IanM: BH and KJA efforts are nowhere near the quality of Dune, but perhaps not as bad as some people would make out. Dune is also much better than the subsequent books by FH, I'd recommend anybody new to the series just read Dune and resist the temptation to try the sequels.
My favorite book is actually The God Emperor of Dune. It has so much depth... Anyway, the sequels aren't *that* bad, but the writing style is so different from Herbert's own that somehow they don't feel like Dune books. But they are a nice wrap-up as Chapterhouse Dune leaves a big cliffhanger, so I'm glad they exist :)