It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
As pc's become more and more receptive to Linux and are starting to move away from the Microsoft Windows platform for sake of open platform retention, I thought I'd ask a few questions.

I'm curious about starting a Linux partition that won't corrupt my Win 7 x64 partition. I've had bad experiences in the past trying to put a 7 partition next to Win 8 (haha Microsoft, I got your joke a day late and a dollar short...) as well as trying to install XP from supposedly "Clean" source dvd's - both situations have corrupted my Windows install.

It's not a huge deal if I have to reinstall Windows, but I am looking for a distro that installs as easily next to 7 as Windows Vista does - IE I can just partition, install on the partition, and dual boot.

I'm looking for something that is easy to get into as a rookie Linux person, and something that my hardware will not have issues with.

I'm currently running an AMD Phenom II 965 Black Edition and AMD HIS 2gb 7850. If you need more hardware details I'm sure I can pull them. OS is currently Win 7 x64 Home Premium.

I seem to remember mentions of Mint and Ubuntu being popular choices. Thanks in advance for your thoughts, I truly think that the PC platform is going to drastically shift to Linux within the next 5 years, based largely on Valve's recent move to creating their own Linux distro and the legions of fans that will use it.

I do realize that a large portion of my gaming library will be incompatible, at least without the right distributables. Please treat me as a "knows nothing about Linux" type of person.
avatar
Leucius: As pc's become more and more receptive to Linux and are starting to move away from the Microsoft Windows platform for sake of open platform retention, [...]
I do realize that a large portion of my gaming library will be incompatible, at least without the right distributables. Please treat me as a "knows nothing about Linux" type of person.
Going away from MS means not necessary going away from the Windows infrastructure & becoming incompatible.
Also, Linux is not without alternatives (especially as the unix foundation is pretty ill-suited for personal computing). Also, it could be argued that by "openess" the window platform was far more "open" than the centralized distro ecosystem of linux, so it makes sense to preserve the enourmous app foundation of windows and the open platform while creating a open and free source OS.

For instance, ReactOS, tries to achieve this: a free and open source OS compatible with Win. Also, making good progress recently on compatibility (but still much stuff to do)... and recently (yesterday!) they started a promissing Kickstarter
(Project Website) which could lead to an development jump and wider awareness.

PS: as last note, I'm not convinced that the SteamOS (even when base on free Linux) will finally lead to a open platform, currently it is locked Valve controlled thing, not better or even worse than plainly windows as platform.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by shaddim
Well I use Ubuntu so, I'm biased towards it. When installing, you will have to look for two checkboxes in the installer which read along the lines of "install third party codecs and flash" and " install non-free/proprietary drivers". Checking those boxes will give you a system that can play music in mp3, aac , etc formats and flash videos along with the ATI/AMD proprietary drivers. Mint, while using the same installer and most of the Ubuntu packages, does not provide those options until after install. Don't know why.

I've not yet seen a distro that will harm your existing Windows, Linux installs. They will resize partitions automatically if that is your choice, or you can come up with a partitioning scheme of your own. The bootloader can be installed either in the MBR of the drive - GRUB will recognize Windows and various other OSes and will provide menu entries that allow you to boot them - or on the linux partitions but in this case you need to use something like EasyBCD to tell ntldr what to boot. I usually install the linux bootloaders in the MBR.

For running Windows programs on Linux you can use vanilla Wine, PlayOnLinux (free, uses wine internally, provides wizard to install stuff) or CrossOver (commercial solution, provides easy ways to install a large variety of Windows programs/games, has a trial period which allows you to evaluate the product)
avatar
Leucius: It's not a huge deal if I have to reinstall Windows, but I am looking for a distro that installs as easily next to 7 as Windows Vista does - IE I can just partition, install on the partition, and dual boot.

I'm looking for something that is easy to get into as a rookie Linux person, and something that my hardware will not have issues with.

I'm currently running an AMD Phenom II 965 Black Edition and AMD HIS 2gb 7850. If you need more hardware details I'm sure I can pull them. OS is currently Win 7 x64 Home Premium.

I seem to remember mentions of Mint and Ubuntu being popular choices. Thanks in advance for your thoughts, I truly think that the PC platform is going to drastically shift to Linux within the next 5 years, based largely on Valve's recent move to creating their own Linux distro and the legions of fans that will use it.

I do realize that a large portion of my gaming library will be incompatible, at least without the right distributables. Please treat me as a "knows nothing about Linux" type of person.
Mint and Ubuntu are probably the ones you want to be looking at then. Mint in particular has less of a strict perspective on the use of proprietary software - that means that proprietary codecs are installed by default. All of the stuff that Mint installs by default can be installed in Ubuntu retroactively. The software repositories also work with each other.

One of the big differences with Mint is that it sticks to the traditional GNOME user interface. Up to version 2, GNOME resembled MacOS in terms of operation. GNOME 3 has since diversified from that and is a nice, unique, if not slightly counter-intuitive interface. Ubuntu uses Unity, which is an interface that has more in common with Windows 7, but is rather glitchy and unpredictable. The Ubuntu team really did introduce it before it was ready.

