It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
timppu: I find it natural that online installers/updaters depend on internet (sounds logical), but isn't it so that there are also ways to install software and system updates offline on Linux (like the links I presented suggested)? I presume that was OP's point, he felt that it can't be done on Linux, like it can be on Windows.
If the updates are through the .deb files (which quite a few are, just download the updated programs and install over the current ones) then yeah. You can probably right-click in the dolphin explorer (or whatever it's called for your flavor of linux) and select to install it, give it admin access and let it go.

Installing via commandline is fairly easy, either copy the files to the /usr/bin/ directory (risky but works), or us the commandline: dpkg -i packagename.deb

Lastly packages that are tgz format you extract and usually just use the install script...

tar -zxf package.tgz
cd packagename/
sudo sh install.sh

And that's just about it.... If it is source code you might have to make slightly different steps...

tar -zxf package.tgz
cd packagename/
less README
./configure install

I've run quite often free software that didn't come in installation packages... Interesting, back in like 2005 i combined the Ogg Encoder, to a microphone app, connected to forwarding the output through netcat (to an ip address) and made a free VOIP program! They just had to listen for it, and do the same thing back to me (which is listening with netcat).

Course i didn't have anyone to share it with :( *sad face*
Post edited August 25, 2014 by rtcvb32
avatar
rtcvb32: -snip
I understand you put a lot of effort into that but it might be a little too much.

I don't think you quite understand what I mean. It's not so much that Linux needs a UI to work it's more that it needs a UI for people to want to use it. I don't know anything about Umix really, but I do know it's not a desktop OS. If a desktop OD doesn't have a UI, then many people simply won't bother using it.
avatar
JMich: Cough*Heartbleed*Cough
To my understanding, heartbleed was an experimental feature that wasn't enabled by default... meaning you had to intentionally turn it on. So the majority of the community using OpenSSL was unaffected... And certainly anything on a private network would be immune to it's effects (probably).


avatar
JMich: 2) Windows can run from a live CD. (Not sure if it could back in 2007, but I have found WinXP live CDs, so I'd guess yes).
The liveCD functionality was actually to my understanding not supported by Microsoft and instead was an adaptation as a admin tool... It was called BartPE.

avatar
JMich: Either way, having dedicated functions for specific things does make sense, since you wouldn't want the function that opens the jpgs to be able to partition the drive (doubt it happens in any OS, used as an absurd example). And most of the 20000 functions are application specific patches due to shoddy 3rd party programmers (did you know that the memory cleanup had a specific if case for Sim City? Sim City used memory right after clearing it, and while that worked on DOS, it would crash under Win95. Special code was added on Windows for that case). As I recall, the Linux approach is "Source code is available, fix it yourself", which may also work.
In many cases programs that open jpeg files CAN partition and format drives... Quite often you do block loopback devices, this allows you to mount disks as files. Give it a try :) (the example may not work but is really close)

bb if=/dev/zero of=newdisk bs=1024 count=1024 //make a 1meg file
mkfs.ext2 newdisk
su //need admin access from here
mkdir /mnt/newdisk
mount -o loop newdisk /mnt/newdisk
exit //leave su/root state
avatar
Magmarock: Another issue that bothers me, is that a lot if Linux still uses command. This mightn’t be a problem for system administrators but for the common end user or even an advanced user it presents a problem and that in all honesty, should’ve died along with DOS.
avatar
timppu: By the way, you might find this tidbit interesting:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_PowerShell#Background

In short, even Microsoft understood that a console (command prompt) is needed for various (more advanced) things, hence the development of PowerShell. So much for wanting command prompt to die for good.
Never said or even implied command should die for good, that's just silly.

But I think you just illustrated my point with "more advanced things" I've been using Windows 7 since the day it came out and in the last three years I have used command on maybe two occasions.

As I said the OS should be designed so that CLI is only used for something rare or uncommon. It should never be used for an every day task. Almost anything the CLI can do the UI can do and vise versa. I think that's a good thing.
avatar
Magmarock: If a desktop OD doesn't have a UI, then many people simply won't bother using it.
Depends on their needs. The big selling point with the Mac as i recall, was the idea of dragging a file to the trash bin told you that you deleted the file, since it was somewhat self explanatory. There are programmers and others who swear by vi and emacs for going through files, rather than dragging the mouse to select stuff and do common actions.

Actually quite a few programs even in the commandline / console section have UI's. Pine, Vi, Emacs, etc. But they are more minimalistic. There's also piping options if you wanted to use it in a script. So it has the best of both worlds. Yeah they may not rely on XWindows, but... *Shrugs* When you start using it and learning a few commands, it isn't hard to figure out your way from there. You'd be surprised how fast you can work on something when you don't have to go to Start and then manually find the program, and then using the mouse for everything to click every single command, when instead you can type it all out on the screen in a single line to do the job for you...
avatar
Magmarock: But I think you just illustrated my point with "more advanced things" I've been using Windows 7 since the day it came out and in the last three years I have used command on maybe two occasions.
To my understanding M$ has been removing features and locking the system down more in order to prevent stupid users from making commonly stupid mistakes... 'I don't use this DOS directory, let's delete it to free up space!'. This becomes annoying when you want to do some advanced features, like use fdisk to repartition a thumb drive because it has a crappy 256Mb partition with default tools on it you don't care about or ever use... Or want to resize a partition... Or change FS types...

