oasis789: Loved Flashback. Much better than Blackthorne, that ripoff
htown1980: I just restarted playing Blackthorne last night (have been stuck on a stupid level that involves making three difficult running jumps in a row which I lack the reflexes to perform). It's still as frustrating as hell. The whole timing of the shooting annoys me to no end as well.
I agree Flashback is many times better than Blackthorne, but I don't know about Blackthorne being a rip off. Sure they have similar animation style (as do the original Prince of Persias) but that's about it. But Blackthorne is a platformer with a stupid shooting mechanic and really basic inventory. Its basically just jump here shoot that. There is no story.
Flashback on the other hand is a rich adventure platformer, that has a great story, interaction with characters, real inventory (as opposed to just keys and bombs) and large interesting levels.
I thought Blackthorne (Blackhawk for us Old-Worlders) to be a competent mid-paced jump'n'run with a good atmosphere... Don't forget it's a SNES game first and foremost, hence maybe the bias toward platforming rather than proper action-adventure.
I always linked Blackhawk more to Prince of Persia than Flashback myself. Especially the hide&shoot fighting mechanic remind me of how fighting in Prince of Persia was all about learning the slash/block/move patterns of the enemies, and very little about actual "action".
And I'd rather have this kind of mid-paced mechanics in an adventure platformer than pure run&gun action fighting.