Backwards puzzles breaks the game
Been playing adventure games since Zak McKracken and have had a lot of fun with the genre through the years. Resonance drew me in immediatly with its pixelated graphics and scifi story, but it left me feeling a bit dissatisfied. Sometimes I laughed, sometimes I was amused but unfortunately too much time was spent being annoyed.
I loved the game for the atmosphere, the setup and the nice looking retro-pixelated graphical style. Not to mention the musical score, which is great too. But on the other hand you have puzzles that are so far-fetched and illogical that you don't need to be very impatient to turn to walkthroughs (or just turn it off). The former Lucasarts alumni Ron Gilbert often talked about the bad practice of backwards puzzles. Puzzles where you find the item you need long before you discover the actual puzzle. This game is full of them, and some items sit in your inventory a looong time before they're supposed to be used.
Another thing I found annoying was the pixel hunting. In some locations there's no hint whatsoever that you can find an item in a particular place, both because you're not looking for the item (because it belongs to a backwards puzzle), but also because you have no idea the item could actually be in that particular place. It's rather lazy game design that haven't been thought through.
And that's a shame since one of the pillars of a good adventure game is the puzzles. The other pillar, story and dialogue, ranges from ok to good. I really like the scifi plot and the touch of conspiracy theory sprinkled on top made the game enjoyable between the puzzles. There's other well executed ideas as well. Having four controllable characters works just as well, if not better, than in Maniac Mansion. And the short and long-term memory inventories work much better than anticipated and are quite fun to play with.
But the arbitrarily designed puzzles is what makes or breaks this game. Only you know if you can take that.
12 gamers found this review helpful