But i agree, Windows 7 has been much easier to use beyond a few hickups than it's predecessors... Especially Vista... UGGG
Post edited August 25, 2014 by rtcvb32
avatar
Magmarock: It's more of a principle thing, but yes it is. In this day and age I think it's quite ridiculous to expect uses to have to use a console to use their computer.
Personally, I think it's ridiculous to force an administrator or power user to use a GUI tool rather than providing a decent text terminal (Microsoft has partially alleviated this with Power Shell, but the Microsoft Management Console is still a hell of a mess).
avatar
Magmarock: It's more of a principle thing, but yes it is. In this day and age I think it's quite ridiculous to expect uses to have to use a console to use their computer.
avatar
Maighstir: Personally, I think it's ridiculous to force an administrator or power user to use a GUI tool rather than providing a decent text terminal (Microsoft has partially alleviated this with Power Shell, but the Microsoft Management Console is still a hell of a mess).
Hmm try marketing a destop OS with that kind of philosophy. I don't think many people would by it.
avatar
rtcvb32: To my understanding, heartbleed was an experimental feature that wasn't enabled by default... meaning you had to intentionally turn it on. So the majority of the community using OpenSSL was unaffected... And certainly anything on a private network would be immune to it's effects (probably).
Nope. Take a look here. Specific versions of OpenSSL (1.01 March 14th 2012) to 1.01f inclusive were vulnerable. Bug was fixed with 1.01g (7th April 2014), which means the bug was in the wild for more than 2 years.


avatar
rtcvb32: The liveCD functionality was actually to my understanding not supported by Microsoft and instead was an adaptation as a admin tool... It was called BartPE.
Windows PE is the official one. It wasn't easy to get, but you can now grab it as part of the Windows Assessment and Deployment Kit (ADK).

avatar
rtcvb32: In many cases programs that open jpeg files CAN partition and format drives... Quite often you do block loopback devices, this allows you to mount disks as files. Give it a try :) (the example may not work but is really close)
So you are saying that having an image viewer able to partition your hard disk is sound practice? Wouldn't it be better to have image viewers showing images, and disk partitioners partitioning disks? (Again, semi-joking)
avatar
Magmarock: Hmm try marketing a destop OS with that kind of philosophy. I don't think many people would by it.
There was DOS versions 1 through 5... Unix, Minix (Microsoft)... It's only with Mac and Windows that people got so lazy they won't memorize a few commands, yet i'm sure you know a kid who knows at least 200 pokemon names, and you'd need considerably less than that to use an OS.
avatar
Magmarock: If a desktop OD doesn't have a UI, then many people simply won't bother using it.
avatar
rtcvb32: Depends on their needs. The big selling point with the Mac as i recall, was the idea of dragging a file to the trash bin told you that you deleted the file, since it was somewhat self explanatory. There are programmers and others who swear by vi and emacs for going through files, rather than dragging the mouse to select stuff and do common actions.

Actually quite a few programs even in the commandline / console section have UI's. Pine, Vi, Emacs, etc. But they are more minimalistic. There's also piping options if you wanted to use it in a script. So it has the best of both worlds. Yeah they may not rely on XWindows, but... *Shrugs* When you start using it and learning a few commands, it isn't hard to figure out your way from there. You'd be surprised how fast you can work on something when you don't have to go to Start and then manually find the program, and then using the mouse for everything to click every single command, when instead you can type it all out on the screen in a single line to do the job for you...
avatar
Magmarock: But I think you just illustrated my point with "more advanced things" I've been using Windows 7 since the day it came out and in the last three years I have used command on maybe two occasions.
avatar
rtcvb32: To my understanding M$ has been removing features and locking the system down more in order to prevent stupid users from making commonly stupid mistakes... 'I don't use this DOS directory, let's delete it to free up space!'. This becomes annoying when you want to do some advanced features, like use fdisk to repartition a thumb drive because it has a crappy 256Mb partition with default tools on it you don't care about or ever use... Or want to resize a partition... Or change FS types...

But i agree, Windows 7 has been much easier to use beyond a few hickups than it's predecessors... Especially Vista... UGGG
Actually I prefer Vista from Win 8/8.1 It starts behaving itself after a few settings have been made.

