It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
pds41: My biggest worry is that it's the motherboard or the CPU. I'm trying to confirm everything else works properly first; I really struggle with motherboard testing.
avatar
Gydion: That's the way to go about it without a spare motherboard. Even then it's easier to swap the other parts out. I would skip the tester and just buy a Seasonic, Corsair or Antec PSU. Get an 80+ Bronze at the least. I would look for 80+ Gold on sale somewhere.
Yeah - I'm planning on replacing the PSU (after the power off issues, I'm a bit concerned, even if it's generally okay).

Next step, I'll whack in my old GTX 275 and see if that works. If not, it's got to be the motherboard or CPU. In which case, it's get on the line to Asrock and have a go at them.

Really hope it's just the PSU though. It's such a pain wiring up a new motherboard into a case. Although, if I end up having to replace the motherboard, I might take the opportunity to get a quieter fan and heatsynch for the processor.
avatar
pds41: I've also tested with another HDD, which gives the same issues. The other thing I've had is the computer rebooting part way through loading up windows a couple of times (when the logo is on the screen) before finally getting in to windows - trouble is, everyone else with this problem, it's been a virus stopping them getting into windows.

I was originally thinking overheating as well (the fan is very fast and noisy on the fx 8350, and I got core temps in the mid to high 50s running f1 2010 on a stock cooler), but that wouldn't explain why it bsods on start-up rather than after a few hours of running.

Considering going Corsair CX750M for power supply; I'm assuming another 750W supply should work (I can also get a G7 880W supply, but I don't think they're as good a brand?)
I don't think it's an overheating issue. Yet, replacing that stock cooler should be on your to do list. Imho, tha AMD stock coolers are not adequate to cool down any of their 6 or 8 core cpu's. You don't need monster coolers though. On my FX6350, a cooler master hyper tx3 win a send fan does a ver,y good job. On a 8350 you probably want a cooler with 120mm fans.

A 750W 80 certified PSU will be sufficient, indeed

Going further, did you activate a fast boot or tubo boost something function ? What if you desactivate it ?

What are your ram settings ? What if you lower them to the level of say 1333 Mhz DDR3 ?
avatar
Phc7006: I don't think it's an overheating issue. Yet, replacing that stock cooler should be on your to do list. Imho, tha AMD stock coolers are not adequate to cool down any of their 6 or 8 core cpu's. You don't need monster coolers though. On my FX6350, a cooler master hyper tx3 win a send fan does a ver,y good job. On a 8350 you probably want a cooler with 120mm fans.

A 750W 80 certified PSU will be sufficient, indeed

Going further, did you activate a fast boot or tubo boost something function ? What if you desactivate it ?

What are your ram settings ? What if you lower them to the level of say 1333 Mhz DDR3 ?
I'll have a look in the BIOS at the weekend (I'm away with work this week); I think at the moment, it's largely running on "auto" or factory settings; I haven't overclocked anything in there as yet, and wouldn't unless I had better cooling.
avatar
pds41: I've also tested with another HDD, which gives the same issues. The other thing I've had is the computer rebooting part way through loading up windows a couple of times (when the logo is on the screen) before finally getting in to windows - trouble is, everyone else with this problem, it's been a virus stopping them getting into windows.

I was originally thinking overheating as well (the fan is very fast and noisy on the fx 8350, and I got core temps in the mid to high 50s running f1 2010 on a stock cooler), but that wouldn't explain why it bsods on start-up rather than after a few hours of running.

Considering going Corsair CX750M for power supply; I'm assuming another 750W supply should work (I can also get a G7 880W supply, but I don't think they're as good a brand?)
avatar
Phc7006: I don't think it's an overheating issue. Yet, replacing that stock cooler should be on your to do list. Imho, tha AMD stock coolers are not adequate to cool down any of their 6 or 8 core cpu's. You don't need monster coolers though. On my FX6350, a cooler master hyper tx3 win a send fan does a ver,y good job. On a 8350 you probably want a cooler with 120mm fans.

A 750W 80 certified PSU will be sufficient, indeed

Going further, did you activate a fast boot or tubo boost something function ? What if you desactivate it ?

What are your ram settings ? What if you lower them to the level of say 1333 Mhz DDR3 ?
Okay - so no turbo or fast boost. RAM is autodetecting - I've got 1333 Mhz DDR3 in there anyway.

