Theoclymenus: My thinking made sense to my philosophy teachers at university and their opinions count becsuse they understand what philosophy is
Appeal to Authority Theoclymenus: I am not a "massive hypocrite", I am extremely honest.
Are you sure? You can be honest and a hypocrite. It's called Cognitive Dissonance.
Theoclymenus: Present day philosophy (the "philosophy of science") is
utterly retarded Theoclymenus: I am grateful to science for all the benefits it brings
utterly: absolutely: completely and without qualification
So to make the hypocrasy here obvious, this is what you actually wrote put into one sentence.
The philosophy of science is delaying or holding back all progress but I am grateful for the massive amounts of progress made in the last 100 or so years due to it, compared to the thousands of years that came before.
Something can't be both utterly retarded
and responsible for the most progress made, in the smallest time, in our (known) history.
Theoclymenus: I don't understand why your reply was so aggressive :)
And I don't understand how you could read a post with ":P" in it and think I was being aggressive..
Theoclymenus: I hope your alarm bells have stopped ringing now. Do you think I'm an Islamic terrorist or something ? I've no idea what you meant by your alarm bells and you didn't explain. Anyway, I found it amusing. Philosophical types have always thought in ways which seem strange to their contemporaries.
It wasn't a constant ringing. It was triggered because your reply was off-topic and directed to me, so I thought you may have been someone else who tried to engage me in discussion a couple of months ago. This is why I didn't explain it further. I don't want to throw the label "troll" around if it didn't apply. Looks like it was the right call :)
Theoclymenus: I studied philosophy at university in the early nineties but had already read Heidegger five years previously, because I was intensely aware at the age of eighteen that one day I was going to die and I needed to know why and what I might have to do.
18? Doesn't the realisation that you are going to die normally hit you much earlier than that? I had figured out I was going to die and what I needed to do (or rather, that there was nothing I could do) before I was 13.
Theoclymenus: What does Being mean ? it is the same question which the ancient Greeks asked but which modern man has forgotten HOW to ask. Even the question itself means nothing to modern thinking so the first task for Heidegger is to reawaken an understanding of the question. If you want to know the "answer" I'm going to give you a reply which you may find annoying or a "cop out" : the QUESTION is the answer.
I don't find the answer annoying or a cop out. I do, however, find it to be incorrect. You/Heidegger are basically saying "The meaning of my existence is to question the meaning of my existence". An absolutely answered question like that is no longer a question. The correct answer is "nothing". The answer may be different if you change the scope though (i.e. what does being mean
to you?)
Theoclymenus: Philosophical conclusions are not like scientific conclusions, they do not satisfy ordiinary everyday thinking.
Obviously, because philosophy is the arena of that which cannot be objectively concluded.
Theoclymenus: Heidegger is an enormous presence in present day thought and whether you or I like it or not that presence wil continue to grow
I presume you mean the presence of his works :P And I am ambivalent to whether they do or not. While I
believe the direction of his works is pointless from the quick summary of 'Being and Time' I've read, they are hardly damaging.
Theoclymenus: As to why it is the coming philosophy I will sum it up by saying that since it leads to the truth ultimately it cannot be avoided. If you want to understand more go and read some of his thought for yourself. I recommend his Introduction to Metaphysics as a starting point.
It doesn't lead to any truth. I have read some of his thoughts and one in particular is particularly egregious.
Making [philosophy] intelligible is suicide for philosophy
Yeah.. no. If what you are proposing cannot withstand [i[being understood[/i], it is clearly and obviously wrong. At least religious people stop at "you can't understand God". This is equivalent to saying "If you understood God,
he would cease being God". (which I personally find quite apt, because I believe an increased understanding of "God" leads to the belief that he doesn't exist :P).
Theoclymenus: but I don't have much choice but to live in the scientific age and science does not bring only benefits, it also has an alienating effect - a fact which many philosophers have been aware of, not only Heidegger. There is in any case something missing from life now which was not missing in previous eras. If you don't feel that there is something missing then there is something missing in you. Science cannot access this "something missing" and so another approach is needed. Philosophy is this approach. But you cannot really understand philosophy without entering into it.
And according to above, you can either not achieve understanding or achieving understanding will kill philosophy.
Theoclymenus: Anyway, that was off topic and I apologise for another thread derailment, but you did challenge me to explain so I've obliged you.
And I appreciate it a lot, especially considering your response was very civil, despite your belief that I was being hostile(?)/aggressive. We can continue this discussion in another thread or over PM/email, if you wish to continue but not continue it here.
Theoclymenus: What is being thought and practised in the world today IS the result of a particular "philosophy", however, and it is never irrelevant to bring philosophy into any discussion. In fact if you want to get to the root of why the world is such a mess you will find the answers and the remedies only in philosophy. There are no scientific answers (it doesn't even have access to the right questions) and no fundamental scientific solutions.
The world is in such a mess because we (here specifically, you) have defined it to be a mess :) There is no point in human history where I would define it any other way as there is always something messy about the world. However, I believe we
can achieve "non-messyness" in our future and that the only way to achieve it is through increased understanding of what we exist in.. and that is done using science.
I find it really interesting that the person you are claiming who has revealed the ultimate truth in our modern era was a (unapologetic and non-regretful!) member of the Nazi party until the end of the war.
This alone makes him lose a
lot of credibility in my eyes. You can't go espousing the idea of Being, the importance of being able to question it and that technology is bad.. and then support a party that deprives millions of people of the ability to question their Being by using technology to put them into camps and then gas them to death.
I was going to end this post with what I thought was the most important philosophical question ("Who am I in the dark?") but in light of information about this philosopher, I feel better about the answer to that question because:
I am not Martin Heidegger.