MrBoat: Without reading all the thread, I'll post my experience within the GNU/Linux systems, hope to help the OP:
I started on Linux (lets put GNU apart, it's not practical to write GNU/Linux all the time) on October 2012, I could say I've been learning about the Linux scene for almost two years.
I started on Fedora, I liked it's philosophy, and by then I didn't dislike the GNOME 3 desktop enviroment, but... surprise! there wasn't a software manager like in Ubuntu, all I had was these ugly lists full of "who knows what that is" packages. Also, my screen looked awful, I had to install the Nvidia Drivers.
Well, that's easy, let's go to Nvidia.com and... wait wait wait... WHAAAAAT?!
So I have to download this .run and... "Wow wow man, what the fuck is this, I didn't left Windows 7 to get back to DOS. Freedom my balls, I want GUIs, user-friendly and sexy GUIs."
These where my thoughts at first, I messed with Fedora for some weeks, and after having to re-install it like three times because I fucked it up installing the nvidia drivers, I went to Ubuntu. I mean, people was screaming about Ubuntu all the time, but it was also the most popular one, there should be a good reason for it.
Oh my, this crap looks like an Macintosh, I installed the nvidia drivers but, but... what the fuck does Amazon offering me books on the Start button, why?!
Is it that difficult to just give my a fucking Win7 Toolbar-like UI?! Is all I'm asking!
Ok, ok, I'll relax maybe I have been whining for everything, I should understand the linux point of view and stop trying to impose my windows user point of view on everything, I'm going to look into some linux blogs. Oh, "What to do after Installing Ubuntu 12.04", seems nice!
Ok... I'm going to open the terminal and... what is this? who cares, enter, enter, enter, repositories? yeah! let's add this also. BOOOM.
What a crap. Fuck it. I'm moving back to Windo.... oh, Mint? Cinnamon?!
Wow!! it looks like a NORMAL desktop environment (I must say at this point that I tried KDE, but didn't like it so much back then), let's try it!
I installed Mint and stayed there for two months, I was having a dual boot though. Then, I met Richard Stallman and his religion.
So... Free-Libre, Free as in freedom, huh? sounds cool! Mint is Hitler, let's move to Trisquel!
(After a week)
PLEASE, SAVE ME! THIS PEOPLE IS JUST INSANE! Of course I want to keep my freedom as much as I can, but I won't trash my 200$ graphic card and buy a supported 8 years old one. What's your problem guys. ScummVM should be deleted from the repositories because they run non-free software games?
This is just insane, I want to preserve my freedom as much as I can, but also my freedom of choice. Maybe it's time to move to Manjaro?
And from then... I just kept switching and switching, learning more and more about Linux ecosystem, I had an Arch machine indeed, and tried Slackware for a while.
Today I'm a proud OpenSUSE user and a Geeko-fanboy. This distribution is pretty balanced, it had the best KDE integration of all, a glorious GUI for the Kernel (YaST), and so on.
On my experience, many things have changed and have become easily over the last year, but do not lie to ourselves, Linux is not prepared for the mainstream. We can talk about Ubuntu (one of the most hated Linux distribution these days) being user friendly, or Mint, OpenSUSE, the new Fedora (trying, trying, trying to be more user-friendly)... but the truth to be told is that while you and me may love to read and learn about Linux, to tweak or system to make it fully customized by ourselves, many people don't have the time nor the will to do so.
You want an user friendly distro? I'd tell you to stick to Mint and forget about Ubuntu (maybe Xubuntu/Kubuntu is also a good option for you).
I didn't try Mint for a while, but as a beginner on Linux it was the best I ever tried.
PS: About the desktop enviroment... you should try all of them until you're comfortable, as a Windows user I'd tell you to go with KDE or XFCE. I found KDE to be the most fitting to me after all, it's highly customizable. Here's a screenshot I uploaded to gog on another thread (the left-side toolbar is a work-oriented decission, not a personal one).
http://static01.gog.com/upload/forum/2014/08/fc24bbc5cb0bfa98f9c2f340afb904173efa50f4.jpeg Oh boy so much of what you said right here describes what I'm going through. There is another Linux version I will tell you about though and that's Zorin. It comes with Wine pre installed :D
But I'm not a fan of it's interface. However you've made me interested in opensuse and Geeko maybe I'll check them out. Are they more offline friendly?