Crosmando: I just finished the second chapter and I'm enjoying it so far.
I would point out though that PCGamer gave high reviews to "adventure games" that are very casual and have basically no real puzzles, ie Gone Home, The Walking Dead and Broken Age, yet they gave a 55/100 score to PRIMORDIA, which is one of the greatest P&P adventures in modern times in my opinion, so their reviews mean shit all to me, it's obvious they don't like real adventure games they like "Story-Games" and " First-Person Walking Simulators".
groze: I'm not trying to instill paranoia towards video game news media, but it all pretty much sucks. No conspiracy theories, no "they get paid to praise this and belittle that" on my part, I just think they're really, really bad at their jobs. They are either PC or console gamers and tend to be way too partial and vocal about it, they make piss-poor reviews of video games and they always excuse themselves with the typical "we're just human, it's just an informed opinion".
That's not to say I didn't like the games you mentioned (I love Broken Age, find The Walking Dead to be 'meh' at best and am biased towards Gone Home because IGN's Greg MIller loves it, and that in itself makes me loath it, even if I tend to like experimental video games like Dear Esther and
Montague's Mount), but I also LOVED Primordia, and that lame excuse for a review rating is a disservice to the video game industry. Yeah, sure, everyone's entitled to their own opinions, but if I'm sick I don't go to a car salesman because of his opinion on medicine, I go to a doctor. Video game journalists should be experts on video games, but instead they're just some random guys that happened to have connections and got a job playing some video games mostly everyone knows about (screw that indie scene stuff, man! Assassin's Creed and Batman Arkham games all the way, baby!) and reviewing their political correctness, their "obvious" misogyny and sexism and how the developers are such cool/uncool people.
I haven't bought Moebius due to an unfortunate economically terrible stage I'm going through in my life, right now, but from gameplay videos, screenshots and word of mouth from people who are playing the game -- people who, though not claiming to be video game experts, end up being more so than "official" video game journalists -- I get the idea some of the lower scores and reviews are really unfair. If you're reviewing a point and click adventure game, the least you can do is have an
actual point and click adventure player and "connoisseur" review it, for crying out loud!
I won't argue that a lot of reviewers aren't bad at their jobs, but are you seriously trying to posit that certain games on a site receiving certain percentages versus other games is an indicator of such? For one thing, many times there is a different reviewer across different games, and they all have their own spin. This is no different than when I used to read newspaper reviews and they would sometimes include the new york times reviews in our local paper alongside our own.
I enjoyed primordia, but if I were to review it alongside something like the walking dead, or even gone home; I would have to give the edge to the later two. Not that it's really fair to compare different genres, or to compare an indie game to games developed by industry experts with more resources.
As an adventure game nut, it feels like there are only two types of adventure games we get these days. Ones that try to be really modern and change things up to be relevant to todays audiences, losing some of the charm of the older games. And ones that pander so hard to be like the older games yet still manage to fall short somehow. I tend to buy games from both camps, but usually end up disappointed in some way :( The closest have been the daedelus games, but their humor and storytelling often doesn't translate very well.
This one is unfortunately looking like the latter to me, from what people are saying. Back to playing journeyman project 3 for me!