tfishell: Yeah, I'd probably enjoy the game if I knew there were cheat codes for it, but as it is apparently it's pretty hard and has none.
What you're saying is probably spot-on but it's unfortunate as it gives GOG even less reason to pursue bringing us classic games. Personally I hope it at least sells 130 copies, roughly the number of wishlist votes it has.
In the end of course GOG will pursue what people will buy, and if most people will buy new indie platformers, that's what they'll bring. (Of course it seems a day-1 discount certainly helps.) RPGs seem to be the most-desired; I wonder how many copies D:OS has sold here.
I think people will buy many different genre of games, older games included.
Overall, I'd say there is probably a percentage of games somewhere between the top 15% and top 1% for a given genre in a given time period that will remain timeless or at least will last several decades before being definitely "outdone" by a later title.
I vary the percentage because here are genres within a given time period that just don't tend to age gracefully I find and others that do.
Many PC TBS and RPG in the late 80s and 90s were pure gold and will likely remain relevant for at least another decade.
However, I find that pre-2000 racing games and pre-DOOM shooters tend to look/feel downright horrible. Similarly, many isometric action games (ex, Crusader) tend to have horrible, horrible controls that will turn off many gamers (honestly, I was obsessed with Crusader when I first played and finished it within 2-3 days, but I gave up mid-way through the game when I played again a year or two ago because the controls are truly horrible by current standards).
Similarly, many NES/SNES/Genesis-era platformers (and possibly a few consoles after that which I did not buy) were masterpieces done by people who were quasi-religious about their craft and are still enjoyable to play nowadays, but they also probably cast quite a shadow on their PC counterpart at the time making the later age not so well. I'd say it was probably those Japanese console games that inspired the bulk of the current Indie platforming movement.