It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
pds41: Right - so basically, you're okay as long as you're not running something that needs lots of RAM and lots of VRAM at the same time?
Exactly. In such a case you wouldn't be able to make use of the full hardware resources your system has.
avatar
FreedomWings: A GTX 660 would be a good choice I guess but don't count on keeping up with the PS4. Really wait for the next set of GPUs, I am waiting for Maxwell myself so I can be sure to beat the PS4.
Yeah - GTX 660 is a bit better than the PS4 GPU in some areas, a bit worse in others (GTX 660 has ~27% better texture fillrate, PS4 has ~8% better pixel fillrate and possibly access to significantly more memory with higher bandwidth).
It should completely outclass the Xbox One GPU ;)
With that said, games tend to be more optimised on consoles, so more powerful PC hardware tends to be needed in order to get the same performance.

I imagine it'll probably run the first few years worth of games pretty well - might want something more powerful if you want to keep running games on high settings in a few years time.
Post edited July 31, 2013 by DreadMoth
avatar
Jeralulz: So if you are going for the FX-6350 I suggest going for the FX-6300 since it has a lower TDP (95 vs 125 IIRC) which means it will run a little cooler and overall there isn't a huge performance difference that would satisfy the higher cost of the processor.
Having built recently systems based on both FX 6300 & 6350, my feeling is that the higher TDP does not seem to translate in a significant increase in CPU / system temp. I haven't tried to O/C them ( the 6300 was for friend, the 6350 for me ) . With a modest cooler master ventirad, the 6350 barely reaches 45 °C full load. (31°C idle ) with a room temperature around 29°C...
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: I read through Psyringe's posts in that thread, and they seem to agree with what I said earlier (although maybe I didn't explain myself clearly enough in my earlier post). You're correct that VRAM does not consume an application's allocated RAM, but it does consume the system's total available memory addresses. Basically a 32-bit system only has 4 GB of addressable memory to hand out, and both VRAM and "normal" RAM pull from this pool of addresses. Now, if your current total RAM usage is less than that 4 GB total then there's no problem. However, if you're really using the GPU and it's asking for 1.5 GB of memory addresses, and the game you're running is asking for another 2 GB of memory addresses, and your system processes and other programs you're running are asking for another 1 GB of memory addresses, then you simply don't have enough memory addresses to hand out and some processes don't get the memory they're asking for.
This is still largely incorrect and covered in that thread. The GPU does take some of the system RAM/Address space as do other components, thus as he explained is why I only got about 3.5 GB of RAM available. In that thread read that the GPU will only take up to 256MB of system RAM, now he said he wasn't sure but I did read the same thing on another site, not sure where.

I tested this myself too, I completely filled all of my system RAM with various programs and had Crysis running taking over 720MBs or VRAM. Thus I had page swapping (virtual memory) going on with my hard drive thrashing about. I also did so toying with oblivion having it consume about I think it was 1.5GB RAM and all 1024MBs of my VRAM, and that is on top of my system plus steam at the time consuming ~1GB already. The combination of Psyringe's teaching and my further reading and expirimentation has taught me a good bit about RAM and it's limitations.

On much older system VRAM used to completely dig into the system address space but this was changed when video cards started getting large amount of VRAM.

Maybe I will install window xp again when Maxwell comes out just to make absolutely certain. At that time I won't be getting a card with any less than 4GiBs VRAM.

avatar
DreadMoth: I imagine it'll probably run the first few years worth of games pretty well - might want something more powerful if you want to keep running games on high settings in a few years time.
Just what I am thinking as well. Supposedly developer will be digging deeper into the PS4 hardware than the PS3 so I am think there is going to be a big surprise down the road. I would not feel comfortable with any thing less than a GTX 780 , to beat the PS4. I would really suck to be stuck behind it.

