hedwards: That's not true, you log in the first time to download it and never again. But you'd have to log in somewhere to get those files anyways. This isn't any different from having to download the files from the HIB site, except that registration gets you automatic updates as well.
The only difference is that this prevents people from taking the maps and giving away the key. They can still give away the maps, but they have to do it manually as there isn't any DRM involved.
What's more, once you have downloaded the files, you wind up with a DRM free copy anyways.I have yet to see any evidence that those files are themselves subject to DRM as they're mostly PNGs and text documents.
What's more, I don't see you bitching about Mr. Gog forcing you to log in here when you want to download games. Mainly because this isn't a form of DRM and you've inadvertently painted yourself into a corner by not thinking things through.
HIB sucks compared with what it used to be, but let's not make up imaginary bogeymen to tilt at.
You have to log in every time you install the DLC, not just every time you want to redownload, at least according to them you do. It might be possible to copy the DLC from one installation to another, but have you tried it?
If it works, then fair enough - it gets elevated to the status of DRM-free via a work around like GamersGate or Minecraft. In other words backing up isn't officially supported, but can be done. This doesn't change the fact that the DLC isn't even DRM-free by Humble's own standards*. I get that they've dropped the DRM-free requirement, but now I can even trust them when they say it is DRM-free.
*what I mean here is that you used to know what you were getting. Even after they started doing Steam only bundles, you knew that if it said DRM-free then you could download it from them. We can't even trust
that now.