It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
StingingVelvet: That justifies nothing, you never had to buy the game in the first place. There is no injustice where there is no force.
Justification does not necessarily imply an instance of injustice. And yes, the action is justified by the problem, which is indeed a force in the market we're all trying to support, a negative force as I would think we'd both agree on.

EDIT:

I might add that you are utilizing the same ridiculous argument that I could utilize to ask you some of the following...

Are you justified in your waste of resources utilized to go on the internet and post messages on GOG?

Are you justified in your slaughtering of hundreds of helpless animals to sustain your ability to go on the internet and post messages on GOG? (I might add that agriculture has caused a wealth of devastation, if you happen to not eat meat)

Are you justified in your enjoyment of anything, given its cost vs. the necessity of your enjoyment?

I would expect you, if you were going to stick to the argument you're using here, to answer no, no, and no, and cease those activities.
Post edited October 29, 2010 by PhoenixWright
You know it's funny how things that negatively affect corporates are viewed as illegal and immoral conversely things that effect the poor are merely unfair at worst.

Here's a ridiculous but interesting theoretical dilemma : If I pirate a game but donate the retail value to say...Children in need; will I still burn in hell?
avatar
Egotomb: You know it's funny how things that negatively affect corporates are viewed as illegal and immoral conversely things that effect the poor are merely unfair at worst.

Here's a ridiculous but interesting theoretical dilemma : If I pirate a game but donate the retail value to say...Children in need; will I still burn in hell?
If you steal a car, but donate the cost of said car to a charity, will it still be illegal?
avatar
Egotomb: You know it's funny how things that negatively affect corporates are viewed as illegal and immoral conversely things that effect the poor are merely unfair at worst.

Here's a ridiculous but interesting theoretical dilemma : If I pirate a game but donate the retail value to say...Children in need; will I still burn in hell?
avatar
Gundato: If you steal a car, but donate the cost of said car to a charity, will it still be illegal?
You don't go to hell for illegal, so that's irrelevant :P There are many things that are not illegal that really should be so staying out of jail might not keep you out of hell.
Post edited October 29, 2010 by Egotomb
avatar
Gundato: If you steal a car, but donate the cost of said car to a charity, will it still be illegal?
avatar
Egotomb: You don't go to hell for illegal, so that's irrelevant :P There are many things that are not illegal that really should be so staying out of jail might not keep you out of hell.
And morality is insanely mutable. Some people can justify assassinations. Most people can justify self-defense. Some sickos can justify serial killers.

So I stuck with the legality angle of your post.
avatar
Egotomb: Here's a ridiculous but interesting theoretical dilemma : If I pirate a game but donate the retail value to say...Children in need; will I still burn in hell?
avatar
Gundato: If you steal a car, but donate the cost of said car to a charity, will it still be illegal?
Illegal yes, but I think Egotomb wasn't arguing for legality as much as morality in this case.

As for your example, isn't that why everyone loves Robin Hood?
avatar
Gundato: If you steal a car, but donate the cost of said car to a charity, will it still be illegal?
avatar
GoJays2025: Illegal yes, but I think Egotomb wasn't arguing for legality as much as morality in this case.

As for your example, isn't that why everyone loves Robin Hood?
Nah, we love Robin Hood because thin Cary Elwes was a sexy devil.
avatar
GoJays2025: Illegal yes, but I think Egotomb wasn't arguing for legality as much as morality in this case.

As for your example, isn't that why everyone loves Robin Hood?
avatar
Gundato: Nah, we love Robin Hood because thin Cary Elwes was a sexy devil.
umm...For me? not so much!
avatar
PhoenixWright: Justification does not necessarily imply an instance of injustice. And yes, the action is justified by the problem, which is indeed a force in the market we're all trying to support, a negative force as I would think we'd both agree on.
Well like I said I don't jump people's shit about it as long as they support PC gaming (actual support not "oh I bought it 2 years later for $5 in a Steam Christmas sale fake support). I'm just saying the idea that there is some moral crusade and justification about pirating games to try them out is silly, you can just not play the games if you disagree with the lack of resale, returns or whatever else. There is no need to buy them, hence no need to try them.
avatar
StingingVelvet: Well like I said I don't jump people's shit about it as long as they support PC gaming (actual support not "oh I bought it 2 years later for $5 in a Steam Christmas sale fake support). I'm just saying the idea that there is some moral crusade and justification about pirating games to try them out is silly, you can just not play the games if you disagree with the lack of resale, returns or whatever else. There is no need to buy them, hence no need to try them.
I don't really want to try and argue any more, but I would like to say that the people I would defend really want to support PC gaming, and just don't have the money to waste on a poor product. They want to buy the game on release and support the developer, but not if it isn't going to work. They want to put that money into the industry, not ignore a game altogether.

Anyways, the position I'm trying to defend is above my own, because I don't pirate; I participate in the fake support you mention, and buy games here. I'll pre-order a game on Steam every once in a while, but I did that with Medal of Honor and got fucking burned. I blew it. I wish, oh how I wish I would have just downloaded it first to see first hand if I was going to like it or not, because it was a waste of money and I misallocated my resources. I should have waited, tried it out, tried other games out, and put my money exactly where I as a consumer thought it should go.

Ramble, ramble, ramble....
Post edited October 29, 2010 by PhoenixWright
avatar
PhoenixWright: Anyways, the position I'm trying to defend is above my own, because I don't pirate; I participate in the fake support you mention, and buy games here. I'll pre-order a game on Steam every once in a while, but I did that with Medal of Honor and got fucking burned. I blew it. I wish, oh how I wish I would have just downloaded it first to see first hand if I was going to like it or not, because it was a waste of money and I misallocated my resources. I should have waited, tried it out, tried other games out, and put my money exactly where I as a consumer thought it should go.
Well Medal of Honor had a closed beta, an open beta, day-one reviews and generally negative word of mouth. If you bought it anyway and then didn't like it whose fault is that but your own?
avatar
GameRager: There's no need to buy them to YOU, but there may be to others.
Uhhh... no. No one needs videogames to survive. No one on this planet.
avatar
GameRager: I meant a mental need, a craving, not a physical one.
That's not a need. The whole point of what I am saying is there are needs and wants. Needs are things you... well... need. The word is self explanatory, you need it, it is essential. Food is a need, water is a need, medicine for your sick daughter is a need, etc. etc.. Video games are never, ever a need, they are a want. You want them, you would like to have them, they make you happy, but you never NEED them, ever.

Therefore the justifications for "try before you buy" go out the window. You never need to buy a video game, hence there is no need to pirate it to see if you want it. Don't like the price? Don't like the return policy? Don't like the DRM? Don't like the developer? DON'T BUY IT. Simple. There is no need to pirate it, there is only selfish desire to play it without accepting the publisher's terms.
avatar
GameRager: Whatever....I can see we're not gonna see eye to eye on this one, so let's agree to disagree here.........:|
Well that's all well and good, but for many people it's hard to just "agree to disagree" because piracy is fucking our platform in the ass.
avatar
GameRager: Whatever....I can see we're not gonna see eye to eye on this one, so let's agree to disagree here.........:|
avatar
StingingVelvet: Well that's all well and good, but for many people it's hard to just "agree to disagree" because piracy is fucking our platform in the ass.
Yes, piracy has made making PSP games uneconomic. Oh, wait...