It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
How does the GOG team determine which games get ported over to mac vs. PC and vice-versa? Would really like to be able to play M.A.X. and The Great Battles Collection on the old mac!
MAX shouldn't be too much of a problem as long as DOSBox runs on your computer. I'd mail you my copy, but the cost of postage wouldn't be that much less than buying here. Plus, I don't include goodies.

Not sure about the other one off the top of my head.
avatar
shaynam: How does the GOG team determine which games get ported over to mac vs. PC and vice-versa? Would really like to be able to play M.A.X. and The Great Battles Collection on the old mac!
Only someone at GOG could answer definitively but I would imagine a number of factors play a role in it. The primary factor is probably whether a Mac edition exists for the game already by the publisher or not. If it doesn't then it would require a total game port which could consume a lot of developer resources and time and is probably not likely to happen unless they perceive a return on investment worthy of doing the work (and have the legal rights to do so). For much newer games it is probably less effort to do due to modern code generally being more portable and using interfaces that are either more portable or easier to convert.

For old MSDOS type games however, I'd say it is very unlikely unless a Mac port already existed for the game as software written for MSDOS is going to be rather ancient non-portable code due to the segmented memory model of the 8086 running in it's native mode for DOS, along with use of XMS/EMS memory management, direct BIOS calls, and probably liberal use of custom 16 bit assembly language which is often self modifying code. Not impossible of course, but potentially a lot of effort to risk for probably no major return on investment. Sad but true.

What would be nice though is for the copyright owners to release the sources of their games publicly. When that's done you can almost guarantee the game will be ported to Linux in as little as 24 hours and maybe as long as a week, and ports to just about everything else out there will occur in a similar time frame also. That's all driven by non-monetary motivation though. :)

Years ago I started porting Wolfenstein 3D to Linux when the sources came out. Got about 3/4 done and had to put it on the back burner for more important things that came up in life, but someone else ended up porting it whom I offered some assistance to in the end. The original sources of that game are absolutely a terrible mess of spaghetti too (as mentioned by John in the accompanying documentation) which is a nightmare when it comes to portability. One can only assume that the source code of most games written back then is varying degrees of equally non-portable code splatter - as awesome as the games might be. :)

I for one would love to port old games to modern OSs, in particular Linux but with highly portable code if game companies started dropping more of their old game code publicly. It'd be a blast! Plus you could add new features and capabilities such as high resolutions, render MIDI/MOD/etc. soundtracks using modern synths and include high quality digital sound tracks, support for modern controllers, improved user interfaces, fix bugs, etc.

Ah, one can always dream...
avatar
skeletonbow: For old MSDOS type games however, I'd say it is very unlikely unless a Mac port already existed for the game as software written for MSDOS is going to be rather ancient non-portable code due to the segmented memory model of the 8086 running in it's native mode for DOS, along with use of XMS/EMS memory management, direct BIOS calls, and probably liberal use of custom 16 bit assembly language which is often self modifying code.
That's completely incorrect for both Mac and Windows releases of old MS-DOS games here. They do not port these to modern operating systems at all, they use DOXBox which is also available as Boxer on Mac OS X to release most old MS-DOS games here. Some of the old games use ScummVM which is also available for Windows and OS X.

I doubt very, very much that GOG staff have ever ported any game here at the source level although it does seem possible to me they may have done some minor hacks with a hex editor perhaps in special cases.

For older Windows titles another option exists and has been used by GOG to bring titles to the Mac and that is Wineskin, a utility that simplifies working with Wine to package up a Windows game as a self-contained Mac app when possible. Whether or not this works varies by title as Wine translates DirectX calls to OpenGL calls on OS X and Linux systems and is used primarily to get Windows games running on them although sometimes applications as well. The Wine project is an ongoing work in progress so that is why results vary by game. And of course, the DirectX libraries are proprietary so the Wine developers are working in the dark so to speak which greatly impedes progress. But they have done an amazing job over many years now in making a lot of games work well. For example, the Infinity Engine games sold here work with Wine, although GOG has not found time to "port" them using Wineskin.

I think the real reason we don't see all MS-DOS games and many more Windows games here for the Mac yet (and probably Linux as well) is simply a matter of available resources/money to spend on this but as GOG continues along and continues to grow I'd expect to see more over time.

