It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I was wandering how many people know about this author and read his books. What they felt when they read those short stories.

Personally, i loved him from the start. It's science fiction at its finest. His series about The Instrumentality are beautifully written and deep. From my point of view, the series are way above Dune.

If you want to know more about the man, here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cordwainer_Smith
I read some of his short stories back when I was a philosophy undergrad. So at the time I was thinking a lot about mind/body problems and what being embodied means for how we experience existing in a world. 'Scanners Live in Vain' and 'The Lady Who Sailed the Soul' have some really interesting ideas about being embodied... differently.
Post edited December 18, 2013 by VanishedOne
Yep, I like his stuff a lot, although I personally don't think it's better than Dune. But a great writer nonetheless.
Familiar with him as well. The New England Science Fiction Association did a couple lovely reprints of his work (http://store.nesfa.org/), as they champion a lot of the great old but sometimes lesser known SF authors. I'm more of a Stanley G. Weinbaum & Fredric Brown kind of guy for that period, but did enjoy some short fiction by Cordwainer as well.
After reading a few of his short stories in various anthologies, i've managed to find a copy of The Rediscovery of Man ( all of the short stories from The Instrumentality of Mankind ) and Norstrilia ( the only novel written for the series ).

Smith intended to cover an even bigger time period, but he died before he was able to finish the series. Also, some of the stories were lost.

Glad to see that there are a few people that know about the man and his work and that he is appreciated.
avatar
Coelocanth: Yep, I like his stuff a lot, although I personally don't think it's better than Dune. But a great writer nonetheless.
I concur. Smith's and Herbert's styles are way too different for a comparison to be fair. ;)

And yep, I did read all works by Cordwainer Smith I was able to find long ago and enjoyed them very much. :)
Post edited December 19, 2013 by Thespian*
There are so many similarities between Smith's work as a whole and Dune it's tempting to see the whole of Dune as a rip-off apart from the Islamic element, whereas Smith was more influenced by Chinese story-telling.. However, taking any one story of Smith's doesn't explain this very well as Smith spread his stories over tens of thousands of years of his future history.

Both feature a space guild that control space travel and whose members are altered so that they are unlikely normal humans. Both feature a drug obtained on one single planet that is essential to future civilisation. Both feature a desert world. Both feature an individual connected with the drug-producing planet who can use his powers as a weapon.who can use "psychic" powers

The difference is that these four elements are not connected in a single work. The drug is not used by the space guild, as they lose their monopoly much earlier. Stroon - the drug - is present as a story element in a number of stories, but the fall of the space guild happens both literally and symbolically much earlier, in Smith's first published Sci-Fi work "Scanners Live In Vain". "On The Sand Planet" is one of a few works to happen much later in Smith's universe.. Rod MsBan can use his "broadband" power to harm other telepaths, but it isn't a central plot line.

Nevertheless, all of Smith's published works came out before Dune - Smith died in 1966, so Frank herbert had plenty of time to absorb them!

There are other similarities but they are not unique to Smith.
He's been on my to-read list for quite a long time; I grew up on authors like Azimov and Dune and Doc Smith, as well as Howard and Lovecraft. After reading the comments here, I think I'll move him up on that list, because his writing sounds even more fascinating than I'd thought.