It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Leroux: ...
I think what matters is the physical location of the servers and/or where the company is registered. Since GOG is Polish and registered in Cyprus with no servers in Germany they don't have to answer to German law.
avatar
TDP: Too bad Zenimax/Bethesda owns the Doom IP now, and this company even made it so you can't buy any of the boxed Doom games anymore, trying to force people to use the Steam platform if they want to buy the game legally... well no thanks. I won't budge.
Citation please? I still see plenty of copies on Amazon/eBay.
avatar
Leroux: Aditionally to GOG lacking the permission to sell Bethesda owned games and the possibility of Bethesda being averse to DRM-free versions of their more profitable games
Which is kind of funny since most people nowadays will simply take those WAD files and throw them in their open-source engine of choice. Can't play BrutalDoom in DOS. ;)
Post edited January 03, 2014 by mistermumbles
avatar
WarlockLord: Citation please? I still see plenty of copies on Amazon/eBay.
New ones? And Doom 3 BFG Edition doesn't count, since it demands Steam to activate.
avatar
WarlockLord: Citation please? I still see plenty of copies on Amazon/eBay.
avatar
Grargar: New ones? And Doom 3 BFG Edition doesn't count, since it demands Steam to activate.
BFG Edition shouldn't count anyway, since it has crappy censored versions of the classics instead of the real deal.

As for new, if you want to spend a ridiculous amount, sure you can get sealed ones, still. If you mean newly manufactured, exactly what company does manufacture new boxed copies of a ~20 year old game for that to be something worth complaining about?
avatar
Grargar: New ones? And Doom 3 BFG Edition doesn't count, since it demands Steam to activate.
avatar
WarlockLord: BFG Edition shouldn't count anyway, since it has crappy censored versions of the classics instead of the real deal.

As for new, if you want to spend a ridiculous amount, sure you can get sealed ones, still. If you mean newly manufactured, exactly what company does manufacture new boxed copies of a ~20 year old game for that to be something worth complaining about?
While not 20 years old, Command and Conquer (1995) was still new in box as an anthology last I checked.
avatar
HiPhish: I think what matters is the physical location of the servers and/or where the company is registered. Since GOG is Polish and registered in Cyprus with no servers in Germany they don't have to answer to German law.
If they're selling to a customer within Germany then yes, they are subject to German law.

Doesn't necessarily mean that they're breaking the law though. For one thing, the virtual goods are not explicitly directed at the German market, given that they are priced in dollars and the website is only in English, so German law treats it as an imported service. On the other hand, it's a safe bet that GOG generates more than €17,500 through sales to Germany, which means that they're subject to German VAT law. I'm not an expert in that field, so I'm not sure how that relationship would come to bear on the direct sales aspect.

Steam is a different kettle of fish - when buying in Germany, it prices its goods in Euros, its storefront is in German, it states German VAT on invoices, and offers German-only payment methods like Sofortüberweisung.

And aside from all that, the JMStV stipulates that "broadcast media" (Telemedien) needs to have mechanisms to be reasonably certain that the buyer is of the certified age for the medium. The burden of proof in this regard is not on GOG, but use of PayPal and/or a credit card is usually a fairly safe way of ensuring that a buyer is 18 or over, which would satisfy the JMStV so that GOG wouldn't have to restrict access to 11pm-6am CET. PaySafeCard is a different matter altogether, and it could be argued that a minor could easily access a game not suitable for them using PSC.

In any case, claiming the applicability of German youth protection legislation regarding Steam is a moot point when Valve itself obviously either doesn't give a fuck or doesn't have a clue what it's doing in this regard. Valve claims to be adhering to local legislation (I had some idiot from Steam Support call it "low-violence legislation" once) but freely distributes games that are clearly rated 18 within Germany with no reasonable proof of age. So much for "sticking to the law".
avatar
zaine-h: While not 20 years old, Command and Conquer (1995) was still new in box as an anthology last I checked.
That box only contains an Origin download code.

Unless you're talking about The First Decade, which sold so poorly that leftover copies are doing the rounds even today.
Post edited January 03, 2014 by jamyskis
avatar
WarlockLord: BFG Edition shouldn't count anyway, since it has crappy censored versions of the classics instead of the real deal.

As for new, if you want to spend a ridiculous amount, sure you can get sealed ones, still. If you mean newly manufactured, exactly what company does manufacture new boxed copies of a ~20 year old game for that to be something worth complaining about?
True enough. Not many are manufactured nowadays, which really disappoints me.
Might want to direct that question to Bethesda my friend, they might be able to provide an answer for that.