It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I've recently been playing a couple of fan-made games based on the Babylon 5 series - "I've Found Her" and "The Babylon Project." I'm pretty much able to enjoy these games, but I can't help but wonder if it would be possible to make the in-game graphics (in any game based on B5) look more like the CGI scenes in the original show?

I don't have much of a clue about this topic in general. I think the CGI was made using a somewhat lower resolution (720x480 or something) than what is common for PC games today. Still, I think even the 20 year-old CGI from season 1 somehow looks more appealing than these games. The 3D models, colours, lights and shadows look better, for some reason.

Can anyone shed some light on this issue? Please keep in mind that I'm pretty much clueless about the technical aspects here.
I think they used Comodore Amiga's with Lightwave or Videotoaster for Babylon 5 but that's about it. =P
The TV show had an estimated $500,000 (per episode) budget. ~ 41 credited people in just visual effects credits and farmed (part or most) of the work to Foundation Imaging a visual effects studio. This may mean that some of the effects are created with LightWave 3D on Video Toaster workstations, which means that the work was completed in analog as opposed to digital and then converted for TV. Don't know if that contributes all that much, but basically well paid professionals using professional equipment.

Fan based games I assume are just a hobby and can make no money without getting into trouble, so there is no profit incentive. The probably just put together what they can in the time they allot themselves. And they probably could make the games look way nicer, but it all a matter of time, manpower, skill, and lack of money.

hope this answers your question
avatar
Strijkbout: I think they used Comodore Amiga's with Lightwave or Videotoaster for Babylon 5 but that's about it. =P
Yes, the CGI was done on Amigas, at least in the early seasons.
avatar
Chimerical: The TV show had an estimated $500,000 (per episode) budget. ~ 41 credited people in just visual effects credits and farmed (part or most) of the work to Foundation Imaging a visual effects studio. This may mean that some of the effects are created with LightWave 3D on Video Toaster workstations, which means that the work was completed in analog as opposed to digital and then converted for TV. Don't know if that contributes all that much, but basically well paid professionals using professional equipment.

Fan based games I assume are just a hobby and can make no money without getting into trouble, so there is no profit incentive. The probably just put together what they can in the time they allot themselves. And they probably could make the games look way nicer, but it all a matter of time, manpower, skill, and lack of money.

hope this answers your question
Thanks. It might be part of the answer, I don't know. Still, season 1 was aired in 1993-94... I just think it would be cool if there was a game which could resemble the smooth CGI from the show. It would have been magic. Some effects might look better in some games today (some early close-up shots didn't always come out good in the show, IMO), but my overall impression is that the show still looks better in some ways.
Post edited November 18, 2013 by Primate
avatar
Chimerical:
Great fan site dedicated to the FX and design side of things on B5 www.themadgoner.com/B5/B5Scrolls/B5Scrolls.htm
avatar
Primate:
Post edited November 18, 2013 by Sachys
Man, I haven't watched that show in ages. Was Ivanova involved in these PC games? I may have to give them a looksey.
Basically there are three problems:

1: Quality of the textures/models. No reason they can't be high quality, but it takes skill and time. This is probably the biggest issue.

2: Qualily and type of filters, lighting, environment, camera direction. This is complicated because it isn't obvious what needs to be done (unlike the above), but even the best models won't look good if the environment isn't right. For example, how did B6 handle shadows or lense flare?

3: Ray tracing. These days this is less significant, but is a fundamental difference to film/tv and games. Games draw various objects (floor, wall, bad guy) on the screen, then apply some effects, because this is quicker to do than ray tracing. In ray tracing you divide the screen into pixels then follow the light for each pixel. Every time you hit a surface you calcluate the scatter and other impacts the surface has and keep going untill you hit deep space. This is great at giving reflections, shadows and all these other real world effects but is generally too slow for a computer to calculate while you are playing a game.
On the topic of ray tracing, there's a version of Quake III that renders using ray tracing: http://www.q3rt.de/

Never used it, but looks interesting.

(and when the hell is GOG getting Quake?)
avatar
qux: On the topic of ray tracing, there's a version of Quake III that renders using ray tracing: http://www.q3rt.de/

Never used it, but looks interesting.

(and when the hell is GOG getting Quake?)
Since Quake is made by Id which is now owned by Zenimax I would say around the time we see any Elder Scrolls (not looking likely as all under Zenimax (Id, Bethesda & others) thinks Steam is PC gaming at the moment)
avatar
_Bruce_: Basically there are three problems:

1: Quality of the textures/models. No reason they can't be high quality, but it takes skill and time. This is probably the biggest issue.

2: Qualily and type of filters, lighting, environment, camera direction. This is complicated because it isn't obvious what needs to be done (unlike the above), but even the best models won't look good if the environment isn't right. For example, how did B6 handle shadows or lense flare?

