It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
So recently my kids Wii died to a lightning strike on our house. They loved that thing so I have spoken with Santa and he will deliver a new console this Christmas. I need to tell him which one. I turn to the GOG community for any guidance you can all provide. To preface, I haven’t a clue about consoles since NHL 94 on the Sega. Here are my high level inputs if it helps frame your response…

- Kids are all young, <8
- Price doesn’t matter much, in as much as I understand I will be putting out a gold mine for any of these. In other words, I will pay for what may not be standard features if it sports a large advantage.
- Motion sense is key. Doesn’t have it, don’t want it.
- Blue Ray play capability would be nice.
- Decent selection of games for young kids. I suppose since they are all new I should say at least one or two titles for kids.
- They love the Carnival games on the Wii, Mini Golf, sports resort, etc. I am trying to stay away from violent things at the moment. Some cartoony stuff would be okay if it wasn’t the focus of the game.

Any thoughts you can give on what console would be best would be much appreciated. Further thoughts on games are welcome as well. My knowledge of those extend to Amazon reviews only.
Wii U seems the obvious choice. It's backwards compatible, so they can play all the Wii games they already have, you get access to all the wholesome family friendly Nintendo franchises, and it's the cheapest option. There are also plenty of good games for the more mature gamer, in particular through Virtual Console, should the parents wish to indulge.

No blu-ray, though.
Motion Sensing Consoles Standard: Wii U, Wii.
Motion Sensing Option: Xbox 360 (With Kinect), Xbox One, PS3/PS4 (With Playstation Eye)
Blue-ray reading: PS3, PS4. Xbox One possibly.
Largest Libraries for Kid Friendly Content: Wii+Wii U. Xbox 360 + PS3 are equal with one another., but it's up to you to understand the ESRB Ratings.
Cost, Cheapest to most Expensive: Wii, Xbox 360, PS3, Wii U, PS4, Xbox One (I think PS4 and Xbox One are in that order, prices from cheapest to most expensive going from $100 to around $600)
avatar
Zchinque: Wii U seems the obvious choice. It's backwards compatible, so they can play all the Wii games they already have, you get access to all the wholesome family friendly Nintendo franchises, and it's the cheapest option. There are also plenty of good games for the more mature gamer, in particular through Virtual Console, should the parents wish to indulge.

No blu-ray, though.
^This, and given the price of many Blu-Ray players now, surely you could pick up one separately for not too much money.
I thought I heard the Wii U was dying a quick death? The reason this matters, I would prefer to spend the money on something that will continue to have content released over the next few years as well. Also heard the Kinect stuff was the best of the motion sensor, true?
avatar
muttly13: I thought I heard the Wii U was dying a quick death? The reason this matters, I would prefer to spend the money on something that will continue to have content released over the next few years as well. Also heard the Kinect stuff was the best of the motion sensor, true?
Depends on who you talk to. The Wii is going to be discontinued. Much of the issue from Nintendo's point of view is content. The issue spoken about on the outside is they haven't been able to figure out how to market it. Wii was gangbusters, DS was gangbusters. 3DS was slow to start and it picked up hard. Wii U isn't going to be replaced quickly, there's a better chance that they'll kill inventory of the Wii and cut price on Wii U to get sales.

Kinect is hit and miss. Developers don't know what to do with it. It's a very technologically advanced piece of hardware, don't get me wrong, but actual programmers are doing more with it than developers can, and very few Kinect games have had lingering impact. There's not many of them to begin with. The Kinect is also standard in the XBox one, so it isn't a separate purchase like with Xbox 360, if that factors into the decision any.
Post edited November 21, 2013 by QC
Will the 360 games also work with the One? I recall reading somewhere it will not. There seem to be some 360 Kinect games fro kids (no idea if they are good or not) but would do me no good of course if they dont work on the One.
avatar
muttly13: Will the 360 games also work with the One? I recall reading somewhere it will not. There seem to be some 360 Kinect games fro kids (no idea if they are good or not) but would do me no good of course if they dont work on the One.
No. Neither the Xbone or PS4 is backwards compatible.
avatar
QC: Largest Libraries for Kid Friendly Content: Wii+Wii U. Xbox 360 + PS3 are equal with one another., but it's up to you to understand the ESRB Ratings.
I'd give a slight edge in kid friendliness to PS3 over 360, with their EyePets, WonderBooks and LittleBigPlanets. But Nintendo is the obvious go-to for kid friendly games, no doubt.
Post edited November 21, 2013 by Zchinque
avatar
muttly13: Will the 360 games also work with the One? I recall reading somewhere it will not. There seem to be some 360 Kinect games fro kids (no idea if they are good or not) but would do me no good of course if they dont work on the One.
Xbox One and PS4 are not backwards compatible, I think the intention is to convince you to play digital versions (Which means, an online subscription and added costs). Wii U will play all Wii games, but not Gamecube games.
Does the additional drive space on any of these things get me anything other than more saved game ability? I cant see having more than a dozen saves lets say. Any reason to get more than the base?
avatar
muttly13: Will the 360 games also work with the One? I recall reading somewhere it will not. There seem to be some 360 Kinect games fro kids (no idea if they are good or not) but would do me no good of course if they dont work on the One.
avatar
Zchinque: No. Neither the Xbone or PS4 is backwards compatible.
avatar
QC: Largest Libraries for Kid Friendly Content: Wii+Wii U. Xbox 360 + PS3 are equal with one another., but it's up to you to understand the ESRB Ratings.
avatar
Zchinque: I'd give a slight edge in kid friendliness to PS3 over 360, with their EyePets, WonderBooks and LittleBigPlanets. But Nintendo is the obvious go-to for kid friendly games, no doubt.
Nintendo also has a slightly better method of transition. Mario is kid friendly, you hit Zelda and Metroid for more teenage games. There's enough games like Sonic and Pikmin to transition between the two.

But again, Mr. OP, it will be up to you to understand the ESRB ratings to determine what you feel is right for your kids, regardless of console.
avatar
muttly13: Does the additional drive space on any of these things get me anything other than more saved game ability? I cant see having more than a dozen saves lets say. Any reason to get more than the base?
Digital downloads. The Playstations and Xboxes also have various optional/mandatory installs for some games. Not sure if the Wii U does.
avatar
muttly13: Does the additional drive space on any of these things get me anything other than more saved game ability? I cant see having more than a dozen saves lets say. Any reason to get more than the base?
It's just more saved game ability. Wii U has 32 Gigs standard, I forget what you are offered for Xbox One and PS4. For PS4 you almost absolutely need another hard drive however because the games are directly installed, and they take up a lot of size. Same for XBox One, but all 3 support external hard drives, and Wii U supports SD Cards.
avatar
muttly13: Does the additional drive space on any of these things get me anything other than more saved game ability? I cant see having more than a dozen saves lets say. Any reason to get more than the base?
avatar
QC: It's just more saved game ability. Wii U has 32 Gigs standard, I forget what you are offered for Xbox One and PS4. For PS4 you almost absolutely need another hard drive however because the games are directly installed, and they take up a lot of size. Same for XBox One, but all 3 support external hard drives, and Wii U supports SD Cards.
I believe both PS4 and Xbone is 500 GB out of the box.
avatar
QC: It's just more saved game ability. Wii U has 32 Gigs standard, I forget what you are offered for Xbox One and PS4. For PS4 you almost absolutely need another hard drive however because the games are directly installed, and they take up a lot of size. Same for XBox One, but all 3 support external hard drives, and Wii U supports SD Cards.
avatar
Zchinque: I believe both PS4 and Xbone is 500 GB out of the box.
I think those are the higher end versions though and not the standard.