It's odd - I'm finding that now I've got a new psu in there, I'm getting BSODs on first boot in the morning (not on subsequent boots unless I turn off for an extended period of time), usually between the logon screen and the desktop. After that, it appears stable - I haven't used it for much gaming yet, but it'll run (e.g.) GTA IV very nicely. Haven't done an extended test though - all I know is that it's good for about 10 minutes.

I've never encountered anything like this before; it's really odd.
Post edited September 16, 2013 by pds41
avatar
pds41: I've also tested with another HDD, which gives the same issues. The other thing I've had is the computer rebooting part way through loading up windows a couple of times (when the logo is on the screen) before finally getting in to windows - trouble is, everyone else with this problem, it's been a virus stopping them getting into windows.

I was originally thinking overheating as well (the fan is very fast and noisy on the fx 8350, and I got core temps in the mid to high 50s running f1 2010 on a stock cooler), but that wouldn't explain why it bsods on start-up rather than after a few hours of running.

Considering going Corsair CX750M for power supply; I'm assuming another 750W supply should work (I can also get a G7 880W supply, but I don't think they're as good a brand?)
avatar
Phc7006: I don't think it's an overheating issue. Yet, replacing that stock cooler should be on your to do list. Imho, tha AMD stock coolers are not adequate to cool down any of their 6 or 8 core cpu's. You don't need monster coolers though. On my FX6350, a cooler master hyper tx3 win a send fan does a ver,y good job. On a 8350 you probably want a cooler with 120mm fans.

A 750W 80 certified PSU will be sufficient, indeed

Going further, did you activate a fast boot or tubo boost something function ? What if you desactivate it ?

What are your ram settings ? What if you lower them to the level of say 1333 Mhz DDR3 ?
Diagnosed the issue to dodgy RAM; I ran Memtest86+ over two days on the box, and after about the 10th pass, one of the chips just started whacking out errors.

It was odd the way the memory problem presented itself - just on first boot. Still, I've RMA'd the RAM and put new sticks in and it seems to be going.

Replacing the cooler is definitely on the list - if just to keep the noise down. These 8 core chips run hot!

I was thinking of something like this: http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2202829

- although I assume for a couple of months it should be fine to run on the stock cooler.
Damn, I was considering building a new AMD rig for my nephew, but I forgot about how hot those things run. Might as well pay the extra $50 for an intel rig if I have to run an aftermarket cooler with the AMD rig.
Post edited September 20, 2013 by jjsimp
avatar
pds41: It was odd the way the memory problem presented itself - just on first boot. Still, I've RMA'd the RAM and put new sticks in and it seems to be going.

Replacing the cooler is definitely on the list - if just to keep the noise down. These 8 core chips run hot!

I was thinking of something like this: http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2202829

- although I assume for a couple of months it should be fine to run on the stock cooler.
Probably a very local conductivity issue. When cold, the chip didn't check well. Once warmer, conductivity was better and the check was a success. Anyway, glad you found the issue. If it was that, it would have become worse and worse over time...

As for the cooler, yes, this is the kind of material you want to purchase if your case allows it. Just check you don't have to remove the motherboard to change a backplate. It's a common hassle when changing AM3+ coolers and really not fun to do once you've got your system up and running.

Anyway, you don't need a monster cooler if you don' plan to overclock. You need to secure a 15°C margin that will ensure a smooth functionning even in case of heatwave , while reducing the level of noise produced. I run a FX6350 and a very basic Cooler Master Hyper Evo with couple of 92 mm fans reduces my CPU temperature to very acceptable levels ( -15° C vs the stock cooler ) at half the original noise level. I had to go for a compact cooler because of the case. The one you mention is quite larger ( picture it as a cube of 13 cm with 1 fan ) and has a dissipation capacity of 160W.

