ET3D: When I log in on another browser, my stamp for The Witcher 2 don't show. I really hope that they're still collected behind the scenes, although I clicked again and I'm not sure what will happen now.
I had the same experience when I looked at the page from work earlier today. I had a look at the code, and it looks like it's saved to the browser's local storage (which is like a cookie, but using a different technology).
So yes, you probably need to collect all the stamps from the same browser on the same machine.