It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Elmofongo: Morrowind on PC is way different fromthe Xbox in terms of interface.
avatar
timppu: Maybe it wouldn't have been, if XBox had had a Steam controller.
Again though I doubt that this Controller will handle Arma 2, and most MMORPGs like Everquest.
avatar
Elmofongo: Again though I doubt that this Controller will handle Arma 2, and most MMORPGs like Everquest.
If you mean for using skills, the touchscreen on the middle might be of some help. But would it work better than a keyboard? Don't think so.
avatar
StingingVelvet: Yes, internet reaction is often filled with extreme amounts of hyperbole and rage. That said, there's a logical fear here that if this thing were to take off it could negatively impact games. Just as shooters were slowed down to accommodate analog sticks RTS and other "mouse games" could be slowed down to accommodate the Steam controller, were it to become super popular.
Now that I remember: one genre where I would probably prefer the Steam controller over anything else is GTA clones. What irritated me at least in e.g. GTA Vice City and Saints Row 2 was that depending what you were doing in the game, you should really be using either a gamepad, or mouse+keyboard, OR even the combination of both at the same time.

1. Running around and shooting others = mouse + keyboard (albeit even in this case analog gamepad + mouse would probably have been the ultimate controller (analog stick for moving around, and mouse for aiming) => Steam controller).

2. Driving, flying etc. = analog gamepad (trying to fly in GTA VC with the keyboard... oh my god!)

3. Chasing someone with a car or a bike, and trying to shoot them at the same time = I'd like to use the gamepad for driving, but the mouse for aiming... so I guess this needs both at the same time.

So if it was implemented correctly, I could see the Steam controller as the ultimate solution for many GTA-like games, unless you want to switch between a gamepad and mouse+kb constantly, or even try to use them both simultaneously sometimes (like in #3, and maybe even #1). I guess currently most end up playing those games only with mouse+kb, or only the gamepad, even though it sucks for some parts of the game.
Post edited October 12, 2013 by timppu
avatar
timppu: I think they are already doing that, even worse, by making all multiplatform AAA games suitable for current analog gamepads.
Yes, but what I clearly said was now this would be extended to mouse-only genres like RTS. The changes made to FPS games due to analog sticks could be replicated with RTS and similar genres due to this new controller.

As for your GTA example, I've always done great driving with WASD but I know others have trouble. At the end of the day though sacrificing mouse aim is just that, whether it be an analog stick or Steam controller.
avatar
timppu: I think they are already doing that, even worse, by making all multiplatform AAA games suitable for current analog gamepads.
avatar
StingingVelvet: Yes, but what I clearly said was now this would be extended to mouse-only genres like RTS. The changes made to FPS games due to analog sticks could be replicated with RTS and similar genres due to this new controller.
I think the changes, if any, would be miniscule in comparison, as the Steam controller is a mouse-like controller, while an analog gamepad is not. Frankly, I think the only change would be that maybe the mouse speed setting would be cranked higher by default for the Steam controller (due to a smaller area on the trackpad), which mouse users could overcome by changing that setting back down, if they are not happy with the default mouse speed. Then again, I think many mouse users have the mouse speed quite high by default, just so that they can make 180 degree turns or scroll the RTS map with very small mouse movements.

Modifying a mouse game to accommodate to analog gamepads has always been a much bigger change than this, this is nothing in comparison.

avatar
StingingVelvet: As for your GTA example, I've always done great driving with WASD but I know others have trouble. At the end of the day though sacrificing mouse aim is just that, whether it be an analog stick or Steam controller.
Me too, but driving and flying (in GTA games, and elsewhere) would clearly be even better with analog controls, unless you always want to accelerate and turn at full force only. Especially the helicopter and RC helicopter missions in GTA VC are clearly meant to be played with an analog gamepad.

