It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
hedwards: Just because SC 2 didn't, doesn't mean that it doesn't make a huge difference. SC 2 can get away with it because they limit the number of units that you're able to use. Pathfinding and AI themselves are some of the easiest things to run in parallel of all the gaming tasks. As you have the option of using as many cores as there are units if you have the luxury or sharing fewer units per core if you don't.

OTOH, a FPS will benefit very little from having more than a couple cores just because it's mainly serial in nature. There isn't an easy way of taking that and turning it into something that benefits greatly from a large number of processors.
I don't know what you are getting at with SC 2. What did it not?

I don't know what you are talking about with "serial in nature", but any sort of application will benefit from more cores.

Some of the most CPU heavy games are FPS Unreal Tournament 3 is relatively CPU heavy and I have been tolled it will use 6 cores and maybe even more. Oblivion and skyrim desperately need more than the 1 core they use. Crysis series is very CPU heavy as is Far Cry series, Arma 3, etc. Jeez while I was tweaking source engine games I read old post from when that engine was new about games on it being CPU heavy. Thanks to some modern games using multiple core my system easily send the frame rate through the roof. I can run many Unreal Engine 3 games very well at hundreds of frames per second which I greatly appreciate.

Traditionally cores have been used for specific things one core for animation, one core for game logic and physics, one core for graphics, etc. Tim Sweeney was talking about this when asked about the development of Unreal Engine 4.

No one said multi threading was easy, dynamic multithreading is even harder.
Post edited August 05, 2013 by FreedomWings
Ok I am reading that document now. This is very interesting right here and I think people should be aware of the alt-tabing thing as this explains why alt-tabing games is not recommended or does not work. Thanks for posting this document.

"Existing games and other graphics applications often allocate virtual memory for a copy of the video memory resources that they create. The application uses the copy to quickly restore the display if the contents of video memory are lost, as might occur if the user presses ALT+TAB, places the machine in Standby mode, and so forth. The DirectX run time typically manages the copy on behalf of the application when the application creates a managed resource, but an application can also manage the copy itself. The amount of virtual memory that the copy uses is directly proportional to the amount of video memory resources that the application allocates."

Ok so that document is kind of old, but what I gather is that do to WDDM and how/or whether it is used, games may burn through more or less of there RAM address space. If WDDM is used as intended then from what I understand from reading that any VRAM mirroring that is done if it is done can be mirrored in VRAM instead of system RAM since VRAM under WDDM is now virtualized, in this case there is more RAM for the application but less VRAM. However I guess if more VRAM were needed WDDM would kick the mirrored data into RAM. Seems patching games to be Large address aware has more importance than I thought.

With WDDM and mirroring video resources the old way, seems to explain why skyrim crashes when trying to use more than 3.1GB of RAM because the WDDM over head is using and in this case wasting the last of the address space.

I think I got the VRAM and virtual address space thing earlier right.
Post edited August 05, 2013 by FreedomWings
avatar
FreedomWings: I don't know what you are getting at with SC 2. What did it not?
The developers didn't give a shit about performance, hence some of the design decisions like not having LAN play and not designing a game that's multicore friendly. Also, they limited the number of units that you can use. They did that in the original game as well, mainly because computers of the era couldn't handle large numbers of units.

avatar
FreedomWings: I don't know what you are talking about with "serial in nature", but any sort of application will benefit from more cores.

Some of the most CPU heavy games are FPS Unreal Tournament 3 is relatively CPU heavy and I have been tolled it will use 6 cores and maybe even more. Oblivion and skyrim desperately need more than the 1 core they use. Crysis series is very CPU heavy as is Far Cry series, Arma 3, etc. Jeez while I was tweaking source engine games I read old post from when that engine was new about games on it being CPU heavy. Thanks to some modern games using multiple core my system easily send the frame rate through the roof. I can run many Unreal Engine 3 games very well at hundreds of frames per second which I greatly appreciate.

Traditionally cores have been used for specific things one core for animation, one core for game logic and physics, one core for graphics, etc. Tim Sweeney was talking about this when asked about the development of Unreal Engine 4.

No one said multi threading was easy, dynamic multithreading is even harder.
You can use more cores for FPS games, but it's not usually necessary. The main benefit there is that you can have more powerful AI, but I haven't seen any games where they really made much use of that.

Graphics and physics are GPU based these days. And you can get away with one for game logic for FPS games, but good luck with that if you've got millions of units all path finding at the same time.

The point is that FPS games just do not benefit the way that some other games do from a large number of cores. What you need is a smaller number of faster cores as most of what is going on needs to happen in series.
I think I see what you are getting at. Would be sweet to have that many units running around.
Okay, so I ended up going with:

FX-8350
Asrock 970 Extreme3 R2.0
16GB Ram (2x8GB)
Windows 7 64bit Professional
MSI Geforce GTX 660 TwinFrozr

I kept my HDD and PSU (turned out it's only 750W - about 4 years old - not branded - it previously ran a AMD X2-250 with GTX 275)

Unfortunately, after putting it together, it's been a bit difficult. I've had two instances where the computer turned itself off and wouldn't turn back on unless I unplug it (this stopped when I swapped my video card to run off the dedicated graphics rail on my psu rather than from the molex converters). I've had BSODs immediately after logging on and once when trying to upgrade GFX drivers (but if it doesn't BSOD immediately, it runs fine).

A lot of memtest and mobo tests. Memory and Motherboard seem fine; I have done *extensive* memtests. CPU and video card survived all the 3d Mark tests.

I'm thinking the PSU might be on the way out.

