It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
yyahoo: Why do people prefer movies have actors speaking instead of dialogue cards between lines like silent movies or subtitles?
avatar
Erich_Zann: Which begs the same question, as for instance the "Nosferatu" of F.W. Murnau remains after almost a century the superior Dracula motion picture, and not for a lack of competition.

When done right it can add a lot, I agree ; having Shodan voiced added to the atmosphere for instance ; but those cases are few and far between, just like the cases of genuine good writing.

Hence, is it justified to treat voice acting like a mandatory feature, or is it another case of the "I want videogames to be like movies" copycatitis disease that's plaguing the medium as of late ?
That's a tough one. You won't find a whole lot of people nowadays that truly appreciate silent films. I'm quite the film buff, and even I don't fully appreciate them all. Chaplin, Keaton, sure, but I have a more difficult time with others, particularly dramatic pieces.

Games are kind of the same way. Just like some people can't handle a silent film or a black and white film, some people can't handle a game without voice overs.

Truth is, I like videogame voiceovers a lot. Video games use a lot of true, pro voice actors who really know what they're doing. Unlike animated films nowadays, which use a lot of stunt casting of live action "names."

That said, there are instances where small studios will have family members of the devs come in a voice parts or people who don't speak the language very well try and perform a voiceover, and yeah, those should have probably just dropped the whole thing (Silent Storm has some of the worst voice overs *ever*; however, that almost falls into the "so-bad-it's-good" area.).

Still, like color and sound in the movies, voiceovers are expected by the audience in games, so the devs feel the need, marketing-wise, to deliver in order to sell the game. It's not always justified, and sometimes detrimental to the end product, but I understand why they try.
Fun is, especially in the case of Monkey Island, both voiceover with and voiceover without, it was a great game and experience. But having only one of those versions only out, is a bit... lacking. People wanting the original should be served. Broken sword got that special treatment (with both new and old version in the same package). Monkey Island; why not?
avatar
KiNgBrAdLeY7: Fun is, especially in the case of Monkey Island, both voiceover with and voiceover without, it was a great game and experience. But having only one of those versions only out, is a bit... lacking. People wanting the original should be served. Broken sword got that special treatment (with both new and old version in the same package). Monkey Island; why not?
isnt the classic graphics version included in the monkey island remake the original?
avatar
KiNgBrAdLeY7: Fun is, especially in the case of Monkey Island, both voiceover with and voiceover without, it was a great game and experience. But having only one of those versions only out, is a bit... lacking. People wanting the original should be served. Broken sword got that special treatment (with both new and old version in the same package). Monkey Island; why not?
avatar
Soccorro: isnt the classic graphics version included in the monkey island remake the original?
Not really, not entirely. It has voiceover, and the sound is of the remake, not the original/8-bit.
avatar
KiNgBrAdLeY7: Fun is, especially in the case of Monkey Island, both voiceover with and voiceover without, it was a great game and experience. But having only one of those versions only out, is a bit... lacking. People wanting the original should be served. Broken sword got that special treatment (with both new and old version in the same package). Monkey Island; why not?
avatar
Soccorro: isnt the classic graphics version included in the monkey island remake the original?
It's the 1992 CD rerelease, which has one joke cut (because it was built around the "insert disk ##" manipulation and kind of falls flat in a single-disk release) and replaces the original, all-text UI with the more graphical one of Monkey Island 2.
Post edited November 06, 2014 by Erich_Zann
I prefer the original look for Monkey Island. I think they did a better job with the newer graphics for Monkey Island 2, though. Still I would probably play it with the original graphics. I'm just old school that way!
avatar
KiNgBrAdLeY7: [...] the sound is of the remake, not the original/8-bit.
Is that a fact ? You are stuck with the "enhanced" music/sound when you switch to the "classic" graphics ?
One more reason to avoid this thing.
its amazing how everyone ignored the post that posted a mod that extracted the voice from the remake to the original version makes it have voices

Here is a run down back when lucasarts released these games , they did not carry the voice over when you switched to classic mode , hoping to keep the two modes as distinct as possible but due to the feedback they implemented it in the second game.

So the easiest way to have the original version have voices is to use this mod
http://gratissaugen.de/ultimatetalkies/monkey1.html
Post edited November 06, 2014 by liquidsnakehpks
avatar
Soccorro: so original or remade graphics?
Original Monkey graphics for the first playthrough.
Afterwards, try it with the remade graphics for the voices and the dev commentary. It's an interesting listen. :)

[Edit: Wait... Is there is a dev commentary? Or did I just confuse it with another game? O_o]
Post edited November 06, 2014 by Getcomposted
avatar
XYCat: The oldschool version doesn't have voiceacting? Switching to oldie graphics in Monkey Island 2 remake didn't affect the voiceacting.
That's because of the complaints about the remake of the first one. When you switch the first one into classic mode, it's pretty authentic - which means no voice acting. Unfortunately for the second one, while they added the option for voices in the classic mode, they broke the music. So the classic mode of MI2 is worse.
avatar
Leroux: Are you saying that if you switch to the original in SE there are no voiceovers? Personally I'd still go with the VGA version, I can't stand the look of the new graphics and it seems they didn't improve much upon the animation either, so to me I guess it would feel odd and inferior in quality, playing the same 90's game, only with a new coat of paint on it. The VGA look should feel much more natural.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks that high-resolution sprites look really strange with so few animation frames.
Post edited November 06, 2014 by SirPrimalform