Yeah using command for advanced stuff is fine but for everyday common tasks like installing drivers/programs or simply changing settings should be UI driven. M$ removed so many things from 8 it drove me up the wall. I'm hopping they will put in more settings into 9
avatar
JMich: So you are saying that having an image viewer able to partition your hard disk is sound practice? Wouldn't it be better to have image viewers showing images, and disk partitioners partitioning disks? (Again, semi-joking)
Access permissions. If you're admin, you are god and you can do anything you damn well please. If you're a user, the image view can't do anything you as the user couldn't, and direct access to block devices is very much hidden behind higher access requirements...

I was mostly showing though that the same file access that uses a file can access a block device. To the kernel it's all files. Your video card, sound card, ethernet card, hard drives, virtual devices (like /proc filesystem)... And as the functions are very very well tested they have fewer bugs.
avatar
Magmarock: As I said the OS should be designed so that CLI is only used for something rare or uncommon. It should never be used for an every day task. Almost anything the CLI can do the UI can do and vise versa. I think that's a good thing.
What were the every day tasks that you were forced to do in console (command prompt) in Linux? I'm just trying to figure out how dependent to console it really it is for casual/home user. I know that at least I can e.g. download and install system updates and software through the GUI, work with compressed files, change lots of system configurations through the GUI etc.

But still, quite often I still choose to do those in console instead, as many times it is much faster and straightforward there. Also as I said, online instructions on Linux usually use the console by default, as it is much easier to explain things through console commands, instead of explaining with long descriptions or pictures/videos, how to wade through menus in order to accomplish something.

I don't see it differently how with e.g. DOSBox (running in Windows), I rather edit the DOSBox config file manually with Notepad, than using some kind of graphical 3rd party utility to change the DOSBox settings (like the one that comes with GOG games, especially as those remove the linefeeds in Windows, making the config file a mess to look at with Notepad).
avatar
Magmarock: As I said the OS should be designed so that CLI is only used for something rare or uncommon. It should never be used for an every day task. Almost anything the CLI can do the UI can do and vise versa. I think that's a good thing.
avatar
timppu: What were the every day tasks that you were forced to do in console (command prompt) in Linux? I'm just trying to figure out how dependent to console it really it is for casual/home user. I know that at least I can e.g. download and install system updates and software through the GUI, work with compressed files, change lots of system configurations through the GUI etc.

But still, quite often I still choose to do those in console instead, as many times it is much faster and straightforward there. Also as I said, online instructions on Linux usually use the console by default, as it is much easier to explain things through console commands, instead of explaining with long descriptions or pictures/videos, how to wade through menus in order to accomplish something.

I don't see it differently how with e.g. DOSBox (running in Windows), I rather edit the DOSBox config file manually with Notepad, than using some kind of graphical 3rd party utility to change the DOSBox settings (like the one that comes with GOG games, especially as those remove the linefeeds in Windows, making the config file a mess to look at with Notepad).
Have you grown up with Dosbox? I have and I use the config file too. However if someone was to ask me I would recommend that they use D-fend or something and even then it can still be a pain.

I grew up with dos, so dosbox isn't that much of a challenge for me, but for others I think it would be a big headache. Luckily there are front ends such as D-fend, even GOG Dos games come with a frontend and the dosbox Wiki is awesome.

While Linux has it's recesses, it doesn't have anywhere near the mount if new user support as Dosbox.
avatar
Magmarock: While Linux has it's recesses, it doesn't have anywhere near the mount if new user support as Dosbox.
But the linux file structure and basic interfaces hasn't changed since it was created... While every version of windows is such a jarring change that takes a while to get used to... Not to mention windows 8 totally throws out 'windows' as everything was intended for tablets so everything is full screen apps....

Just for reference... I suggest everyone watch this :)
You are right, of course. Linux requires a bit more effort compared to Windows. Especially as a new user, you have to be prepared for a lot of googling and probably copying down lots of console commands you have no understanding of. Still, once it is all set up and running, it goes easy. Heck my friend set his mother's PC up with Ubuntu, and while she doesn't do more than surf, check her email, watch movies and play solitaire, she's not had any problems at all. And yes, even now, with linux gaming better than ever, it is nowhere near as approachable as gaming on Windows.

But I'm pretty sure you can install the whole thing to a usable point without internet access. Heck, if I remember correctly, you can even have the ubuntu disk mailed to you directly (don't know if you still can). Of course, it won't come pre-built with all the software you'll probably want, and while it IS possible to get those offline, it is far simpler to download them.

As far as drivers go, you can't really blame Linux for the fact that so many device manufacturers don't provide linux versions, so that you have to end up downloading those drivers. Again, the procedure is the same for windows- if you can't find the CD with the drivers, you'll need to download them too.

As mentioned earlier, aside from maybe a little at the start when you're setting everything up, you shouldn't really need to use the console much. Most programs come with a GUI, and even those without usually have a GUI front-end you can download separately.

And I actually prefer LibreOffice to Microsoft Office...at least it adheres to the standards, and isn't constantly changing file formats and causing compatibility issues.