And I don't get your point about "sacrificing mouse aim" with the Steam controller. You do realize that the trackpad in it is a mouse-like direct aiming device (ie. basically a mouse in another form), while an analog thumbstick in current console/PC gamepads is not? With a Steam controller support, the same mouse aim would still be there, maybe only with a different mouse speed default setting.
Post edited October 13, 2013 by timppu
avatar
timppu: And I don't get your point about "sacrificing mouse aim" with the Steam controller. You do realize that the trackpad in it is a mouse-like direct aiming device (ie. basically a mouse in another form), while an analog thumbstick in current console/PC gamepads is not? With a Steam controller support, the same mouse aim would still be there, maybe only with a different mouse speed default setting.
I think you're greatly exaggerating this things resolution, accuracy and ease of use. Even Valve have termed it as "approaching" the mouse in these areas, not matching it.
avatar
StingingVelvet: Even Valve have termed it as "approaching" the mouse in these areas, not matching it.
Yes, similarly as e.g. a trackball is only "approaching" a mouse, not 100% matching it. But it still can be used quite much like a mouse, also in strategy games.

If this kind of gamepad design would become the norm in gaming, it would have a much bigger effect on console gaming than PC gaming, and many of the changes on PC gaming would be in fact positive (like that multiplatform AAA games would take "mouse-like" controls into account from the very start, and not just haphazardly implemented, if at all, only to the PC versions afterwards).

Anyway, since most PC gaming still happens on desktops where using a gamepad doesn't offer advantages over kb+m on many types of games, I don't really see it happening either that PC game user interfaces wouldn't take into account also real mouse and kb controls, on top of only Steam gamepad controls. But the barrier between the gamepad controls and kb/m controls would be much lower in the game design phase, if gamepads also had mouse-like direct controls.
Post edited October 13, 2013 by timppu
avatar
StingingVelvet: Check it out: http://gamasutra.com/view/news/202214/Video_Check_out_the_Steam_Controller_in_motion.php

Not sold. He has to do a lot of swiping, re-position and then swiping again to do much of anything. If you increase sensitivity to tone this down, I imagine precision would become a problem.

It obviously works fine but as a mouse replacement for PC games? Eh. Need to see more.
....but do you play with keyboard and mouse on sofa? because thats what contollers are pretty much all about: Sofa gaming.
Can't say that I am a fan of the Steam Controller. After my experience with the Wiimote and Eyetoy, I have become rather skeptical of new control schemes. Mouse & Keyboard works fine for most games, and I have a 360 Controller for games better suited to a gamepad. The only improvement that I could think of for the 360 pad would be the addition of Z and C buttons.
I think alot of people are really missing the point of steam controller.

Steam controller is not really supposed to replace mouse and keyboard for those who play at their computer like most do. However, valve is out to conquer the sofa side of the house - and to do that they need another controller method than mouse and keyboard - as they are simply not suitable for that environment.

So the point with steam controller is that you can play whatever pc game you play some some extend with the controller as well. Anyways that how read it.

I havent got clue that will the steam controller work or not, but i think its nice they are bold enough to try new things. I know that i wont be taking my gaming away from computer for long long time and thus controllers arent really my thing. But the sofa world is filled with people who have used to play only with controllers on consoles - and thats where valve is aiming at.

I really it makes sense. Alot of sense.

...only time will tell how it will actually turnout. However, please do drop the mouse+keyboard vs steam controller stuff, because its not really the heart of the matter in the first place.
avatar
iippo: ....but do you play with keyboard and mouse on sofa? because thats what contollers are pretty much all about: Sofa gaming.
I do that occasionally with a wireless mouse and keyboard, and while it is doable, there's lots of room for improvement. It takes some time to get a comfortable position, stacking a couple of pillows under the mouse so that it is on correct height etc. I even bought a wireless trackball which I occasionally also use, as it doesn't need to be moved around like a real mouse does. I am not fully accustomed to the trackball though, maybe due to lack of practice. It is mainly the FPS games where I have some trouble with it, strategy games and web browsing are fine.

A gamepad would allow me to position myself more freely on a couch while playing. But yeah, I probably wouldn't want to play competitive online FPS game with the Steam controller. But for single-player games, probably yes.
Post edited October 13, 2013 by timppu
avatar
iippo: So the point with steam controller is that you can play whatever pc game you play some some extend with the controller as well. Anyways that how read it.
No one here is stupid enough to not realize that. The problem is that just like analog sticks the Steam controller will have an effect on gameplay if it takes off. Companies like to say things like "hey if you like mice keep using them, no problem." The truth is a little different, as Halo and the modern FPS will show.