exceptions (Patricia Tallman in particular, whose role really didn't come into her own until the mediocre Season 5 ironically) were really badly acted.
Agree that B5 had its weaknesses due to this and that, but it's by far the most compelling sci-fi concept I've ever seen. Plus I enjoyed its attention to physics (to some degree), something which really can't be said about certain other popular sci-fi brands. I vaguely remember that movie as being somewhat good, but apart from that I never cared much for Star Trek in any way.
Post edited November 20, 2013 by Primate
avatar
F4LL0UT: I don't know what the games you're talking about look like but frankly I always considered the CGI in Babylon 5 pretty cheap and it has been possible for ages to render nicer stuff in real-time. Just compare X3's in-game graphics to Babylon's CGI sequences (and X3 is pretty old by now).
avatar
jamyskis: Indeed. Even Star Trek: The Next Generation in 1987 had better CGI than Babylon 5 and, back in 1993, it was obvious even then that Babylon 5's effects were made on a much lower budget and with a much less competent team. I've seen some awesome stuff done with Lightwave on the Amiga, but Babylon 5 wasn't among it.

B5's strength was in its writing, which overcame the poor effects and some fairly wooden acting (and overacting). The main cast (O'Hare, Doyle, Boxleitner, Furlan, Katsulas, Jurasik, Carter, Mumy, Furst, Christian) were good, but almost all of the secondary characters with a few exceptions (Patricia Tallman in particular, whose role really didn't come into her own until the mediocre Season 5 ironically) were really badly acted.
I haven't seen TNG in a few years, but I remember that show looking absolutely gorgeous. It's just a shame that the effects shots were done using tape technology rather than the film they used for the rest of the show.