And no, there should be no risk running the stock cooler. You may want to change it by next Summer though...
avatar
jjsimp: Damn, I was considering building a new AMD rig for my nephew, but I forgot about how hot those things run. Might as well pay the extra $50 for an intel rig if I have to run an aftermarket cooler with the AMD rig.
Would you really need a 8350 ? The 4350 and 6350 do not run that hot. Just their stock coolers are noisy and not that effective. On the other hand, Intel I5's usually do not need an aftermarket cooler, and that pays you back half of the difference on the CPU.
Post edited September 20, 2013 by Phc7006
avatar
Phc7006: Would you really need a 8350 ? The 4350 and 6350 do not run that hot. Just their stock coolers are noisy and not that effective. On the other hand, Intel I5's usually do not need an aftermarket cooler, and that pays you back half of the difference on the CPU.
Yeah, I'll have to look at how much of a difference each is, but I need to take in account purchasing a cooler for the AMD. I'm not to versed on the AMD processors, as I have been building intel rigs for the last five years, but I was looking at an i5. Still waiting for the Xmas sales to begin. This will be a Xmas present, so I have a lot of time to wait.

He lives in the deep south, and their air conditioner is usually not used. I always get a hotel when I visit for that reason.
Post edited September 20, 2013 by jjsimp
avatar
Phc7006: Would you really need a 8350 ? The 4350 and 6350 do not run that hot. Just their stock coolers are noisy and not that effective. On the other hand, Intel I5's usually do not need an aftermarket cooler, and that pays you back half of the difference on the CPU.
avatar
jjsimp: Yeah, I'll have to look at how much of a difference each is, but I need to take in account purchasing a cooler for the AMD. I'm not to versed on the AMD processors, as I have been building intel rigs for the last five years, but I was looking at an i5. Still waiting for the Xmas sales to begin. This will be a Xmas present, so I have a lot of time to wait.

He lives in the deep south, and their air conditioner is usually not used. I always get a hotel when I visit for that reason.
Right now, I guess building a FX6350 based system with a mid-range motherboard ( I wouldn't advise entry level AM3+ MBs) and reasonable tower cooler with a 120mm fan would be roughly cost the same as a I5-4430/4440 with an entry-range motherboard ( by definition Haswell MB are recent) and stock cooler. Although I really like my 6350, I think that in that cas I'd go the Intel way. None the least because it has a better tolerance to temperature. Also because your nephew probably cares more about gaming performance than multithreaded operations
avatar
Phc7006: Anyway, you don't need a monster cooler if you don' plan to overclock. You need to secure a 15°C margin that will ensure a smooth functionning even in case of heatwave , while reducing the level of noise produced. I run a FX6350 and a very basic Cooler Master Hyper Evo with couple of 92 mm fans reduces my CPU temperature to very acceptable levels ( -15° C vs the stock cooler ) at half the original noise level. I had to go for a compact cooler because of the case. The one you mention is quite larger ( picture it as a cube of 13 cm with 1 fan ) and has a dissipation capacity of 160W.

And no, there should be no risk running the stock cooler. You may want to change it by next Summer though...
I got a bit worried by my current operating temperatures (they've been creeping up a bit, with the core temperature on the CPU hitting 69 degrees under load, so I emailed AMD support on that one. They took some numbers, and basically told me that I needed to get a warranty replacement as it was running too hot (ambient temps around 22 degrees)

This is turning into a pretty stressful build!
avatar
pds41: I got a bit worried by my current operating temperatures (they've been creeping up a bit, with the core temperature on the CPU hitting 69 degrees under load, so I emailed AMD support on that one. They took some numbers, and basically told me that I needed to get a warranty replacement as it was running too hot (ambient temps around 22 degrees)

This is turning into a pretty stressful build!
They consider the safe sustained temp is in the 60-62°c range. But with their stock coolers, their CPUs will under load venture into the 58-65° range. So, 69 is pretty much in the danger zone. Seems indeed high to me, even with a stock cooler. ( should at least be 5° below that ). Could be a bad cpu, or a bad cooler/fan or a bad thermal paste. Still, it's probably worth giving a look at the case as well

