topeira: i agree with you, silvertemplar, in the sense the a challenge sould not be frustrating.
very VERY (X5) few games can get challenge without frustrating. the idea is giving the players all the tools to beat the challenge, giving him full control over the enemies moves and how to counter them yet making it harder to accomplish.
i HATE boss fights. i HATE THEM WITH PASSION. they are really rarely use the same fun mechanics that the rest of the game is built on. in TW2 only letho seemed like fun but i hated that fight because it felt cheap. letho had infinite vigor and could kill me in about 30% of the amount of hits i needed to kill him. he was more fun than the other boss fights but still cheap.
the only 2 games i can think of that had FUN boss fights and challenging gameplay that NEVER got frustrating were:
1) batman arkham asylum
2) The first templar
batman had some tough segments. especially on HARD without upgrading your armor at all , like i did. but i NEVER EVER felt like the game was cheating. even after i lost about 15 times in a row i always new that it was my own fault for not doing well. i didntmind trying the same hard parts for literally 90 minutes straight. it was a fun challenge.
the first templar is a low budget game and a game that does only one thing well - combat. boss fights were mirely normal fights again one really tough enemy and a few minions. but these tougher bosses required u to do what u do against any other enemy - know how to block, parry, counter and dodge and manage your zeal (equivalent of vigor of THAT game).
it was never frustrating either. as mediocre as that game is, i still loved it.
i think boss fights are nice for diversity and should give nice set pieces but shouldnt be frustrating either but the idea behind most boss fights is letting the player figure out what to do. in this sense they are more PUZZLES under pressure than a fight. i dont like that but that's how it is. sadly.
Yes, that's how i feel about boss fights too. This is why i usually don't like console games, because that's exactly what they do on consoles. I play RPGs because you build up a character and master your skills and abilities and then apply them against increasingly more challenging opponents. Sometimes they are bosses and sometimes they might need you to flip a switch or use a special sword, but i would always be able to use my character "as-is" and feel my character has options and ways to get past the fight like any other fight.
Console boss fights usually take away all your normal combat abilities and make you do whatever the developers found amusing. It becomes like a "mini game" that is forced on you. Kinda like forcing you to do the wrestling and dice games. Even though you spent the last 10 hours crafting a brand new sword , but now you're blocked from progessing because you can't win a dice game ....