Fenixp: Funny: You have described quite precisely why I prefer Morrowind to Skyrim :D Morrowind is slow, and that is the point: you are nothing when you enter the gameworld, you aren't hero, you aren't a brave warrior, killing opponents left and right. You are nothing. If there were dragons in Morrowind, you'd have to build and fight your way towards being able to defeat them. I loved that, I loved a game that basically showed me I am as meaningless and as powerless as all the other people in the game's world. It just felt so immersive. And thanks to this, I could be anything - hell, I played a herbalist who avoided combat, the game didn't force me into the main quest in any way or form.
edit: Oh yeah, also, you said the story is weak: It's actually the best in the series IMO, full of politics, interesting lore and development. It's just not as well presented.
But then, there's Skyrim. In Skyrim, you're not a person you choose to be - you are Dragonborn, whether you like it or not. Whatever you do, people keep approaching you as a hero, asking
your help with everything, and you're capable of murdering bandit camps on level 1. I've even killed a werewolf on lvl 4! It's just ... The game serves you everything on golden platter, and if you dare to choose to play it in a different way than being and 'epic hero who saves everyone,' it keeps reminding you to return to that path every 5 minutes.
I'll admit, there are elements of Skyrim that do suck, such as being a bit railroaded.
The thing for me though, is in any game at all
something has to grab me.
Maybe it's the story.
Maybe it's the gameplay.
Maybe it's the desire to explore the world.
Something has to grab me and say "This game is a good game that's worth playing."
Morrowind: Gameplay- meh so-so. Story- There's a plotline? Coulda fooled me. World: .. Morrowind's world never felt like a vibrant living world to explore, and whenever I tried to explore I got lost or killed. >.>. (I also kinda don't like swamps)
It might be the best game in the world. but.. nothing grabbed me. I have limited free time, so how I spent my time for entertainment had darn well better entertain me. If it doesn't entertain me, I'll go find something that does.
Morrowind was entertaining for bits here and there. Just running amok doing stupid shit, but even when I tried to follow the story.. sat down and told myself "This time Zolgar, you're really going to get in to Morrowind and see what it has to offer!" it just.. disinterested me.
Skyrim for me though:
Gameplay- Better and worse than Morrowind. Story: Maybe it's not as fancy of a story as Morrowind, but at least it's presented so that if you want to follow it you don't need a gorram GPS. World: I love mountains. I love exploring woods and climbing on things just to see a view from the top.
I do think you start out a little too powerful in Skyrim, yes. Although for the story it kinda works.
But I felt in Morrowind you started out just a bit too weak.