Runehamster: Then you are saying laws are irrelevant if they are inconvenient and annoying? I'm sorry, I don't mean to come off as sarcastic, but the only argument you've offered is that you might buy something that you don't like or can't run if you don't pirate it first.
PhoenixWright: Thanks for the actual response this time. Sarcastic? No, you've summarized my point beautifully, although you slipped "you might buy
something that you don't like" into my mouth, when all I said is the "can't run" part. With the internet, it's absolutely possible to tell if you'll like a game or not (unless the game's terrible parts are not shown). But what is the problem with my argument?
You said, in the original post: Good news for pirates that pirate games to try them! Google!
I said: You may buy something you can't run (either because of your computer specs or because it's broken) if you don't pirate it first. Google can't exactly answer this question for you, as you have a unique configuration.
I am going to respond to other things you said, but what is wrong with the above? Don't you think the people with ATI cards would have been happier not buying NFS Shift on release when it was discovered that there were some big problems with it? And in this case, the law is exorcising the very "might-is-right" mentality that you mentioned, because those customers probably couldn't return the game unless they raised a bit of hell. Screw legality, if it's going to screw me. No, not be inconvenient, no, not be annoying, but actually take money from me for nothing in return.
Also, I don't think the legality of cracking games is completely defined, because I am legally allowed a backup copy that would need "illegal" activities to obtain. More "might-is-right" from the law, keeping me from exorcising my full rights upon my purchases. Again, not inconvenient, not annoying, but actually trying to remove one of my rights.
EDIT: See
The Escapist's open letter for more complaints about games that don't work.
You're right, the issue of 'liking' it was from another conversation. I do beg your pardon, I'm on day two of my cold-turkey caffeine diet. I'm afraid that the issue you speak of can be legally resolved by waiting until the game you want has been out for a little while - then you can easily discover with a quick Google search whether there are hardware incompatibilities. For instance, I have all the requirements I need to play the UFO series on GOG, but I found out with the version I purchased a year ago on Steam that my old ATI card is the only
brand not supported. And that is not mentioned in official system requirements on most sale pages. This was my fault, however, since a quick google search would probably have found the answer. If I had bought the game when it first appeared, then no, I would not have known this. Regardless, it is still illegal to download pirated copies of a game to see if they'll run. I understand this can be resented, but it is better to pressure companies to put a testing device on their websites (similar to systemrequirementlab's) than it is to commit a crime for a piece of entertainment that can probably be exchanged for a different piece of entertainment without any real loss of amusement.
In regards to your second comment, about the legality of cracking games, this is one area where I would absolutely agree with you. It is unconscionable that those who have legally purchased games have to suffer with copy protection and DRM's. I despise it, hence why I buy physical copies of console games and handhelds, and GOG games. I refuse to break the laws they have in place, so I refuse to play their games. On the other hand, some will recall that many games used to be distributed as freeware or shareware, with extremely crude DRM in the form of a cd-key being used sometimes to prevent piracy. As piracy became more prevalent, the Draconian copy protection we see now became more common.
Finally, I recently was told of a service called 'Gamefly'. I am not at all trying to be sarcastic when I suggest this as another option; apparently it has a system similar to Netflix's, but with video games, and thus would be a splendid option for trying games to see if they will function on a system. And to preclude any argument here, yes, I acknowledge that they might not have the specific game you want, in which case my original post stands - the only legal way of checking is by spending time doing the research.