Disappointing. Saved by user content.
Maybe I wouldn't have been so disappointed with this one, back in the day, if it'd been done by someone other than Bioware, the makers of Baldur's Gate 2.
It utterly fails to stand up to Baldur's Gate 2, because there's no real attempt to put any emotion into the story. And it's just you and maybe one NPC, who simply falls short (very short) of the sort of personality you can expect from a BG2 group NPC. It's really just kill, kill, kill.
So what if you liked the Icewind Dale series (which lacked the BG banter and was about monster slaughter?) Neverwinter falls short of that too, because you've only got two characters (only one of which you made.) Compared to Icewind, there's next to no tactics or strategy or through. Without the need to manage a six-person party, in 99% of the battles, you just click on the enemy and go get a sandwich, especially if you're a fighter who's just going to auto-hack the enemy whether you're watching or not.
One more thing; this came out at about the same time as Morrowind. Er, what? That's horrible. It looks downright ugly compared to Morrowind (might as well have stuck with BG graphics) and even outdoor areas are like rooms. No open world like Morrowind.
Also, while it's possible to play Dungeons and Dragons with only one or two characters, I really feel the system is set up for a group of well-rounded characters of different abilities. Mage, cleric, fighter, thief. 2 people just feels... stunted. I suppose you can multi-class your own guy but then you still have to just take what you get from the NPCs you find.
Anyway, why am I not giving this one star, with all this griping? User-made modules/adventures. Some of them are actually well written, and made the most of the engine. Worth the price just for those -- some were more professional, deeper, and better-written by far than the main quest (some even allow full groups that DO banter.) There's enough there to keep you busy, well, forever, if you can sort out the good from the bad.
54 gamers found this review helpful