It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
lowyhong: Gameplay video here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dbZFlnEUBc
Nice. Saw this game on Steam but didn't really think much of it, but watching that video I gotta say it seems promising. Unfortunately I've already bought far too many games recently, so probably won't pre-purchase it. Will definitely keep an eye on it once it's released though.
avatar
lowyhong: Gameplay video here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dbZFlnEUBc
Wohoo! A video with a battle in it! And it looks fun. :D
avatar
Crosmando: Sigh, why can't they just make it completely, 100%, turn-based, they always try to evoke MoO2 and then dumb it down to "pause-based" or whatnot.

Apparently most mainstream gamers have severe attention span issues.
avatar
orcishgamer: There's not much difference in many cases and the Pause based functionality can lead to some superior game play and strategy if done correctly.

It's not like wiping out 75% of the AI's fleet in MoO2 before a single one had a chance to fire was all that deep.
Actually, it did, because you had to plan those kind of moves turns ahead, to pull them off in a single turn/

I would make a wager this game will be all about graphics, "Oh it looks like Star Wars or BSG space battles", but the combat will be standard-fare RTS, whoever has the most ships wins, and will become boring after a few hours of play.

Yeah I liked Sins of the Solar Empire too, until I realized how utterly shallow it is.
avatar
orcishgamer: There's not much difference in many cases and the Pause based functionality can lead to some superior game play and strategy if done correctly.

It's not like wiping out 75% of the AI's fleet in MoO2 before a single one had a chance to fire was all that deep.
avatar
Crosmando: Actually, it did, because you had to plan those kind of moves turns ahead, to pull them off in a single turn/

I would make a wager this game will be all about graphics, "Oh it looks like Star Wars or BSG space battles", but the combat will be standard-fare RTS, whoever has the most ships wins, and will become boring after a few hours of play.

Yeah I liked Sins of the Solar Empire too, until I realized how utterly shallow it is.
No you didn't, during end game you could fire on your first turn with your end game weapons and "Doomstars" or whatever they were and annihilate the opposing force at their starting positions. I suppose I could be recalling it wrong (I don't have any end game saves lying handily about), but even if I was, there was absolutely no "setting up" to do aside from refusing move on your first turn. Oh how very tactical...

Look, don't get me wrong, I fucking love MoO2, it is in my top 5 games of all time. But the turn based combat was not tactical at all, especially during end game when you did most of your fighting, even compared to other games of its time, like HoMM2 (the best HoMM!). Calling pause/realtime less tactical is just silly, you're putting the bad parts of yesteryear up on the pedestal with the outstanding parts and they DO NOT belong there.
Post edited May 04, 2012 by orcishgamer
avatar
orcishgamer: There's not much difference in many cases and the Pause based functionality can lead to some superior game play and strategy if done correctly.

It's not like wiping out 75% of the AI's fleet in MoO2 before a single one had a chance to fire was all that deep.
avatar
Crosmando: Actually, it did, because you had to plan those kind of moves turns ahead, to pull them off in a single turn/

I would make a wager this game will be all about graphics, "Oh it looks like Star Wars or BSG space battles", but the combat will be standard-fare RTS, whoever has the most ships wins, and will become boring after a few hours of play.

Yeah I liked Sins of the Solar Empire too, until I realized how utterly shallow it is.
Sins is much like standard RTS games. Grab as much territory as fast as you can, tech up, build a fleet and attack. It also have the standard thing with units with various abilities and a rock/paper/scissors system that you need to use to have a successful fleet.
The reasons I like Sins is that it's not overly complicated, it looks good having starships firing everywhere and it fucking rocks in LAN play against the computer. :)

So I wouldn't call it utterly shallow unless you play against easy opponents. You have to think to win otherwise. But yeah, it's not the most complicated game out there by a longshot.

avatar
Crosmando: Actually, it did, because you had to plan those kind of moves turns ahead, to pull them off in a single turn/

I would make a wager this game will be all about graphics, "Oh it looks like Star Wars or BSG space battles", but the combat will be standard-fare RTS, whoever has the most ships wins, and will become boring after a few hours of play.

