Arcanum, the Fallout games, Sanitarium, Might and Magic VII and IX, Nox, Planescape Torment, The Zork Anthology, the Icewind Dale games, the Baldur's Gate games, the Tex Murphy games, the Bard's Tale (only because I wanted the original games), Phantasmagoria, Temple of Elemental Evil, Dragonshard. I'll throw in the Neverwinter games too, although for some they probably aren't "old school" enough.
That said, I'm slowly getting back into preferring boxed games, if I can find them.