It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I suppose like Blizzard the company will slowly lose its way and its magic touch. Every time the key and core team the company was formed around (typically highly creative and unusual individuals) is replaced by frankly generic mass replacements it never seems to work, unsurprisingly. Like replacing a gourmet chef with a vending machine or Leonardo with a potato paint stamp. You end up with a company with a history of amazing games, probably a fanbase with good memories and a great back catalogue of IP to milk, but their only options seems to be recycling that and at best polishing it, while a steady decline sets in.

The other side of this coin is when a creative genius leaves a team with which they produced great results. Often the creative genius needed that team to balance other weaknesses or to avoid too much freedom costing them focus. Peter Molyneux being one example of this and I suspect Romero may be another.
Post edited November 28, 2013 by Fezred
avatar
Fezred: Peter Molyneux being one example of this and I suspect Romero may be another.
In my opinion Molyneux has only produced crap after leaving Bullfrog while Bullfrog has still released two fantastic games after he left (Populous: The Beginning being one of my favourite games ever and Dungeon Keeper 2 also being a great game - haven't tried the Theme Park sequels). And even while Molyneux worked at Bullfrog the company released a few great games that he wasn't involved with (like Syndicate Wars, as far as I know). The fact that Molyneux has still been more successful afterwards suggests that he's a great evangelislt rather than a brilliant creative mind.

You may be right about John Romero, though. Although I have a hard time comparing his importance to that of Tom Hall and Adrian Carmack and sometimes I think that I should feel sorry for those two since it's always the two Johns who get all the credit for id Software's achievements.
Post edited November 28, 2013 by F4LL0UT