Yeah I liked Sins of the Solar Empire too, until I realized how utterly shallow it is.
avatar
orcishgamer: No you didn't, during end game you could fire on your first turn with your end game weapons and "Doomstars" or whatever they were and annihilate the opposing force at their starting positions. I suppose I could be recalling it wrong (I don't have any end game saves lying handily about), but even if I was, there was absolutely no "setting up" to do aside from refusing move on your first turn. Oh how very tactical...

Look, don't get me wrong, I fucking love MoO2, it is in my top 5 games of all time. But the turn based combat was not tactical at all, especially during end game when you did most of your fighting, even compared to other games of its time, like HoMM2 (the best HoMM!). Calling pause/realtime less tactical is just silly, you're putting the bad parts of yesteryear up on the pedestal with the outstanding parts and they DO NOT belong there.
I would call paus/realtime less tactical. But that's not because the function itself is but that realtime strategy/tactical games usually have graphics, adrenaline rush and other "cool stuff" as selling arguments so they do not use pausable realtime to its fullest.
Our own fault I guess because it sell well.
avatar
Tarm: I would call paus/realtime less tactical. But that's not because the function itself is but that realtime strategy/tactical games usually have graphics, adrenaline rush and other "cool stuff" as selling arguments so they do not use pausable realtime to its fullest.
Our own fault I guess because it sell well.
I think it's completely fair to say that individual instances of it can be (and often are), but saying it's inherent in the mechanism is wrong as far as I can tell.

And there's plenty of TBS non-tactical blunders that litter the gaming world as well, so I don't actually think it's just to pick on pause RTS as being any "worse" than TBS in this regard.
Post edited May 04, 2012 by orcishgamer
avatar
orcishgamer: No you didn't, during end game you could fire on your first turn with your end game weapons and "Doomstars" or whatever they were and annihilate the opposing force at their starting positions. I suppose I could be recalling it wrong (I don't have any end game saves lying handily about), but even if I was, there was absolutely no "setting up" to do aside from refusing move on your first turn. Oh how very tactical...

Look, don't get me wrong, I fucking love MoO2, it is in my top 5 games of all time. But the turn based combat was not tactical at all, especially during end game when you did most of your fighting, even compared to other games of its time, like HoMM2 (the best HoMM!). Calling pause/realtime less tactical is just silly, you're putting the bad parts of yesteryear up on the pedestal with the outstanding parts and they DO NOT belong there.
As much as I love MoO2 I agree that late game strategy and tactics are a little too easy - there are times when I wish I could slow the game's research down or keep myself in the early stages only where the found military tactics and strategies to be much more interesting.
avatar
Tarm: I would call paus/realtime less tactical. But that's not because the function itself is but that realtime strategy/tactical games usually have graphics, adrenaline rush and other "cool stuff" as selling arguments so they do not use pausable realtime to its fullest.
Our own fault I guess because it sell well.
avatar
orcishgamer: I think it's completely fair to say that individual instances of it can be (and often are), but saying it's inherent in the mechanism is wrong as far as I can tell.

And there's plenty of TBS non-tactical blunders that litter the gaming world as well, so I don't actually think it's just to pick on pause RTS as being any "worse" than TBS in this regard.
I'm agreeing with you here. It isn't inherent in the mechanism. BUT it might as well be because the function is in 95% of the time not used as it could have been.

Why am I arguing? Now you made me feel like I'm arguing for the arguments sake. That's not fair. :P
avatar
orcishgamer: I think it's completely fair to say that individual instances of it can be (and often are), but saying it's inherent in the mechanism is wrong as far as I can tell.

And there's plenty of TBS non-tactical blunders that litter the gaming world as well, so I don't actually think it's just to pick on pause RTS as being any "worse" than TBS in this regard.
avatar
Tarm: I'm agreeing with you here. It isn't inherent in the mechanism. BUT it might as well be because the function is in 95% of the time not used as it could have been.

Why am I arguing? Now you made me feel like I'm arguing for the arguments sake. That's not fair. :P
Lol, not trying to argue, I agree with the point, just stating TBS has a similar problem (though there's tons less TBS these days, so it's easy to forget I guess).

