It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Sooo... Barring the Xbox360 controller, what would everyone else suggest? I am working on a little bit of a budget (no thanks to the Insomnia sale :-p ) so I was strongly considering the Logitech F310 for $20. Any other suggestions?

(Currently do not have any type of pad/stick and will be using it primarily for platformers.)
avatar
Kaitu: I was strongly considering the Logitech F310 for $20
You pretty much already answered your own question. Finally picked up one of those myself about a month ago, and I certainly don't regret it. Man, I'm kind of kicking myself for not having done this sooner.

Worked great for the following games I've played with it:
Assassin's Creed (just a test for that one), Batman Arkham Asylum, Spec Ops: The Line, Spelunky, Rogue Legacy...

I'm sure I'll be able to find plenty more good uses for it in other games. :)
Do you require it to be Xinput compatible?
avatar
Kaitu: I was strongly considering the Logitech F310 for $20
avatar
mistermumbles: You pretty much already answered your own question. Finally picked up one of those myself about a month ago, and I certainly don't regret it. Man, I'm kind of kicking myself for not having done this sooner.

Worked great for the following games I've played with it:
Assassin's Creed (just a test for that one), Batman Arkham Asylum, Spec Ops: The Line, Spelunky, Rogue Legacy...

I'm sure I'll be able to find plenty more good uses for it in other games. :)
Awesome! Think I was just wanting to reinforce my decision and that helps. :-) Anyone else have good experiences with this one or have another to suggest?
F310 is a solid choice. I'd suggest the F710, but it is pricier. The F510 is basically a F310 with force feedback, if you are looking for that.
Be aware that there have been reports of huge deadzones, but personal opinion is that it's something you can get used to.
avatar
SirPrimalform: Do you require it to be Xinput compatible?
Sadly, I don't know what that means (been out of the loop in this sphere for a long while). :-p
avatar
JMich: F310 is a solid choice. I'd suggest the F710, but it is pricier. The F510 is basically a F310 with force feedback, if you are looking for that.
Be aware that there have been reports of huge deadzones, but personal opinion is that it's something you can get used to.
I looked at that one too but the wireless really isn't an issue for me unless it has other notable enhancements.
Post edited November 20, 2013 by Kaitu
avatar
SirPrimalform: Do you require it to be Xinput compatible?
avatar
Kaitu: Sadly, I don't know what that means (been out of the loop in this sphere for a long while). :-p
avatar
JMich: F310 is a solid choice. I'd suggest the F710, but it is pricier. The F510 is basically a F310 with force feedback, if you are looking for that.
Be aware that there have been reports of huge deadzones, but personal opinion is that it's something you can get used to.
avatar
Kaitu: I looked at that one too but the wireless really isn't an issue for me unless it has other notable enhancements.
For the first, the Logitech one is a good choice because it supports both Xinput (Xbox360-like) and Dinput (old standard) calls made via a toggle switch on the bottom. Around the time the 360 got released Microsoft added a new format in how gamepad calls to DirectX are handled, and pretty much everyone uses that format these days.

For the second, the only difference is wireless and rumble (plus the added need to feed it batteries).
Post edited November 20, 2013 by mistermumbles
avatar
SirPrimalform: Do you require it to be Xinput compatible?
avatar
Kaitu: Sadly, I don't know what that means (been out of the loop in this sphere for a long while). :-p
XInput is the method XBox controller uses. It has 6 axis (so analogue triggers) and a few other enhancements. Any game that supports XBox controller uses XInput.
The older model (and the one PS controllers use) is DInput. The older games don't support XInput but support DInput, and DInput controllers can usually be calibrated to emulate keyboard and mouse (with variable results obviously).
The F?10 series supports both XInput and Dinput with a switch to choose what you use, so you can use it both for older and for newer games.
avatar
mistermumbles: For the second, the only difference is wireless and rumble (plus the added need to feed it batteries).
And the ability to be further away from the usb port. Unless you use a 5m cable or sit close to the monitor. But being able to use the TV to blast aliens while you sit on the couch does have its appeal, doesn't it?
Post edited November 20, 2013 by JMich
avatar
Kaitu: Sadly, I don't know what that means (been out of the loop in this sphere for a long while). :-p