I would advise you to try to put on a sheet of paper a sketch of the airlfow. Where is the air entering the computer, where is it supposed to exit ?) , then check that all the fans are mounted in the correct direction. Ideally, with these CPUs , you want to have more extraction ( usually at the rear) than air inflow, meaning the intake fan in front of the case or on the side( but ensuring that the CPU block is between the intake and the extraction) and the extraction in the rear or on top. If you opt for a cpu cooler with a vertical fan, the fan should blow " in" the airflow. Also when placing the aftermarket cooler, use a reliable thermal paste (arctic MX2, Noctua NT H1 )
avatar
Phc7006: They consider the safe sustained temp is in the 60-62°c range. But with their stock coolers, their CPUs will under load venture into the 58-65° range. So, 69 is pretty much in the danger zone. Seems indeed high to me, even with a stock cooler. ( should at least be 5° below that ). Could be a bad cpu, or a bad cooler/fan or a bad thermal paste. Still, it's probably worth giving a look at the case as well
Yeah - I'll return the CPU in any case as they have asked me to. I also had another look at the case; it's quite an old one (c 10 years), and it looks like the front fan has given up on me. I'm running a full ATX motherboard, so I'll start looking for a new midi tower as well, although I'll get the new chip in first.

I think the other thing that worried them was that the temperatures got to 68 degrees in under 2 minutes of putting load on the processor.

I've been thinking either http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2203039 (GZ-G2 Plus) or http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2203226 (EZ-Cool K9-720B). Probably the GZ-G2 on the grounds that the fan isn't lit up and the intakes look better placed.
Post edited September 28, 2013 by pds41
avatar
pds41: I've been thinking either http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2203039 (GZ-G2 Plus) or http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2203226 (EZ-Cool K9-720B). Probably the GZ-G2 on the grounds that the fan isn't lit up and the intakes look better placed.
I would indeed favour the GZ-G2. For several reasons :1/ the PSU goes to the bottom of the case, that means a cleaner build - although you better check that your PSU is compatile with that type of setup 2/ the combination of rear 80mm and top 120mm fans is quite good for heat dissipation. In fact, that case will almost have two air flows : one taking air from to top front fan, exhaust by rear/top fans, cooling the CPU & ram. One taking air from the lower front fan and cooling down the bottom and the PSU 3/ much easier for cabling & mounting hdd / optical drive 4/ PSU dust filter
avatar
pds41: I've been thinking either http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2203039 (GZ-G2 Plus) or http://www.rlsupplies.co.uk/product.php?id_product=2203226 (EZ-Cool K9-720B). Probably the GZ-G2 on the grounds that the fan isn't lit up and the intakes look better placed.
avatar
Phc7006: I would indeed favour the GZ-G2. For several reasons :1/ the PSU goes to the bottom of the case, that means a cleaner build - although you better check that your PSU is compatile with that type of setup 2/ the combination of rear 80mm and top 120mm fans is quite good for heat dissipation. In fact, that case will almost have two air flows : one taking air from to top front fan, exhaust by rear/top fans, cooling the CPU & ram. One taking air from the lower front fan and cooling down the bottom and the PSU 3/ much easier for cabling & mounting hdd / optical drive 4/ PSU dust filter
How do I know if my PSU is compatible with a bottom mount? I'm using a CX750M, so assume it would be (as it's not a generic PSU), but is there a way to be sure?
avatar
Phc7006: I would indeed favour the GZ-G2. For several reasons :1/ the PSU goes to the bottom of the case, that means a cleaner build - although you better check that your PSU is compatile with that type of setup 2/ the combination of rear 80mm and top 120mm fans is quite good for heat dissipation. In fact, that case will almost have two air flows : one taking air from to top front fan, exhaust by rear/top fans, cooling the CPU & ram. One taking air from the lower front fan and cooling down the bottom and the PSU 3/ much easier for cabling & mounting hdd / optical drive 4/ PSU dust filter
avatar
pds41: How do I know if my PSU is compatible with a bottom mount? I'm using a CX750M, so assume it would be (as it's not a generic PSU), but is there a way to be sure?
Most PSUs are ( and the CX750M is - I have a bottom mounted CX600M in my desktop) compatible. You even have the choice to either mount your PSU with its air intake facing the floor ( as the case has ventilated space under the PSU mount ) or inside the case. The former would allow the PSU to have fresher air but should be avoided if you have carpet on the floor . And if you haven't, don't forget to clean the dust filter from time to time. The second option will mean that the PSU will breath slightly hotter air ( that may reduce slightly its efficiency, but it's not that significant ) but will also suck some more hot air out of the case. The choice is yours

PSUs that shouldn't be bottom mounted do not have a large fan on one of their faces ( but an array of holes). Meaning that their heat will go up in the case