Oh yes just as a word of caution, I just read while messing with my new windows 7 install that windows 8 does not allow you to turn off desktop composition. You may want to reconsider your choice of using windows 8.
Post edited August 01, 2013 by FreedomWings
Just passing through.
Build a PC last year, not to bad, but it scared me when I would put parts in and hear a little CLICK as it is just silicon.

Any way this might make you smile - http://xkcd.com/349/
interesting comic, I am currently having great frustration with windows 7, I hate it.
avatar
FreedomWings: This is still largely incorrect and covered in that thread. The GPU does take some of the system RAM/Address space as do other components, thus as he explained is why I only got about 3.5 GB of RAM available. In that thread read that the GPU will only take up to 256MB of system RAM, now he said he wasn't sure but I did read the same thing on another site, not sure where.

I tested this myself too, I completely filled all of my system RAM with various programs and had Crysis running taking over 720MBs or VRAM. Thus I had page swapping (virtual memory) going on with my hard drive thrashing about. I also did so toying with oblivion having it consume about I think it was 1.5GB RAM and all 1024MBs of my VRAM, and that is on top of my system plus steam at the time consuming ~1GB already. The combination of Psyringe's teaching and my further reading and expirimentation has taught me a good bit about RAM and it's limitations.

On much older system VRAM used to completely dig into the system address space but this was changed when video cards started getting large amount of VRAM.

Maybe I will install window xp again when Maxwell comes out just to make absolutely certain. At that time I won't be getting a card with any less than 4GiBs VRAM.
You got me curious, so I dug into the issue a bit deeper. When running programs in 32-bit windows (or running a 32-bit program in 64-bit windows without it being made large-address aware) each program is limited to 2 GB of virtual memory. This is independent of how much physical RAM the system has. All memory address allocation by the program, which encompasses both system RAM and VRAM, is limited to this 2 GB; in other words, the total system RAM+VRAM usage for a single program cannot exceed 2 GB. If the program runs into this limit you'll run into problems ranging from stuttering to outright crashes, depending on how the program is designed (or not designed) to handle such a case. However, there's another issue on top of this. If the program is running using DX9 then all VRAM usage is also mirrored to system RAM (and this mirrored address usage is still included in the 2 GB application cap); this does not apply for DX10+. So if you have a GPU with lots of VRAM and a game is really making use of it then this can cause the program to very quickly gobble up all the virtual memory allocated to it.

Ultimately it's this virtual memory limit that is most likely to cause a high-RAM GPU to cause performance issues, rather than the overall 4 GB limit on memory addresses. This issue is exacerbated if a game is running under DX9 because any VRAM usage counts double towards the 2 GB virtual memory limit, due to the mirroring of VRAM to system RAM.
avatar
DarrkPhoenix: You got me curious, so I dug into the issue a bit deeper. When running programs in 32-bit windows (or running a 32-bit program in 64-bit windows without it being made large-address aware) each program is limited to 2 GB of virtual memory. This is independent of how much physical RAM the system has. All memory address allocation by the program, which encompasses both system RAM and VRAM, is limited to this 2 GB; in other words, the total system RAM+VRAM usage for a single program cannot exceed 2 GB. If the program runs into this limit you'll run into problems ranging from stuttering to outright crashes, depending on how the program is designed (or not designed) to handle such a case. However, there's another issue on top of this. If the program is running using DX9 then all VRAM usage is also mirrored to system RAM (and this mirrored address usage is still included in the 2 GB application cap); this does not apply for DX10+. So if you have a GPU with lots of VRAM and a game is really making use of it then this can cause the program to very quickly gobble up all the virtual memory allocated to it.
You are making me curious as well. But no the GPU does not use the game's 2GB address space unless it runs out of VRAM, then unless the game is programed otherwise the GPU will start dumping what it can into the games 2GB address space. I watched this happen in oblivion when I was on XP. I don't know of any game that have done it but I read that developers can have the GPU dump data into a separate address space should the GPU run out of VRAM.

