modul8r: Hello fellow Witchers,
Overall, I'm enjoying Witcher 2, however, there are some things that annoy me, that I'd like to share with you. I'm interested in seeing if others feel the same way (or not), have run into the same problems (or not), etc.
Note that, overall, I am enjoying this game and there is a lot more that I like about it than don't like.
I'll address point by point, as I agree on some and disagree on others:
1) Are you doing this after rolling/dodging? There's a delay after doing that, which has been complained about by others. While I also find it annoying, for the nonce, it's a matter of adjusting your tactics (i.e. make sure you roll/move far enough away from the mobs to give you time to cast).
2) You can access the tips in your journal. There's a Tutorial tab that will allow you to read them at your leisure.
3) You do get XP for mobs, although it's a pithy amount compared to quests. Overall, I think it's a better system than a static moderate to large award for trash mobs. As well, I believe if it's a mob you've not encountered before, defeating a few of them gives you knowledge about them in your journal.
4) Yes, the alchemy window is annoying, as it often also defaults to using your more expensive and rare ingredients. This has been complained about before as well. As far as figuring out how many of the default ingredient you have, you can just double click another ingredient of the same alchemical substance. This puts that one in the 'mix slot' and moves the default to the inventory. This allows you to see how many you have. A pain, to be sure, but it's what I end up doing in order to see the amount I have available.
5) A 'max' like you describe would mean you'd have to drop what you don't want and pick up that new, better item. Not much better than the system as it is now. What I did is just use a mod to give items zero weight. I find it too annoying to keep running back to merchants just to sell trash, so I just opted to carry it all and sell when I feel like it.
I also agree that looting should be a simpler process. Not a fan of auto-loot, but a one-click process would be welcome.
6) I'm not positive on this one, but it seems to me from what I've played in the game that spamming attacks is much less effective than going slower and timing them. I seem to find if you time them, you'll be hitting more and doing better damage. Could just be an illusion though.
7) No idea. Think it's a holdover from the first game and there's really no use for food in this one.
8) Honestly, I like it better the way it is. At first I thought it was a pain, but I find now it makes more in-game sense to have to use an item to find things. I can certainly see your point though.
9) Might be nice as an option, but that would mean a lot of VO work, which becomes a cost concern for the devs and also means much larger game files.
10) This is an RPG, which is all about story. While I don't agree with the basis of your complaint (too much story), I do think that some games rely too heavily on cutscenes to tell their story, which gives the player far less sense of control over events. This game isn't that bad though. So far (I'm only just nearing the end of Chapter 1), I think they've done fairly well with the use of cutscenes.
My 10 orens.