koima57: Hi, I have to disagree because the nostalgia factor is at play here, there are cult classic that doesn't suffer the cruel tides of time, like 2D Super Mario, or 2D Sonic because of their clever structure and the overall quality (graphics, sounds) already more advanced than blocky pixels of early C64 and Intellevision creations.. Beside PONG and PACMAN I know no games of this era that made it to the Hall of Fame..
Halls of Fame and top lists really mean nothing.
They are an interesting topic for conversation, but in the end of the day, they are only some people's perceptions of things. Just like you can have great movies which never get nominated for awards and crappy movies receiving loads of awards.
But if you want an example, think about California Games. Has there been a sports game before or since, which would have such a fresh take on the entire concept of sports? That game would still be as addicitive as it ever was, as it never relied on graphics or gimmicks, instead, it relied on a fresh way of thinking and immersive playability.
And so on.
koima57: The amount of data was limited before, but today it is an indicator of the ratio quality / content there is, even if it sound unfair, it is a fact.
So basically this way of thinking means that a game which uses uncompressed sound and image files, instead of, let's say lossless compression, is better, because it has more data?
I don't think I have heard anyone saying that games like Machinarium or Time, Gentlemen, Please! are worse games than, let's say, Jack Keane 2 (a GOG cult classic), even though you could fit both games like 20 times to the storage space that Jack Keane 2 requires.
koima57: I can think of a child playing C64 goodies as first gaming experience and enjoying them thoroughly, but I can't think of this same child knowing modern gaming and still enjoying C64 games.
Yeah, and that very same child would fall asleep during the first 15 minutes of 2001: A Space Odyssey, so it must be a crappy movie?
koima57: Because what is known is setting a new reference in our memories, it's like you drink everyday good fruit juices and then, plain water... Yes, water is more healthy, no additive, etc.. But you will miss the orange juice and hardly remove it from your memory as you drink your water, unless having nothing else and it saving your life, but that's irrelevent for old games,.. But well, you get the idea!
You can have juices made from concentrates, where you have the balance of the mix completely wrong. You can have juice which has been lying in room temperature (or worse, in the direct sunlight) for hours. In both cases the juice is so disgusting, you can hardly drink it.
And then again, you can have a glass of cold, clean water. Which do you prefer?
Not to mention that juice is a rather bad drink to extinguish thirst. Have you ever run a marathon? You never drink juices during marathons. The most important liquid will be water, with special sports drinks every now and then. But never, ever, juice, no matter how much you appreciate its taste.
koima57: Even approaching C64 offerings with an adult, fresh, open mind I don't think there is THAT many cult classic and genuine fun to dig there, but that's just me, time is too short for this kind of backward experience unless very curious or just nostalgic.
Well, to each his own, I guess.
I prefer older stuff mostly when it comes to entertainment. I have no problem watching movies which were made before I was even born. A while ago I read through Arthur Conan Doyle's Holmes stories and they kept me totally entertained. And that stuff is like from 18xx something.
Although, on occasion, I do play latest games.
I installed and started playing both Botanicula and Broken Sword 5 just few hours from their release. But I don't think these are better games than older games, just because they are new.