yyahoo: Why do people prefer movies have actors speaking instead of dialogue cards between lines like silent movies or subtitles?
Erich_Zann: Which begs the same question, as for instance the "Nosferatu" of F.W. Murnau remains after almost a century the superior Dracula motion picture, and not for a lack of competition.
When done right it can add a lot, I agree ; having Shodan voiced added to the atmosphere for instance ; but those cases are few and far between, just like the cases of genuine good writing.
Hence, is it justified to treat voice acting like a mandatory feature, or is it another case of the "I want videogames to be like movies" copycatitis disease that's plaguing the medium as of late ?
That's a tough one. You won't find a whole lot of people nowadays that truly appreciate silent films. I'm quite the film buff, and even I don't fully appreciate them all. Chaplin, Keaton, sure, but I have a more difficult time with others, particularly dramatic pieces.
Games are kind of the same way. Just like some people can't handle a silent film or a black and white film, some people can't handle a game without voice overs.
Truth is, I like videogame voiceovers a lot. Video games use a lot of true, pro voice actors who really know what they're doing. Unlike animated films nowadays, which use a lot of stunt casting of live action "names."
That said, there are instances where small studios will have family members of the devs come in a voice parts or people who don't speak the language very well try and perform a voiceover, and yeah, those should have probably just dropped the whole thing (Silent Storm has some of the worst voice overs *ever*; however, that almost falls into the "so-bad-it's-good" area.).
Still, like color and sound in the movies, voiceovers are expected by the audience in games, so the devs feel the need, marketing-wise, to deliver in order to sell the game. It's not always justified, and sometimes detrimental to the end product, but I understand why they try.