I looked at that one too but the wireless really isn't an issue for me unless it has other notable enhancements.
avatar
mistermumbles: For the first, the Logitech one is a good choice because it supports both Xinput (Xbox360-like) and Dinput (old standard) calls made via a toggle switch on the bottom. Around the time the 360 got released Microsoft added a new format in how gamepad calls to DirectX are handled, and pretty much everyone uses that format these days.

For the second, the only difference is wireless and rumble (plus the added need to feed it batteries).
Perfect! Sounds like that is my best bet then for all-around playing.
avatar
JMich: But being able to use the TV to blast aliens while you sit on the couch does have its appeal, doesn't it?
Maybe if had a TV, maybe if I had a couch, and maybe if had something other than a lappie. =P I'm pretty sure PC couch gamers are in the minority. Even with most regular desktop setups I don't see the sense in a wireless pad other than for added convenience for some.
avatar
mistermumbles: Maybe if had a TV, maybe if I had a couch, and maybe if had something other than a lappie. =P I'm pretty sure PC couch gamers are in the minority. Even with most regular desktop setups I don't see the sense in a wireless pad other than for added convenience for some.
Lappie + TV/Projector + Wireless controller = Fun!
But yes, if it's a desktop, wireless doesn't give that much of a benefit, wired is usually preferred.
avatar
Kaitu: Sadly, I don't know what that means (been out of the loop in this sphere for a long while). :-p
Xinput is the 360 controller protocol. When games have plug and play 360 controller support that's Xinput and it usually doesn't allow remapping of controls at all (like a console game). There are other Xinput supported controllers but they all have the same number and location of buttons as the 360 controller.

The other (and IMO better) protocol is DirectInput. That supports controllers of all sizes, shapes, numbers of buttons and so on but usually you have to map the buttons yourself in the game's options menu.

When you say primarily for platformers, do you mean 2D or 3D platformers?
avatar
JMich: And the ability to be further away from the usb port. Unless you use a 5m cable or sit close to the monitor. But being able to use the TV to blast aliens while you sit on the couch does have its appeal, doesn't it?
You guys are like the cartoon devil on my shoulder trying to convince me to spend more money. :-)

Granted I AM hooked into a 36" HDMI TV but I don't foresee myself being more then a couple feet from my tower at any given time.
avatar
Kaitu: Sadly, I don't know what that means (been out of the loop in this sphere for a long while). :-p
avatar
SirPrimalform: Xinput is the 360 controller protocol. When games have plug and play 360 controller support that's Xinput and it usually doesn't allow remapping of controls at all (like a console game). There are other Xinput supported controllers but they all have the same number and location of buttons as the 360 controller.

The other (and IMO better) protocol is DirectInput. That supports controllers of all sizes, shapes, numbers of buttons and so on but usually you have to map the buttons yourself in the game's options menu.

When you say primarily for platformers, do you mean 2D or 3D platformers?
Mostly 2D (looked like Rogue Legacy is a Xinput title since the buttons were preassigned). Maybe a 60/30/10 split between 2D/3D/Flyers or somewhere in that range.
Post edited November 20, 2013 by Kaitu
avatar
JMich: Lappie + TV/Projector + Wireless controller = Fun!
Now there'd be something tempting. Ought to be easy enough to set up some sort of projector especially since most new lappies like mine come with an HDMI output these days. Now it's just a question of money and space. Too bad I severely lack the latter.
avatar
JMich: XInput is the method XBox controller uses. It has 6 axis (so analogue triggers) and a few other enhancements. Any game that supports XBox controller uses XInput.
Those aren't enhancements, DirectInput supports 8 axes. :P