It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I agree with most people in this thread. You can't be angry at GOG since they haven't done anything wrong. Some games can't work on Linux and they have to be run with WINE.
avatar
Stendall: If GOG sell a wine launcher game that have Linux native versión,
avatar
Lifthrasil: Which game(s) are you referring to, specifically?

And really? GOG finally starts to support Linux and you don't have anything better to do than to w(h)ine?
I have taught you well my young Padawan..
I...

Oh, fuck it. I'll just leave this here. That'll do the job.
You are missing the point.

GOG is not releasing linux games
GOG is not developing linux games
GOG is not porting linux games

GOG is supporting some of the the games it sells on linux.

Support is a strange term, often abused. In my opinion (and legal understanding) it means that you are making a promise to the customer that owning a system of that specification will mean that you can play that game. So if you own a linux system, and GOG cannot get the game to work, you can log a support request, and potentially (if they cannot sort it) get your money back.

It is not necessarily a justification of linux or a signal that GOG are all in favour of linux now (they might be, but that's not what "support" means). It's a promise to customers that they can play the game on the platform.
avatar
wpegg: You are missing the point.

GOG is not releasing linux games
GOG is not developing linux games
GOG is not porting linux games

GOG is supporting some of the the games it sells on linux.

Support is a strange term, often abused. In my opinion (and legal understanding) it means that you are making a promise to the customer that owning a system of that specification will mean that you can play that game. So if you own a linux system, and GOG cannot get the game to work, you can log a support request, and potentially (if they cannot sort it) get your money back.

It is not necessarily a justification of linux or a signal that GOG are all in favour of linux now (they might be, but that's not what "support" means). It's a promise to customers that they can play the game on the platform.
While that is true, GOG is also promoting it weirdly by saying things like "the first time on Linux!" when they're just using an emulator (DOSBox).
Then again, marketing has never been their strong point.
avatar
Stendall: I think nobody expect that when you buy a Linux versión of a game that have native Linux executable.
GOG uses native files unless there are legal or technical issues that prevent them doing so. There are probably some cases of Linux releases that no longer work correctly on modern distributions. This has happened with a couple of Windows games (the GOG version uses DOSBox instead); anything made for classic Mac OS is totally incompatible with modern versions of Mac OS X so those native versions are out of the question as well.

GOG has a choice of selling a Wine/DOSBox version or not selling that game at all for that platform. The system requirements mention Wine being used so those wanting to avoid that can do so.
avatar
InkPanther: GOG finally starts supporting games on Linux, and a whole bunch of people starts complaining and arguing about semantics and minor things...
As the old saying goes, some people will cut off their own nose just to spite their face.
I'd find it nice to have the game stub inform me if it was 'native linux' or 'wine' etc. More info to the consumer is never a bad thing.

Edit: ok it does, just hard to see sometimes. Maybe add the 'Wine' thing in the 'Compatible with' section up top?

like in the case of 'Flatout':

'Compatible with': Windows (XP, Vista, 7, 8) and Linux (Ubuntu 14.04, Mint 17 -Wine)
Post edited July 26, 2014 by ThorChild
avatar
Fenixp: Stop whining, people!
Not until GOG stops Wining. ;-)
All games created for DOS are not Windows games either. They are doing the same thing that they did for windows, which is the installation process that automates everything. On Linux, this includes a DOSBOX config file that mounts the game folder, mounts an img if needed for DRM, sets full screen, and executes the game. They are entitled to say first time on Linux since they automated the process before their competitors like Steam.
Post edited July 26, 2014 by javajeff
avatar
Smannesman: While that is true, GOG is also promoting it weirdly by saying things like "the first time on Linux!" when they're just using an emulator (DOSBox).
Then again, marketing has never been their strong point.
I think it only means "the first time a version "officially" working on Linux is sold" not necessarily the first time somebody manage to make it work on Linux nor the first time a native Linux version is released.

EDIT: Ok why do I have a ".854" stuck to my username ? Time to contact support I guess...
Post edited July 26, 2014 by Gersen.854
avatar
ThorChild: I'd find it nice to have the game stub inform me if it was 'native linux' or 'wine' etc. More info to the consumer is never a bad thing.

Edit: ok it does, just hard to see sometimes. Maybe add the 'Wine' thing in the 'Compatible with' section up top?
Flatout system requirements for linux:

Minimum system requirements (Linux): Ubuntu 14.04, Linux Mint 17, Processor: 2.2 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo or equivalent, Memory: 2 GB RAM, Graphics: GeForce 8800GT, Radeon HD 5770 or better (Intel cards are not supported), Requires the following packages to be installed: libc6:i386, libasound2:i386, libasound2-data:i386, libasound2-plugins:i386 and dependencies, Notice: game comes with a 32-bit binary only, this is a Wine game Patched to version 1.1
Post edited July 26, 2014 by Petrell
avatar
Stendall: When I buy a Linux game I expect I'm buying a NATIVE Linux game.
The performance on "Linux" (Wine) versión of Flatout it's crap. And I have a much more than decent PC for this kind of games. 3.2 Ghz Dual core, 4GB ram Gigabyte Geforce Gtx 660 OC 2GB ram.
You should address support with that (might have to wait out the weekend, though). If they can't fix your problems, you're entitled to a refund.

As to the rest, I would actually agree with you. Using Wine would be reasonable for pre-XP titles, but not for newer ones. Also, marketing something as "First time on Linux" while being emulated is quite facetious.
No matter what, someone just has to complain.

First of all GOG is still new to Linux and I have to say they did a good job so far, give them time. Things will smooth out eventually.

The fact that GOG takes a Windows game with a non existent Linux port, tests it up and then puts it for sale is a nice thing, in other words it's like them saying "hey we did the hard job so you don't have to". There's no valid reason to complain because it's a good thing they're doing and consider THIS: It's better than nothing.

You have to take into account there's millions of system setups so what may run good for some might not be the same for another.

Unless I miscounted, only the Flatout games are using Wine and both of them have written that they're using Wine.

Now if there was a native Linux version but a Wine one is being offered, I would say ok there's a good reason to be upset. But when there's not just say thanks and shut up.
It's a game. It runs on Linux out of the box. Therefore it's a Linux game. I mean, what about games written in java or C#, are those not Linux games either? Technically they are running through a compatibility layer as well. All that really matters is if the game works out of the box. Sometimes a native Linux build just isn't possible for one reason or another and adding special categories would just confuse people. A better idea would be for someone who cares to make a GOG mix like we have for DOSBox-wrapped Windows games.