The last interesting mechanic I ran across was probably Clash of Heroes, ironically.
avatar
Tarm: I'm agreeing with you here. It isn't inherent in the mechanism. BUT it might as well be because the function is in 95% of the time not used as it could have been.

Why am I arguing? Now you made me feel like I'm arguing for the arguments sake. That's not fair. :P
avatar
orcishgamer: Lol, not trying to argue, I agree with the point, just stating TBS has a similar problem (though there's tons less TBS these days, so it's easy to forget I guess).

The last interesting mechanic I ran across was probably Clash of Heroes, ironically.
True. TBS suffer from it too. Probably another case of the gaming markets general lack of new ideas or the guts from the financiers part to try something new.

Hm. Haven't tried Clash of Heroes. I'll look it up. New mechanics are always interesting to try.

Edit: Might & Magic and not on PC.That leaves that out. Well I have too many games on my backlog anyway.
Post edited May 04, 2012 by Tarm
avatar
Tarm: Edit: Might & Magic and not on PC.
Might and Magic and ON PC.
avatar
Tarm: Edit: Might & Magic and not on PC.
avatar
Vestin: Might and Magic and ON PC.
Whoops. Did a "Read homesite Fail". :S

Edit: In the wishlist you go.
Post edited May 04, 2012 by Tarm
Definitely interested. I'll wait though.
I started up a game on the alpha build earlier and failed miserably (ran my colonies into the ground, I did). However, I do have some first impressions; most good, a few bad.

The first thing I did is try to rescale the game starting resolution from 1024X768 to my native resolution of 1680X1050. I kept hitting save but the change would not take. I tried 1440X900 and it worked, so no biggie. I wish it had told me in game that 1680X1050 was an unsupported resolution, but not a huge deal for an alpha build.

Then I went to make a game. I really like all the option available to tweak the galaxy format. The galaxy map uses the same sort of 'galactic pathway' model that Swords of the Stars and Master of Orion 3 uses, and the game allows the player to tweak the distance and quantity of these connections. I like being able to set these connections to fewer so that the map becomes that much more strategic with bottlenecks and choke-points. It all has all the the galaxy options folks would expect, such as: size, shape, age, number of enemies, game difficulty, and win conditions. Really, the only thing that I didn't like is the inability to make a custom race; it is hardly necessary, and custom races often kill balance, but the option would have been nice.

Once in the game proper, everything was pretty intuitive. Just about everything is click-able in each menu to interact with, and anyone that has played a 4X game will probably be able to figure it out without much trouble. Just muddling through a first game for about 30 minutes let me get a decent handle on game-flow and mechanics.

Combat was interesting. Essentially you get 3 attack phases (one for each type of weapon: missile, beam, and kinetic), and you get to choose an action for each phase. Some actions are defensive (like repairing or evasive maneuvers), other are offensive (like power surge), while still more require a hero to perform. I would have preferred a real time tactical battle format like Master of Orion 3 or Sword of the Stars, but there is a great deal of strategic thinking to be had in this model. It is a far cry better than the Galactic Civilization 2 rock/paper/scissor auto-battle method, imho. I rate it about even to Master of Orion 1/2 turn-based combat; what it takes from in individual ship control, it gives back in lack of tedium.

I lost my first game pretty badly because I colonized my home system too quickly and my planets started starving. Once I had sorted that out, all the other races had far outstripped me in production. I might have been able to pull it out (I had a couple really good systems), but I figured I would just make a new game later and do it better.

I didn't get around to colony invasion, which is something that really isn't touched on much in the manual or tutorial. I really would like to know how that is accomplished, but it will have to wait for a new game.

I hope this post is helpful. All in all, I really like this game, even as an alpha build. If anyone has any questions about some game-play feature in particular, let me know and I will try to give you my impressions.

Edit:
Looks like I was wrong about there not being any custom races. They must just be turned off for the alpha version, because one of the devs talks about custom races on their forums (link).
Post edited May 04, 2012 by Krypsyn
avatar
Krypsyn: ....
Oh now I hear good things about Sword of the Stars after it's been on sale 5 times, I'll probably have to wait a year for the next one.

Though you did speak of MoO3 as if it was a good thing, perhaps I don't want Sword of the Stars...