I am aware of VRAM mirroring but not all DX9 or lower games do this mirroring. The game developer can program the game not to mirror the VRAM. Skyrim and oblivion have been criticized for mirroring VRAM, bethesda has no intention of fixing that. Also not all of the VRAM is mirrored, I am not sure but I think it is only texture files or something like that which is mirrored.

If the game uses up all of it's address space and then needs more I think it will just out right crash as windows detects this and shut the program down.

You may be interested in looking at RAM usage with Skyrim. Skyrim will crash if it tries to go over 3.1GB. Many people have skyrim consuming 3.1 GB RAM plus 2.5+ GB VRAM. The highest VRAM usage I have seen was 2.8-2.9 GB.
Post edited August 03, 2013 by FreedomWings
avatar
FreedomWings: You are making me curious as well. But no the GPU does not use the game's 2GB address space unless it runs out of VRAM, then unless the game is programed otherwise the GPU will start dumping what it can into the games 2GB address space. I watched this happen in oblivion when I was on XP. I don't know of any game that have done it but I read that developers can have the GPU dump data into a separate address space should the GPU run out of VRAM.
Seems I'm learning quite a bit through this discussion. After a bit more reading it seems you are partially correct in that VRAM usage doesn't automatically count towards an application's virtual memory limit, although parts of VRAM usage can count towards it under a variety of conditions (in other conditions the operations using VRAM are handled entirely on the card and the game process doesn't even see it). Certain methods that can be used for populating VRAM (creating mappable surfaces) can consume large amounts of virtual memory space; a discussion of this can be found here. You can also read a bit more on issues surrounding the consumption of virtual memory by VRAM usage in this white paper from MS.

Also, going back to overall memory address limits, there's a good discussion here of how the 4 GB limit on 32-bit systems can be partially eaten up due to memory mapped I/O used in some types of hardware (including graphics cards).

avatar
FreedomWings: If the game uses up all of it's address space and then needs more I think it will just out right crash as windows detects this and shut the program down.
It depends on how the game was coded. Programs should include error-handling for running out of address space so that the program can fail gracefully without becoming unstable or crashing, but naturally this doesn't always get done.
I think I already read the hard forum posting, but read it again anyway. The memory mapped I/O video aperture thing is the 256MB limit I mentioned earlier. I think he made a mistake about window versions, I think all windows xp version below professional can only use 2GiB or RAM but I am not sure. I always use the pro version to avoid problems. I suppose we could check this mapped I/O value on our systems.

The blog page is messy and a bit contradictory. Also I don't think page swapping (virtual memory, they really need to stop calling it that.) kicks in and allows you to store more data for the application beyond the address space limit, maybe some fancy code could do that for some data but I don't think it would at all be viable for games. I have not heard or witness page swapping occur like that. Page swapping to the hard drive will occur when you run out of RAM as I tested earlier when I said my hard drive was thrashing, which is when pages are being continuously swapped in and out, Crysis was stuttering about greatly.

Damn I can't read the .doc file. I am still restoring my system.
Post edited August 03, 2013 by FreedomWings
avatar
JMich: Don't forget that Playstation 4 and XBox One will both have 8cores in them, and games will be made to take advantage of the multiple cores. Not sure if all 8 will be used or only 4, but multiple cores should benefit games in the near future.
Once a game has been coded to use more than one core, is it easy to upscale and use more cores with little development time? Or is each additional core considered equal.

In other words, if the PS4 and Xbone utilise 4 cores, can I expect PC ports to support my 8 core CPU because it's easy to upscale?
avatar
pds41: If I have a 2GB graphics card, will that leave 32 bit windows only able to access 2gb of system ram?
avatar
misteryo: A 2 GB video card has 2 GB of VRAM on the card. Has nothing to do with your system RAM.