Of course, new native Mac releases of indie titles can be found here already now as well. Those are actually the only native Mac games GOG is selling.
Post edited October 30, 2013 by dirtyharry50
avatar
shaynam: How does the GOG team determine which games get ported over to mac vs. PC and vice-versa? Would really like to be able to play M.A.X. and The Great Battles Collection on the old mac!
I'd suggest checking the websites (use Google, etc.) for:

Boxer - an excellent app that makes setting up MS-DOS games to work on a Mac pretty easy
Wineskin - an excellent app that makes working with Wine on a Mac simpler
WineHQ (where you will find AppDB - a listing of what works and how to get it working with Wine)

Expect to invest an afternoon learning about this stuff roughly. The payoff is worthwhile in my opinion because it empowers you to make a lot of stuff work on your Mac yourself using free open source tools to do it. Honestly, even though it may seem foreign at first, "porting" a game at this level isn't rocket science. It does not require you to be a programmer by any means. The hard work has been done by the programmers who created these tools for us.

Again, expect that not everything will work but the good news is that a lot of games will, including many available here. For example, you could try looking up Great Battles on AppDB and see if you find any info there from somebody who's already set it up with Wine. For an MS-DOS title, there's nothing to even look up. Just learn how to use Boxer and "port" it yourself. It's easy once you learn how.

It's fun and rewarding learning how to do these things for yourself. I think you would benefit from looking into it at least. So in some cases, you wouldn't need to wait for GOG to get around to it. You could do the very same thing they would yourself!
avatar
dirtyharry50: That's completely incorrect for both Mac and Windows releases of old MS-DOS games here. They do not port these to modern operating systems at all, they use DOXBox which is also available as Boxer on Mac OS X to release most old MS-DOS games here. Some of the old games use ScummVM which is also available for Windows and OS X.
I agree that using DOSbox et al. might be a suitable way of getting a game up and running on other platforms, and is probably the first thing that should be attempted, but it isn't "a port" to another platform. To do an actual port requires retrofitting the source code to compile on that platform and incurs the complexity so a true port of such old titles is unlikely as I suggest.
avatar
dirtyharry50: I doubt very, very much that GOG staff have ever ported any game here at the source level although it does seem possible to me they may have done some minor hacks with a hex editor perhaps in special cases.
That's not entirely clear, but reading through threads where GOG employees have commented in the past, I've gotten the impression that they do have some sources of games and have worked on them directly or with the original publisher, or that the parent company CD Project may have.

In order to get a lot of these games working on modern operating systems requires some serious work that can't always be done with OS level compatibility settings or using DOSbox or other emulation tricks. Sometimes the games are just so buggy they wont run at all. GOG doesn't have it, but the original Command & Conquer is a good example of a game that wont run without a 3rd party unofficial patch. That level of hacking might be doable with some games but no major changes are likely to be done that way just due to time/effort overhead. It's sad but with some games - and possibly even many games people would like to see on GOG - will require the source code in order to port it to current platforms. I don't have any examples of that to offer, but due to the nature of things it is a reasonable assumption having worked on porting some old games personally myself when source code was available.
avatar
dirtyharry50: For older Windows titles another option exists and has been used by GOG to bring titles to the Mac and that is Wineskin, a utility that simplifies working with Wine to package up a Windows game as a self-contained Mac app when possible. Whether or not this works varies by title as Wine translates DirectX calls to OpenGL calls on OS X and Linux systems and is used primarily to get Windows games running on them although sometimes applications as well. The Wine project is an ongoing work in progress so that is why results vary by game. And of course, the DirectX libraries are propriety so the Wine developers are working in the dark so to speak which greatly impedes progress. But they have done an amazing job over many years now in making a lot of games work well. For example, the Infinity Engine games sold here work with Wine, although GOG has not found time to "port" them using Wineskin.
Indeed, Wine has come a long way in recent years and made a lot more games playable in Linux at least and it continues to improve and get more and more games running. It's somewhat of a best effort type of solution though than something solid. A pure port will always beat any form of emulation IMHO as long as it is done right. But, DOSbox and wine are certainly things that I'd look at first if I were GOG also as it is the least path of resistance if it will actually work. Most of us gamers wont complain if new games appear for our favourite platforms as long as they work though, no matter "how" it was done. ;oP
avatar
dirtyharry50: I think the real reason we don't see all MS-DOS games and many more Windows gamers here for the Mac yet (and probably Linux as well) is simply a matter of available resources/money to spend on this but as GOG continues along and continues to grow I'd expect to see more over time.
Indeed, I totally agree with you on that front. I don't know if GOG has ever said it officially here or elsewhere but it all boils down to business in the end. They're a company and their primary motivator is making money so before they embark on anything they will not only need to perceive that it stands to bring back a return on investment that meets or beats a minimum expectation, but also that the amount of limited manpower commitment they might have for a given project doesn't have another more profitable project they could be working on at the same time. That's just good business decision making of course. :) It really comes down to finite resources available as you say.

