Tizzysawr: Waiting on a 50% off sale for this one. Risen was just terrible. No, not the game itself, but its combat. Clunky, badly explained, damn impossible to figure out. I'll get this one for cheap, that way I won't feel bad is combat is as horrid as it was the first time around and I end up not playing it much.
Pemptus: AN ARGUMENT ON THE INTERNET EMERGES!
No, but seriously, it seemed clunky at first, but once you get a few levels in a chosen weapon skill (each level nets new moves, which is something I'd like to see more of) and practice a bit, the resulting combinations of dodges, parrys, combos and charged attacks get very enjoyable and quite, uh, kinetic.
I liked Risen a lot, and my only complaint is that it wasn't ambitious enough. I accepted that after the relative failure that was Gothic 3 (much better than it's reputation as I see it, but the general consensus seems to be that it failed) they had to scale down a bit. However, I think they should think bigger, and without DLCs (they should be extras), and try to offer something of the scale of Gothic 2 Night of the Raven. Their idea to re-use the mine valley area was excellent (more developers should do similar things).
This time, however, I think they have taken after Bioware (Dragon Age 2) and try to maximize money and minimize content (DLCs).