Tallima & HiPhish: those are great points, and both dropbox/symlinks solution and game save manager are definitely related to my project.
Regarding Dropbox:
1) With dropbox, you must figure out where each game stores its data on your own, and setup the symlinks yourself on each computer you want to sync to. It's easy to make mistakes, too - for example, you remembered to symlink the HOMM2 save directory, but did you also symlink the high score file? If you play a lot of different games or switch games often as I do, it would require quite a bit of work to setup all the symlinks. With my solution and UDM files, you just download them on one computer & go. With community contributions, we can create UDMs for a large number of games.
2) Dropbox can't support games like Caesar 3, which store their saves in the same directory as the game data files (unless you go back in and create a new symlink each time you create a new save game, which is pretty annoying, or you sync your entire game install, which is the sort of thing that can quickly push you over the free storage limit if you have more than a few games like this).
3) There are some config files which should only be partially synced across machines, and dropbox can't handle that. For example, some games that store unlockables into a config script or INI file, and in that same file they also store graphics quality settings and screen resolution. Using dropbox for this would force you to use the same resolution and graphic quality settings on both your laptop and desktop, which would be annoying, and a few games will even fail to start if they're set to an unsupported resolution on a laptop with a small screen.
4) Dropbox doesn't support syncing registry, which some games require to really sync everything you want.
5) Dropbox becomes a pay service when you exceed a certain storage size, and if their pricing structure changes in the future and you don't want to pay, you may find yourself wanting another boat to jump to. My project is that boat :)
6) By using this, providing feedback, filing bugs, contributing UDMs for new games, you're supporting an open source solution that *everyone* will be able to use for a better future. Join us and help improve the world for your favorite games :)
Regarding Game Save Manager, this is a little closer to my project in intent (a solution specific to managing game settings), but I believe this mostly does backups and resoration, which is a manual process and in my experience pretty slow, or it can automatically create symlinks for you, which eliminates drawback #1 from above, but does have drawbacks #2, #3, #4 from above. Also again it's not open source, so the owners can in the future do whatever they want with it, including charge money for it, even charge money for supporting games that they only support because *you* contributed that support to it (at least, I think so - someone correct me if I'm wrong and I'll edit the post). I can't do that with my project because of the terms of the license of the WiX project that my project is a part of, and that's a good thing for everyone who uses it. I must say game save manager DOES have a very impressive library of games it can support, however I hope to form a small community of folks who contribute to the project, to catch up to this.
There's a reason Valve added Cloud support to their Steam service - because it makes settings and save games on Steam mostly "just work" for certain games. Likewise there's a reason Gamesave manager added automatic symlink creation support. I'm seeking to replicate that experience, but support even more games by giving appropriate granularity of settings, all via open-source code that doesn't tie you to any company or organization's specific service (it can be used with Steam games or GOG games, or games you install by CD, etc).
Post edited April 16, 2014 by MikeGC