It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I can't understand most reactions here in this thread. Maybe the title of the thread wasn'et well chosen, but he explained very well without any rage his problem and point of view. I understand him at some point, because there is a massive difference in performance between an emulated or native game. To bring up Dos games as comparison is silly, they run mostly without any problems on every system today. Also with ScummVM there isn't performance-wise any problem.

The problem here is that from the screenshots you expect a game that natively should perform very well on your system but will maybe not because of the emulation. For many gamenerds here it's easy to guess that a game uses Wine, but a new and less gaming interested customer uses mostly the screenshots to decide about a game. I'm pretty sure, no one here with a relatively new system will check the system specs, especially on a website which sells good "old" games. Really, just try to see this from a new (maybe also very young) customer, who is not a hardocre gamer and just want to buy a new game for his system liinux/mac.

Yes, gog already put the information that they use wine in the system recommendations, that's good,, but personally I think that's not enough. There should be a clear and easily visible mark in the upper gamecard, something like "this game doesn't run natively Linux/MacOS and uses Wine, please check the system recommendations down below if your system can handle it.

Summary: In this topic there is much less drama then many here think. Gog should use Wine to make windows games easily runnable for other plattforms, but also make easy visible on the gamepage that as using Wine the system recommendations are higher and so should be checked.
Post edited July 26, 2014 by DukeNukemForever
high rated
I CAN'T BE BOTHERED TO READ THE SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS, SO I'M GONNA MAKE A THREAD COMPLAINING ABOUT MY INABILITY TO READ THE SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS/COMPATABILITIES!!!!

*cough*
avatar
DukeNukemForever: Yes, gog already put the information that they use wine in the system recommendations, that's good,, but personally I think that's not enough. There should be a clear and easily visible mark in the upper gamecard, something like "this game doesn't run natively Linux/MacOS and uses Wine, please check the system recommendations down below if your system can handle it.
No, that would make it look like using Wine is something bad. If a user has performance problems even though he or she does meet the system requirements, then they need to get in touch with support. Simple as that.
avatar
DukeNukemForever: *snip*
The problem is that the OP over-reacted and accused GOG of false advertising, of which they did nothing of the sort.
low rated
Almost the half of the GOG games can be played trough Wine.
That it that way since time ago.
Just see the list of GOG games suported buy PlayonLinux. More than 200 GOG games.

I don't buyed any of my GOG games to play in WIndows. Not a single one.
And I've been playing them for a long time.

So play a Windows game on Linux it's not new. Not something that GOG invented.

Again, for the ones that only knows Windows. Selling a Windows game runing with Wine it's not the same that sell a Linux game.
And that doesn't change anything having support from GOG or not.

It's not a Linux game. And sould not be not advertised as a Linux game.
For instance there is Linux native version of Return to Castle of Wolfnstein. And there is a Windows version.
Selling the Windows version bundled with Wine it's that: A Windows version bundled with Wine. Not the Linux version.

There is a lot of Windows users in this tread, it's ok. But I think most of they thon't have enough Linux base to understand the problem here.
Anyway my problem it's with GOG, not Windows users.

As Linux costumer (that I've been from the first game) I will not buy again a single game in GOG (Linux or Windows labeled) if insists on advertise Windows with wine as Linux games.

It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
avatar
Stendall: It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
I'm a Linux user and I strongly disagree with you.
high rated
avatar
Stendall: ...
Look, everything you say in this post applies to any game using DosBox as well, which is about half of GOG's catalogue. Most of the games on GOG do not have a Linux port legally availible - that doesn't mean it's not availible, that means it's not legally availible, two different things. At any rate, GOG promises that the installer you download will install a copy of the software which will run on your machine - they do not guarantee a native port. Again, take a look at all the DosBox releases (and yes, there are games for Windows for which native Windows versions exist, yet they run their DOS versions because Windows version proved problematic / GOG didn't have rights to release that one) - GOG can't feasibly run native-only releases.

Secondly, when outcry for Linux versions was strongest, part of the arguments of Linux users themselves was '... You can use WINE to run the older Windows games!' I'm sorry you consider yourself to be the sole speaker for Linux world, but alas, you are not. If you do not like GOG's business model, take your business elsewhere - like on Steam, I'm sure a hardcore Linuxer like you will appreciate the DRM.

Lastly, you have the operating system which is capable of seamlessly operating software from any other operating system and somehow find a reason to bitch about it! Holy shit, one of the things that impressed me about using Linux the most was that I could run most of my Windows applications without any issues. Yet some Linux users manage to consider it a bad thing, somehow.

avatar
Stendall: It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
Nope.
avatar
Stendall: Almost the half of the GOG games can be played trough Wine.
That it that way since time ago.
Just see the list of GOG games suported buy PlayonLinux. More than 200 GOG games.

I don't buyed any of my GOG games to play in WIndows. Not a single one.
And I've been playing them for a long time.

So play a Windows game on Linux it's not new. Not something that GOG invented.

Again, for the ones that only knows Windows. Selling a Windows game runing with Wine it's not the same that sell a Linux game.
And that doesn't change anything having support from GOG or not.

