akhliber: It's a real shame, especially considering it was all their own code, and it really was lovingly made. I was sad to see them have to stop sharing it, as it was one of the best fan remakes/remixes of any game/series I've seen.
PapaShango: Sega was probably flabbergasted at the amount of content the game had and not to mention the gameplay quality far exceeded than what they could come up with.
After reading the replies here and also many thanks for the suggestions, I'll definitely check out the games mentioned so far
1. Scott Pilgrim vs the World
2. Zeno Clash 1 & 2
3. Charlie Murder
4. Foul Play
5. Megabyte Punch
6. Shank 1 & 2
7. Dust an Elysian Tail
8. Mark of the Ninja
@babark- I was actually waiting for a 'Sleeping Dogs' Complete/GOTY edition with all DLC but unfortunately nothing came of it until there was a leaked store listing for 'Sleeping Dogs HD' for next gen consoles. So will be waiting to buy that instead.
If you have any other games in mind just feel free to post it, though currently I'm only looking for PC beat'em ups but then again I never did play some of the ones mentioned for PS3/360.
Right now I'm just going on a buffet of beat'em ups.
Sleeping Dogs Collection is the same thing as a "GOTY" edition, it contains all of the DLC, I know because I own it. No idea why Steam doesn't have the correct info, but again, I own the Sleeping Dogs Collection on Steam and it contains all of the DLC. Steam has a demo for Sleeping Dogs that you can try.
The Batman: Arkham games are similar to Sleeping Dogs (or rather, Sleeping Dogs is similar to the Batman: Arkham games) in terms of gameplay, although much more fast paced and with more enemies.
The developer of the Zeno Clash games (ACE Team) are releasing a new game in two days called Abyss Odyssey that is a 2D Rogue-lite/like beat 'em up game.
Anyway, I'll give another vote for Sleeping Dogs (amazing game, nearly flawless) and the Zeno Clash games (also amazing games, their only flaw is their overall length).