It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Toying with the idea of getting back into casual game development. Did most of my games in Java some years back, but now there are tons of great development environments out there. So I would like to solicit the opinions of any game developers on here as to what they use and/or recommend.

My primary interest is PC and Android development, but if the engine supports easy porting to Linux & Mac, that is a bonus. Prefer a free environment as opposed to something I have to license, and one which is more like a programming language than a prebuilt engine only suited to certain games (like the ancient Shoot 'Em Up Construction Kit). Currently I'm looking at Torque 2D, so if you have feedback on that as well, I'd love to hear it.

Thanks!
I develop with Unity (selling addon code, not a game), it runs on Windows, OS X, Linux, iOS and Android. It's only free in the "gratis" sense, but not in the "libre" sense, so I don't know if that's good enough for you. The basic version is free of charge, but you can also buy the Pro license for more features.

Unity is a very general purpose engine, but it is clearly developed with 3D games in mind with realistic physics. The more you want to deviate from that, the more you have to do yourself. For example, making a 3D character walk through a 3D world requires next to no coding, but if you want to move in 2D it gets more complicated. Now, if you want to get the clockwork-like precision of Super Mario platformers you can kiss Unity's built-in physics goodbye and you're best off rolling your own physics solution (or buying one).

It's not that Unity's physics are bad, far from that, it's just that they have been built with certain usecases in mind. The good news is that there is a complete Mono environment (open-source version of .NET) under the hood, so if you need something you can write it.
Unity is pretty much what everyone is using these days. Take a look at Kickstarter projects, they're mostly Unity, even high profile ones.

Unity has a free version, and it's possible to do a lot with it, but it's also missing more advanced features.
Thanks folks, I've seen Unity all over the place but haven't checked into it's distribution model yet. I'm fine with a commercial base product as long as everything I produce is mine to distribute. I just don't want something where there is a secondary licensing scheme in place.

I'll read up on Unity and compare it to the Torque suite. Since both have free versions I can try them out as well. I expect the Unity developer community is huge, given all the games made with it.

Cheers!
avatar
ET3D: Unity is pretty much what everyone is using these days. Take a look at Kickstarter projects, they're mostly Unity, even high profile ones.

Unity has a free version, and it's possible to do a lot with it, but it's also missing more advanced features.
Unity also has a fairly significant asset store to go along with it. But, that's not likely to be much of a consideration if the OP isn't planning to sell the game.
I still prefer to use java as the programming language, but finding a decent graphics framework has always been a challenge. JME (JMonkeyEngine) isn't horrible if you want to use 3d, but I've yet to find something I like in 2d. I started prototyping a new 2d project a couple of weeks ago but didn't immediately find something I liked for display.

I have also considered doing work in Unity. Of course, I've also considered just targeting html5 :-)

I'd be interested to hear what you eventually decide on.
avatar
mkienenb: snip
Yah, I've done Java since the days of JDK 1.1, and can speak it in my sleep. But I have had trouble finding an integrated game development solution that suits me, as you too have experienced. I'm frankly tired of cobbling together disparate toolsets (MP3 support library, gamepad input library, hi-speed fullscreen blitter library...) into a sort-of works framework. Now I just want something that runs out of the box.

I did build out some demos in HTML5 and that's really appealing for portability, not to mention rapid prototyping. But the loose typing and inheritance model of JavaScript drives me up a tree for complex projects.

I'll be glad to share my results, and if you in turn discover some package that suddenly makes Java the attractive choice again, please let me know. Thanks!
I've been using Haxe and HaxePunk and it is easy to use with relatively quick dev times, as well as support for all major platforms (PC/Mac/Linux/iOS/Android/Flash/HTML5), as well as experimental add-ons from users for platforms like Playstation Mobile.

Also supports Java and C++ interfacing!
Post edited November 08, 2013 by johnki
avatar
IAmSinistar: I did build out some demos in HTML5 and that's really appealing for portability, not to mention rapid prototyping. But the loose typing and inheritance model of JavaScript drives me up a tree for complex projects.
I wonder how mature the java to javascript tools are. A google search turned up a number of them. Might be something to consider.

