I asked something similar friday and here's what I came up with; we start a thread with our wishlists and all of us either post our email addys to it or get a free addy you don't mind posting. Then we can edit our lists as games are either obtained or added.
That way if Blackraven decided to get KavazovAngel a game (just for example) he could do it at his leisure and not have to play forum tag to get the info.
The only problem with this is Akwater might go broke lol
I started a thread for all of us to put our wishlists and email (email is optional) here
http://www.gog.com/en/forum/general/members_game_wishlist We can see how it works out that way and maybe they can implement something official if it does well.