And, yes, you'll want new RAM. Your new board will support DDR 3. I'm fairly sure your current system has DDR 2
Depends on the OS, but on some OSes the GPU and system share address space, so the two are somewhat related. However, that really shouldn't be the case with 64bit OSes. If I'm not mistaken XP 32 bit does share the address space between the two.
avatar
JMich: Don't forget that Playstation 4 and XBox One will both have 8cores in them, and games will be made to take advantage of the multiple cores. Not sure if all 8 will be used or only 4, but multiple cores should benefit games in the near future.
avatar
Dzsono: Once a game has been coded to use more than one core, is it easy to upscale and use more cores with little development time? Or is each additional core considered equal.

In other words, if the PS4 and Xbone utilise 4 cores, can I expect PC ports to support my 8 core CPU because it's easy to upscale?
That really depends upon the game. Some games can be coded to use as many cores as you give them, but others don't benefit much, if at all from additional cores. RTS games tend to be easy to scale onto additional cores, but other games that don't do so much all at once, aren't going to see much benefit.

I'd look at the recommended requirements to see how many cores they recommend, but ultimately, you're usually better off with a smaller number of faster cores when it comes to gaming.
Post edited August 03, 2013 by hedwards
avatar
Dzsono: Once a game has been coded to use more than one core, is it easy to upscale and use more cores with little development time? Or is each additional core considered equal.

In other words, if the PS4 and Xbone utilise 4 cores, can I expect PC ports to support my 8 core CPU because it's easy to upscale?
For the first question, no and things get tougher with more cores and that is why you need a dynamic system which is what all the big new engines are doing. Making a dynamic system is much more difficult but once you have it you can scale up the core cont much easier. I don't think you will need to worry for future games except those by developers such as bethesda that insist upon using poor engines, we will see if they change their ways.

For the second question the safe bet is yes, since the new engine were specifically developed with things like this in mind and the new consoled are using PC hardware.

Also about core cont usage, when it comes to emulating like the PS2 emulator it is a whole new ball game.
avatar
hedwards: That really depends upon the game. Some games can be coded to use as many cores as you give them, but others don't benefit much, if at all from additional cores. RTS games tend to be easy to scale onto additional cores, but other games that don't do so much all at once, aren't going to see much benefit.

I'd look at the recommended requirements to see how many cores they recommend, but ultimately, you're usually better off with a smaller number of faster cores when it comes to gaming.
That is not the case the games must be made to use the cores and the genre has nothing to do with it, starcraft 2 only uses 2 cores I read.

The second statement is correct for the current gaming climate but will start to change to other way. I am very eager to see what awaits us.

My big question for PC gaming is will Linux replace windows and finally free me from these shackles. I hate windows 7 and I just got it. Just found out I can't organize files and folders. GRRRRR
Post edited August 03, 2013 by FreedomWings
avatar
FreedomWings: That is not the case the games must be made to use the cores and the genre has nothing to do with it, starcraft 2 only uses 2 cores I read.

The second statement is correct for the current gaming climate but will start to change to other way. I am very eager to see what awaits us.

My big question for PC gaming is will Linux replace windows and finally free me from these shackles. I hate windows 7 and I just got it. Just found out I can't organize files and folders. GRRRRR
Just because SC 2 didn't, doesn't mean that it doesn't make a huge difference. SC 2 can get away with it because they limit the number of units that you're able to use. Pathfinding and AI themselves are some of the easiest things to run in parallel of all the gaming tasks. As you have the option of using as many cores as there are units if you have the luxury or sharing fewer units per core if you don't.

Just play a game of Warzone 2100 and you'll see what I mean. The game gets incredible sluggish during the end game because there aren't enough processors to handle the load of those millions of units on the screen.

OTOH, a FPS will benefit very little from having more than a couple cores just because it's mainly serial in nature. There isn't an easy way of taking that and turning it into something that benefits greatly from a large number of processors.
avatar
FreedomWings: My big question for PC gaming is will Linux replace windows and finally free me from these shackles.
This is a dream we all share :)