Any thoughts team?
avatar
pds41: I'm thinking the PSU might be on the way out.
PSU could definitely be one of the causes. Not sure how much you spent, but I'm always partial to a quality name-brand PSU. A bad PSU can trash all your hardware if you are unlucky.

The other thing you can look at is the RAM timings and drop them down a notch if you haven't already. Of course it could always be the motherboard. ;)
Post edited September 10, 2013 by Gydion
avatar
pds41: Okay, so I ended up going with:

FX-8350
Asrock 970 Extreme3 R2.0
16GB Ram (2x8GB)
Windows 7 64bit Professional
MSI Geforce GTX 660 TwinFrozr

I kept my HDD and PSU (turned out it's only 750W - about 4 years old - not branded - it previously ran a AMD X2-250 with GTX 275)

Unfortunately, after putting it together, it's been a bit difficult. I've had two instances where the computer turned itself off and wouldn't turn back on unless I unplug it (this stopped when I swapped my video card to run off the dedicated graphics rail on my psu rather than from the molex converters). I've had BSODs immediately after logging on and once when trying to upgrade GFX drivers (but if it doesn't BSOD immediately, it runs fine).

A lot of memtest and mobo tests. Memory and Motherboard seem fine; I have done *extensive* memtests. CPU and video card survived all the 3d Mark tests.

I'm thinking the PSU might be on the way out.

Any thoughts team?
I had memory go bad even with various memory testers giving it a clear. I'm currently running an 8350 myself, good choice on CPU.

But what you got sounds like PSU issues. Never take a PSU apart, they can give a lethal shock. I have a PSU tester and it's a handy thing to have since I work on PC's for family and friends all the time, up to you if the price is worth it or not. This one is $30 and would do fine and can check for unstable power supply:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16899109003&nm_mc=KNC-GoogleAdwords&cm_mmc=KNC-GoogleAdwords-_-pla-_-PC+tools%2f+Testers-_-N82E16899109003&gclid=CMzDyumZwrkCFYxcMgod1R8AeA
Post edited September 10, 2013 by tb87670
Since you kept your old HDD, how did you proceed installing your new OS?. Did you format the drive + clean install ? If not, that could explain that type of erratic behaviour.. Other than that, yes, the PSU would be the usual suspect.
avatar
Phc7006: Since you kept your old HDD, how did you proceed installing your new OS?. Did you format the drive + clean install ? If not, that could explain that type of erratic behaviour.. Other than that, yes, the PSU would be the usual suspect.
Yep - well, I deleted the partition through windows install and created a new one. Upgraded to windows 7 64 bit, on a clean install.

I've also tested with another HDD, which gives the same issues. The other thing I've had is the computer rebooting part way through loading up windows a couple of times (when the logo is on the screen) before finally getting in to windows - trouble is, everyone else with this problem, it's been a virus stopping them getting into windows.

I was originally thinking overheating as well (the fan is very fast and noisy on the fx 8350, and I got core temps in the mid to high 50s running f1 2010 on a stock cooler), but that wouldn't explain why it bsods on start-up rather than after a few hours of running.

Considering going Corsair CX750M for power supply; I'm assuming another 750W supply should work (I can also get a G7 880W supply, but I don't think they're as good a brand?)
OP, check out this guide, it's great for planning your build based on your budget to get the absolute best deal/prices:
http://4changboard.wikia.com/wiki/Falcon_Guide
avatar
Crosmando: OP, check out this guide, it's great for planning your build based on your budget to get the absolute best deal/prices:
http://4changboard.wikia.com/wiki/Falcon_Guide
Cheers - that's a useful site, which I'll definitely be looking at going forwards.
avatar
pds41: I'm thinking the PSU might be on the way out.
avatar
Gydion: PSU could definitely be one of the causes. Not sure how much you spent, but I'm always partial to a quality name-brand PSU. A bad PSU can trash all your hardware if you are unlucky.

The other thing you can look at is the RAM timings and drop them down a notch if you haven't already. Of course it could always be the motherboard. ;)
My biggest worry is that it's the motherboard or the CPU. I'm trying to confirm everything else works properly first; I really struggle with motherboard testing.
Post edited September 11, 2013 by pds41
Don't buy Hitachi HDD's whatever you do.
avatar
Crosmando: Don't buy Hitachi HDD's whatever you do.
Did that once, 10 years ago. It was a mistake. Not going to do that again.
avatar
tb87670: But what you got sounds like PSU issues. Never take a PSU apart, they can give a lethal shock.
Just watch out for the caps. Always treat all parts in a power supply like they have power still applied. I've personally only replaced fans that have slowed down, got really noisy, or just failed. Other than that, I usually just buy a new one.
avatar
pds41: My biggest worry is that it's the motherboard or the CPU. I'm trying to confirm everything else works properly first; I really struggle with motherboard testing.
That's everyone troubleshooting nightmare. It's one of the hardest problems to troubleshoot, because it can act like any of the other parts is bad. Unless you have a spare motherboard then it is hard to determine.
Post edited September 11, 2013 by jjsimp
avatar
pds41: My biggest worry is that it's the motherboard or the CPU. I'm trying to confirm everything else works properly first; I really struggle with motherboard testing.
That's the way to go about it without a spare motherboard. Even then it's easier to swap the other parts out. I would skip the tester and just buy a Seasonic, Corsair or Antec PSU. Get an 80+ Bronze at the least. I would look for 80+ Gold on sale somewhere.

avatar
Crosmando: Don't buy Hitachi HDD's whatever you do.
Meh, all hard drive vendors suck equally.