I'm also considering targeting IOS with java -- Objective C used to be my language of choice before there was java, but I really don't want to go back to reference counting instead of automatic garbage collection. I saw a java2objc tool that might do what I want. I haven't used the Cocoa/Appkit libraries since Apple was bought out by NeXT, but they were decent frameworks back in the 90s.

And I've been meaning to say this for a few weeks -- I love your avatar. Sinistar was my first quarter-sucking video game -- we only had Sinistar and Space Invaders -- I loved the idea of the game, but I was never any good at it :) Fortunately, I never had all that many quarters.
I used Unity briefly at my previous job. Personally, I found it to be a PITA, thought I can see why people use it; just a matter of taste. I'm just pleased people are using .NET for games development.

When making games, I like to create & use my own engine(s), there's something to be said in having total control over what the software does and the direction it goes in. Depends on your requirements I suppose.
Post edited November 08, 2013 by qux
avatar
johnki: I've been using Haxe and HaxePunk
...
Also supports Java and C++ interfacing!
Sweet, thanks for the lead johnki! Hadn't heard of this one before, worth looking into.
avatar
mkienenb: I wonder how mature the java to javascript tools are. A google search turned up a number of them. Might be something to consider.
Some are pretty decent, just like there are nice PHP frameworks now with MVC and inheritance. It's the core of JavaScript that concerns me, both with the loose typing and with the lack of being able to lock CPU cycles as dedicated. Not critical in some game styles, but a real pain in others. (I do expect that to be address later though by more mature HTML5 components.)
avatar
mkienenb: And I've been meaning to say this for a few weeks -- I love your avatar. Sinistar was my first quarter-sucking video game -- we only had Sinistar and Space Invaders -- I loved the idea of the game, but I was never any good at it :) Fortunately, I never had all that many quarters.
Thank you! Sinistar is one of my favourite game characters, and he terrified the hell out of me back in my arcade days. I'm somewhat loathe to admit that I feel the game itself is pretty mediocre, with only three enemy types and a very repetitive play mechanic. But still a classic of its time, and made so much more memorable by the game's star.
avatar
johnki: I've been using Haxe and HaxePunk
...
Also supports Java and C++ interfacing!
avatar
IAmSinistar: Sweet, thanks for the lead johnki! Hadn't heard of this one before, worth looking into.
I started some projects using haxe with EclihX, an Eclipse haxe IDE -- http://www.eclihx.org/home -- back in Spring of 2011. I wrote a simple find-the-object game in haxe for one of my kids when she was a pre-schooler (my wife and the other kids were playing these type of games but their games all required being able to read), and started a remake of Wilderness Campaign. I liked that I could develop using Eclipse since I do all of my day-job work in that environment. I liked that it could target any environment for deployment. I don't remember why I didn't continue with it, but I also don't remember being overwhelmingly overjoyed to use it. To be fair, I don't know if the Eclipse/linux toolsets were really up-to-par back then, so you might find this a good fit these days. Taking a look at it this morning shows that EclihX didn't do any further releases since I was using it, which is too bad.

HaxePunk is new to me -- a 2d game engine framework might make it worthwhile to revisit haxe.
avatar
mkienenb: I started some projects using haxe with EclihX, an Eclipse haxe IDE -- http://www.eclihx.org/home
Thanks for the link, I use Eclipse at work so am pretty comfortable with it. Shame they haven't updated the setup in a while, but could still be worth investigating since Eclipse can be expanded manually as one wishes.
A few friends of mine and I are casually working on a video game. We're doing everything from scratch using C and OpenGL for unix-like operating systems.
avatar
elendiel7: A few friends of mine and I are casually working on a video game. We're doing everything from scratch using C and OpenGL for unix-like operating systems.
That's certainly an option, and most of my own game engines are self-built. I've got a dungeon crawler, a side-scrolling shooter, a match-3, a roguelike, and an isometric "big voxel" engine I wrote over the years, among others. Really wish I had followed up on the big voxel one, seeing how popular they became later.

The main problem with those custom engines is that I still had to find external Java libraries to handle some parts of them. And Java, in spite of its "run everywhere" philosophy, still proved troublesome when folks ran the games on different configurations. So now I'd like to have a base environment that I can build my games in without worrying about the performance and portability issues.

None of this should discourage you, however. You are using the right tools for building a decent engine from the ground up, and I wish both of you very good luck with it!