It's not a Linux game. And sould not be not advertised as a Linux game.
For instance there is Linux native version of Return to Castle of Wolfnstein. And there is a Windows version.
Selling the Windows version bundled with Wine it's that: A Windows version bundled with Wine. Not the Linux version.

There is a lot of Windows users in this tread, it's ok. But I think most of they thon't have enough Linux base to understand the problem here.
Anyway my problem it's with GOG, not Windows users.

As Linux costumer (that I've been from the first game) I will not buy again a single game in GOG (Linux or Windows labeled) if insists on advertise Windows with wine as Linux games.

It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
While I agree at some point with you I disagree that this is a linux vs windows problem. The idea behind GOG is to make games easily playable for the customer. They started first with windows, then with MacOS and now with Linux. The idea just saying only a native game is a real game isn't helpful for anybody who just is new to linux and just want to install and play a game. There are always ways for advanced users to make software runable, but that is and should not be the main target for gog. It can't be in the interest for linux to keep out any new users who just want to install and run software, nevertheless which system it was made for. I agree that right now the labeling isn't well done by gog, but only in respect to possible system specs problems. It should be more clear how they make the game runnable on the system (native, port, emulation, etc.), but what they sell are just games that can be easily installed and played on the listed system, nothing more. It's just about playing the game, and at the end an emulated game is always better then none game.
Post edited July 26, 2014 by DukeNukemForever
avatar
Stendall: It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
Actually it's the Mac and Linux users were the ones who requested GOG to make games run on Mac/Linux and only way to do that is DOSBox/ScummVM/Wine or some other such medhod as no native Mac/Linux native port exists (and no one will port age old game even in rare case where source code actually exist) for those games. They are the ones who've been trying to prove how easily the games can be made to run thru Wine (or one of it's forks) and where instructions can be aquired.

Also all this should not have come as surpise as GOG has already used Wine to make Windows games work on Mac for over a year now. Most seem happy finally being able to play the games on their system.

Lastly I will add that I really wish people behind Wine would port their work to Windows (there is Wine for Windows by afaik it's abandoned). There already is number of games that don't run on modern windows and there's no quarantee that MS provides backward compatibility with future versions of Windows so we'll need something else to provide backward compatibility with systems MS no longer supports. Personally I don't care what voodoo magic GOG uses to make the games run as long as they work and don't cause harm to my system.

I do agree that GOG should make it clear when DOSBox/ScummVM/Wine et all is used.

(Oh and I would not mind if GOG somohow managed to bring games from Amiga or other old computer or even some of the old consoles here and I'm fully aware only way that's possible, legal hurdles aside, is using emulators.)
Post edited July 26, 2014 by Petrell
Guess this is why GOG resisted Linux for so long...
GOG don't support Linux = whine about no Linux version and threaten to take business elsewhere.
GOG support Linux = whine about Logo, whine about WINE and whine about false advertising.

Great. -.-
avatar
k1bell: Guess this is why GOG resisted Linux for so long...
GOG don't support Linux = whine about no Linux version and threaten to take business elsewhere.
GOG support Linux = whine about Logo, whine about WINE and whine about false advertising.

Great. -.-
Whine about having to install dependensies game needs to run , whine about games not working because user refuses to install the dependensies, whine about why GOG does not supporting distro user made themselves on their spare time, whine about coding in GOG scripts, whine about GOG using this libraty instead of that, whine about using Linux instead of GNU/Linux...

;-p
avatar
Stendall: It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
Nope.
avatar
Stendall: It's that simple. And iI'm sure that most of Linux users will agree with me.
I don't need to be lumped into some absolutionist viewpoint, and can speak for myself on the issue. http://www.gog.com/forum/general/clear_mark_titles_that_include_wine/post17

Linux may have been born, and fostered by some very strong minded people, but they did it to give Linux to the world. Now the world is accepting this gift, and with that acceptance comes a myriad of people with all their conflicting viewpoints and intentions. There is no way to toss us all in a corner together, or act like we are a family of like minded individuals, or even technically inclined ones.

Linux is drafting everyday people that want to play games without needing skills, and with the assurance of support. A game that could be configured to work for someone is not the same product as one that is prepared and backed by official support when talking about everyday people.

Official support, wine wrapped or not, opens doors to those sexy linux natives we haven't had access to, which encourages more of those sexy natives to be created so that we don't have to rely on the fading star that is wine.

The world is imperfect. We simply cant go from something imperfect to perfection in one step. It almost always requires many iterations of imperfection to get somewhere good, and anyone that demands that it all happen in one fluid motion is being unrealistic, and often just in the way.
Try selling Linux games to Windows users calling them "Windows games" with 320mb of additional emulation supportfiles per game. Then see epic outrage.

WINE on GOG, ok. I don't like it but GOG can emulate whatever they like. But stop calling them "Linux games".
avatar
zerothis: Try selling Linux games to Windows users calling them "Windows games" with 320mb of additional emulation supportfiles per game. Then see epic outrage.
They're selling DOS games with DosBox calling them "Windows games".