I hope to see GOG grow in the future as well and start to make a large dent in the way the larger market perceives DRM, and hopefully change that from being the default paradigm. Hopefully Valve's SteamOS and Linux efforts will fight a different part of the battle of portability that we can benefit from in the future also. I think that will give indie developers more incentive to bring their games to Linux in the first place, and indie developers are probably the largest gaming category who have embraced DRM-free game releases.

I don't know how this all affects the Mac though, that one's up in the air. :)
avatar
skeletonbow: /snip
I understand what a "real" port is which was why I kept putting the word "port" in quotes. The end results are in effect a port of sorts, as in the end result is the same thing - a game working on another operating system but yeah, it's no source code level port and that was my point. And using DOSBox or Boxer is the way GOG "ports" if you will, those old MS-DOS games to modern Windows and Mac. I own over 200 games here and many of them are MS-DOS games. All of those use DOSBox, Boxer or ScummVM, every single one. No source ports to Windows or Mac there. As for Windows games, again I really, really doubt they have a software engineer on staff doing source level ports of games to other operating systems. Hell, they can't even allocate the resources currently to get all the simple, easy stuff done, namely all the MS-DOS stuff they could just drop into Boxer and sell to Mac users. I'm sure they want to but they don't have the resources to do everything at once. And I do not think they have software engineering talent on board to do source level software ports either. Case in point? A simple downloader app is still in beta for I think well over a year now or more? And it still has issues. Just visit its very own sticky thread in this forum. If they can't get a project that easy done and at least 1.0 what do you really think the odds are that they have somebody on board who is capable of porting a full blown game? I'm thinking the odds are about zero. I'll give you one thing though. I do not work there. So, I cannot know exactly what they have for resources or what they do with them. I only know what I see around here and form my judgments accordingly.

By the way, one factor in the selection process here would be just what is required to get a particular game working I think. I am thinking if a game needs serious work at the source level and if the source is even available for it anymore, then they might just pass on that in favor of something more doable. The other thing is, there is zero engineering effort involved in "porting" an MS-DOS or ScummVM title. The stuff works so often and so reliably that only real issue that could be present is if the game was shit to begin with when it was released. In that case, it is pretty safe to bet it doesn't qualify for classic status and won't ever be seen here anyway.

GOG is a retail store first and foremost. They are not a software development nor software porting organization. They are unique I guess in that they employ individuals to create their own branded installers and the do utilize tech like DOSBOX, ScummVM and Wine to get old games working on newer systems. They may also do a little hex editing to deal with old copy protection schemes, such as disc checks, etc. Beyond that, I don't think too much of what we'd call software engineering goes on there. It makes sense too. How the hell could they afford it for old games selling as cheap as $5.99 and half that on sale? I think these do pretty well for them but I doubt they do enough volume on any given title to pay for a full blown professional port, again assuming the original sources are even available.

Your example of the original C&C game is actually a good one to illustrate my point about return on investment. EA could have fixed that of course, easily. They could have employed the necessary engineering talent and got it done. Why didn't they do that but instead left it to be fan fixed? Because, quite simply in their analysis it was not worth paying somebody to do that work. Sufficient return on investment was not projected so they elected not to do it, just a simple business decision and that's that. Well, the same basic rules apply here. It needs to be worth doing. It needs to make enough money to pay for a professionally done port. I don't think there's a lot of room for that with games people wait for sales to pay $2.99 for. The oldies market is a niche market you know? This ain't a Call of Duty title we're talking about here. Something like System Shock 2 might have been worth it but of course at this late date, the fans had already stepped in and done the work. Night Dive and GOG and now Steam and others have basically cashed in on their work. Would any of them have paid for the work? Well, maybe for that game but such games are few and far between and also in this case it I forget now what the fixes were but I don't believe that was any source level port either.

Mac gaming is doing very well at this point in time, the best it's ever been. More and more recent and AAA titles are starting to show up on Steam and the Mac App store and elsewhere for OS X. It's great. Many indies also do Mac along with Linux versions. I've got more games of great quality than time to play them all. It's a nice place to be. I believe the current trend of growing options for OS X and Linux users will continue to grow as time goes by.
Post edited October 30, 2013 by dirtyharry50