It Should Have Been Great
Mixing together elements of Lovecraft's Call of Cthulhu short story and his Shadow Over Innsmouth novella, the game is played from the first person as you explore Innsmouth and the surrounding areas. You need to look for clues using things such a journals, newspaper articles and even NPC conversations. This "detective-ing" part of the game works really well and feels very organic.
The stealth is pretty basic; basically, stay crouched, stay in the shadows and you can creep right up to an enemy and they will remain unaware of you, unless you're directly in front of them. Combat in Cthulhu is terrible! If you're too close to an enemy, weapons simply will not damage them. Also, what may kill one enemy may not necessarily work on another enemy of the same kind. Add to that that reloading takes an absolute age regardless of weapon and you have a recipe for very frustrating battles.
The game does an amazing job of conveying the fear, dread and despair of Lovecraft's writing. You really feel Jack's fear as the game is legitimately spooky. The writing is top notch. All the characters are well formed and the reasons for Innsmouth being as weird and creepy as it is is really well conveyed.
Controlling Jack is rather frustrating. Standing half a room away from a door and hitting the action button will open it, but to talk to another character you basically need to be standing on top of them.
It's a huge shame as this could have been an amazing game. Originally planned as a PC game, publisher Bethesda forced Developer Headfirst Productions to change to the original X-Box halfway through development.
Unfortunately, all this means the game is hard to recommend, even for the most dedicated of Cthulhu devotees.
5 gamers found this review helpful