3: Ray tracing. These days this is less significant, but is a fundamental difference to film/tv and games. Games draw various objects (floor, wall, bad guy) on the screen, then apply some effects, because this is quicker to do than ray tracing. In ray tracing you divide the screen into pixels then follow the light for each pixel. Every time you hit a surface you calcluate the scatter and other impacts the surface has and keep going untill you hit deep space. This is great at giving reflections, shadows and all these other real world effects but is generally too slow for a computer to calculate while you are playing a game.
I think 1 is probably the biggest bit. The software necessary to do this is relatively easy to get. The Matrix itself was rendered on a FreeBSD rendering farm, you could probably get that kind of processing power for not a huge amount of money these days. A single quad core computer could probably replace several of the machines they used.

EDIT: They used 32 450mhz dual processor computers for the rendering.
Post edited November 19, 2013 by hedwards
avatar
_Bruce_: Basically there are three problems:

1: Quality of the textures/models. No reason they can't be high quality, but it takes skill and time. This is probably the biggest issue.

2: Qualily and type of filters, lighting, environment, camera direction. This is complicated because it isn't obvious what needs to be done (unlike the above), but even the best models won't look good if the environment isn't right. For example, how did B6 handle shadows or lense flare?

3: Ray tracing. These days this is less significant, but is a fundamental difference to film/tv and games. Games draw various objects (floor, wall, bad guy) on the screen, then apply some effects, because this is quicker to do than ray tracing. In ray tracing you divide the screen into pixels then follow the light for each pixel. Every time you hit a surface you calcluate the scatter and other impacts the surface has and keep going untill you hit deep space. This is great at giving reflections, shadows and all these other real world effects but is generally too slow for a computer to calculate while you are playing a game.
Some of the textures in the show remind me of linear texture filtering (?) seen in 3D games using graphics hardware since the late 90s. Sort of smooth and blended. Curves look perfectly nice and round and not blocky as they do in many games. And the edges of 3D models seem so smooth with little or no discernible aliasing. I realise there is a difference between pre-rendered CGI and in-game graphics with full interaction, but is this really an issue in the field of in-game computer graphics 20 years on?

I might be exaggerating the quality of B5 CGI a bit here (afterall I'm a layman in this field), but I just don't get that same "feeling" when playing these games.
Post edited November 19, 2013 by Primate
I think that the main reason these games don't look that good is their age. Games designed 5-10 years ago had to work with primitive graphics cards by today's standard.

I imagine that if people recreated these games as Star Citizen mods for example, they could be made to look better than the show.
avatar
Primate: I might be exaggerating the quality of B5 CGI a bit here (afterall I'm a layman in this field), but I just don't get that same "feeling" when playing these games.
I don't know what the games you're talking about look like but frankly I always considered the CGI in Babylon 5 pretty cheap and it has been possible for ages to render nicer stuff in real-time. Just compare X3's in-game graphics to Babylon's CGI sequences (and X3 is pretty old by now).

As for the "perfect curves": indeed, that's something that wasn't really possible in real-time for a long time but by now the necessary technologies exist. There's pretty advanced anti aliasing techniques by now and to my understanding tessellation (introduced in DirectX 11) is capable of drawing perfect curves out of polygonal 3D objects in real-time. One of the earlier demos for tessellation was a comparison pic from Stalker: Call of Pripyat where thanks to tessellation a gasmask would appear like a perfect cylinder while you could clearly see all the flat surfaces that the cylinder was made of when tessellation was off.

So yeah, if people with more skill and resources would make a game based on B5 now it would most definitely look much much better than the CGI sequences from Babylon 5 in every possible way.
Post edited November 19, 2013 by F4LL0UT
avatar
F4LL0UT: I don't know what the games you're talking about look like but frankly I always considered the CGI in Babylon 5 pretty cheap and it has been possible for ages to render nicer stuff in real-time. Just compare X3's in-game graphics to Babylon's CGI sequences (and X3 is pretty old by now).
Indeed. Even Star Trek: The Next Generation in 1987 had better CGI than Babylon 5 and, back in 1993, it was obvious even then that Babylon 5's effects were made on a much lower budget and with a much less competent team. I've seen some awesome stuff done with Lightwave on the Amiga, but Babylon 5 wasn't among it.

B5's strength was in its writing, which overcame the poor effects and some fairly wooden acting (and overacting). The main cast (O'Hare, Doyle, Boxleitner, Furlan, Katsulas, Jurasik, Carter, Mumy, Furst, Christian) were good, but almost all of the secondary characters with a few exceptions (Patricia Tallman in particular, whose role really didn't come into her own until the mediocre Season 5 ironically) were really badly acted.
Post edited November 19, 2013 by jamyskis