With those out of the way, I want to bring forward my own minor squabbles about the game, likely not shared in opinion by others. These are getting quite nitpicky, so you may want to avoid them.
--------------------------------------------
Personal Hopes Overhaul the Inventory and Crafting: I feel the most unnecessary part of both Witcher games is screwing around with the inventory. Neither inventory system adds much to the game, and it might be one part where TW2 fared worse than the first game. I think a category called "junk" emphasizes that point well enough. The problem is that the systems in which you use items is entirely automated. Sure, you can choose certain ingredients to use in potions, but besides making sure quest items don't get gobbled up, why would you want to? The choice is utterly meaningless in the long term and carrying around the items is a chore. At least in other games it's sorted through dungeon delving, here it's just robbing people's stuff (which REALLY breaks the story's core). That needs to be amended, because it's simply ridiculous.
Here's my proposed solution: Up the effects items have, and increase the rarity. Mindlessly picking up plants, even when you don't mean to is just boring, and doesn't make you feel like you're being clever in the world no matter how well planted the herbs are. Make each individual herb, token, ingredient, etc. worth a lot more than it is. Not in economy standards, but in how it affects minute to minute play. Celandine could give a certain affect while other plants another. Why use Blue Meteorite Ore over Red? Describe the potency on the ingredient, rather than making entirely separate crafting tables. By allowing us less direction in how we go about making our items and using them, the game truly becomes unique in its gamepaly experiences. I stated earlier that potions can define a playstyle, and how better to emphasize that than with slight tweaks to how you make potions?
By increasing the rarity, you also don't have to resort to throwing heaps of items around just to make sure the player has stock. Instead, the player learns early that items don't come easy, and is more protective of each oren they make towards their eventual goal. It also breaks the effect of raiding people's houses, and makes each item all the more enjoyable to receive in the first place. I feel that this is simply necessary in order to sustain the game's true feel, because otherwise we'll simply keep seeing inventory as a chore. Given that its very nature is tied in with being a Witcher, that's not a good thing.
Preach What You Promise: I find this one funny, because I got a lot more from this game than I was expecting, but still not what I seemed to be most looking forward to. I will point you to this:
The first video on TW2 I ever saw (Posted by Benzaie of That Guy With the Glasses). not only did it sell me on the stealth aspect (we know how that turned out), it also promised to have no 'cardboard cutouts' as the presenter calls it. Meaning that we could go to anywhere in the castle, taking the right routes. While those aren't the exact words out of his mouth, more along the lines of "You will be able to be around this castle at some point", it always stuck out to me because the implication was that I would be able to flaunt about on top of that bridge which they showed with the unhinged camera. Take what you will of that, but I found it to be less than honest.
The second, definite lie they told, was in a video I cannot find readily. But the claim in the video was that boss fights (specifically the Kayran) had multiple 'hidden endings' to take them down. We all know there is only one way to skin a Kayran, and none of the other bosses had even the remotest cinematic element where something could change. This is a perfect place where I could bring up using your elements more diversely in the world again. I doubt it was a struggle of figuring out HOW to do multiple endings as it was a matter of budget, but it was a promised feature for something that looked very cool at the time. However, no harm no foul, and I certainly won't get miffed over a few missed promises. Understanding how the game and engine functions now, the devs should be able to project exactly what they are capable of in their time.
Feel Free to Leave Things Open-Ended: The first Witcher had the benefit of being rather condensed and less epic, which in turn helped it evaluate the smaller things that affected Geralt. Since TW2 is about political upheaval, it needed to be bigger, and ultimately that meant more sprawling. The biggest thing I want to emphasize with this point is that not everything has to be resolved. That was what really stuck about the ending of the game, more than anything else. The fight will still continue, the world is still in flux, and your decisions will have greater ramifications. Don't be confined to resolving everything in TW3, even if you intended the story to be a trilogy. Like I mentioned before, the ambiguity is one of the most defining things about The Witcher series, in all of its forms. Not every little action needs to see consequence immediately, and the Nilfgaardian War shouldn't just be done with in one game.
This is a section where open-world could help the most. Your actions don't have to have an immediate affect because you can cross wide areas of the world without it immediately needing to. This concept is especially great for sidequests. I found it jarring that I would meet the people I was recommended to arm wrestle or play dice poker with in Act 1 in Act 2 without fail. That much is amended when there's more places to visit, and it becomes more circumstantial than perfectly plotted. Not having things be so tight is good when it comes to emerging characters and a growing world. This approach can open up a lot more options, and make those options easier to resolve in the future.
More Divergent Character Moments (But Better): I gotta say, the opening to Act 2 was perfect (at least on Roche's side) save for one detail: Fighting as another character. It's absolute tripe that you have to limit yourself to a single sword move and blocking for that section. We shouldn't be mirroring Geralt here, but give us at least the mobility that enemies receive in the game. These moments of taking over other characters,
especially with dialogue moments, was a perfect way to show a new perspective without being forced into it for too long. One of the greatest pieces of story-telling in games is in FF7 where you flashback to fight along Sephiroth, the main antagonist. It helps establish his character through mechanics, and overall strengthens your impressions because of it. Henselt and Saskia are introduced in a similar fashion and benefit brilliantly.
However, the same cannot be said for Auckes and Serrit. Not only is no effort made to establish their character, but the gameplay sections you play through are a whole heap of missed opportunity. Not only can you FAIL those sections without seeing the ending, but the game completely squanders the intriguing concept of recreating moment from an outside perspective (and fighting yourself!). There was a lot that could have been done which simply wasn't properly evaluated, and ultimately turned out to be an exposition device. I wish that things wouldn't be put in the game when they're only half-baked, I think is the salient point here, and probably a better point than the one I highlight. Tone down the scale if you have to, but don't drag the game to a halt.
Accessible Lore: I don't mean this so much in terms of explanation, but in terms of actually being able to learn about the world in more than dialogue. Primarily, books. Books cost too damn much in this game, are uninteresting to read, and waste time you could be discovering the world with. This is a section where Elder Scrolls does brilliantly. You discover books throughout the world, and they feel substantial (again, an Inventory problem) so you hope to read them. Occasionally they give benefits, contextualize history, and are generally just neat to look at. This is a cheap and fun way to increase the amount of information you can portray to fans, so why not open up that option? It's literally just making your books a bit larger and putting more words into the. Master Dandelion would appreciate.
Change that Ploughing Font!: This relates to the above, but
GAHHHHH the non-world aesthetics are terrible! I don't know what it is about such talented artists that leave the rest of the player experience so drab, but it feels like a slog even to look at these things! I'm not saying to change the font or style in basic user interface and subtitles. Those are nice and easy to read. With flavor text though, you need something better. Get your 2D artists to work on a more fanciful UI, because it's way too clean.
--------------------------------------
Well, that took damned long. Probably missed a few things, but I'll end it there. What else are you hoping to see improved in TW3? Do you agree with the broader statements made? as always, discuss below, and happy monster hunting!
(I am sorry for this being so long!)