I've considered attempting a switch to Mint, but I've been using Ubuntu for ten years now and old habits die hard. I find that I use Windows for gaming and work nowadays and Linux for everything else (development, personal organisation, creativity etc.). I would certainly consider starting out with Mint if you're new to Linux.

A couple of thoughts on your gaming:

* A fair number of Windows games will run on Linux OSs through WINE, just like on a Mac (actually, WINE was predominantly a Linux project until it gained traction on Mac a few years ago following Rosetta's "retirement")
* All of the DOS and ScummVM games on GOG will run natively under Linux in the respective Linux versions of DOSBox and ScummVM. You will need to unpack installers using WINE or innoextract.
* Steam obviously also has a Linux version, although I've found it to be incredibly buggy. Most games seem to work well, but the Steam client has a nasty habit of crashing regularly. There's a surprisingly large number of games for Linux under Steam.
* You'll want to look at the excellent PlayOnLinux, which automates a lot of the above processes.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by jamyskis
avatar
jamyskis: * Steam obviously also has a Linux version, although I've found it to be incredibly buggy. Most games seem to work well, but the Steam client has a nasty habit of crashing regularly.
source: https://github.com/ValveSoftware/steam-for-linux/issues nearly 1000 issues.

Ultimate reason is the highly fragmented nature of the distro focussed linux ecosystem. Steam might become the long missing focus point but in a way we will not enjoy it, as most likely it will lead to a locked, walled garden app store infrastructure not a open marketplace (like Windows now).

Also, currently Steam pushes the acceptance of DRM under the linux folks ... it's horrfying.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by shaddim
avatar
shaddim: Ultimate reason is the highly fragmented nature of the distro focussed linux ecosystem. Steam might become the long missing focus point but in a way we will not enjoy it, as most likely it will lead to a locked, walled garden app store infrastructure not a open marketplace (like Windows now).
Steam is not designed for Linux universally - the only distro supported is Ubuntu, and all those issues arise under Ubuntu. It has nothing to do with fragmentation.

Also, at least half of those issues relate to games, not the Steam client itself.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by jamyskis
avatar
shaddim: Ultimate reason is the highly fragmented nature of the distro focussed linux ecosystem. Steam might become the long missing focus point but in a way we will not enjoy it, as most likely it will lead to a locked, walled garden app store infrastructure not a open marketplace (like Windows now).
avatar
jamyskis: Steam is not designed for Linux universally - the only distro supported is Ubuntu, and all those issues arise under Ubuntu. It has nothing to do with fragmentation.

Also, at least half of those issues relate to games, not the Steam client itself.
Officially they support only Ubuntu, so Steam shouldn't be advertised with "Linux support". On the other hand, they accept bug reports of other distros (see them marked as invalid?), so this is about fragmentation and the strange schizophrenic nature of the linux ecosystem overall.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by shaddim
Bah, I knew this was going to turn into a stupid flame war.
avatar
silviucc: Bah, I knew this was going to turn into a stupid flame war.
*He* don't summon it! ;) Not if we try to keep it focussed, it's christmas... :D
Post edited December 24, 2013 by shaddim
Well, I use Linux for a few years now and started with Ubuntu. I would recommend Linux Mint these days though, since it is based on Ubuntu and therefore has all of its advantages, plus fixes some problems a new user might have with Ubuntu these days. It is also the most used distribution by far, so you should be able to find solutions for your problems very quickly in the Wiki and forums.

Before you think about installing it on your HDD, you should think about testing it first (I am assuming you have not done that yet, if you have, ignore this note). There are many ways to do so, for example running the OS in a virtual environment, or using a Live-DVD. Just search for this terms and you will find many tutorials and explanations.
Thanks for all the advice.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by Leucius
I'd recommend Mint myself, especially for old Windows users. Here's a few tips

1. Use a LiveDVD to try Linux before installing anything. You can use UNetbootin to create a LiveUSB from a DVD image (see http://unetbootin.sourceforge.net/) which would save burning a DVD.

2. When you want to install, shrink the Windows partition from within Windows using Windows tools. (see http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/magazine/gg309170.aspx). This should (hopefully) prevent you from accidentally breaking anything (unless there is a power cut...)

3. Use the manual or advanced Linux install to make sure the installer doesn't overwrite Windows.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by ChrisSD
avatar
Leucius: As pc's become more and more receptive to Linux and are starting to move away from the Microsoft Windows platform for sake of open platform retention, I thought I'd ask a few questions.
Not really, Windows and Mac still get user-friendliness in a way Linux distros can't.

On the mobile market for example, Windows 8 tablets and Ipads are the main players. Android is the third player here.

The problem with Linux is that you have some extremely technically gifted folks leading the charge and on a subconscious level, they don't truly grasp the limitations of the non-technically gifted potential user. It's a bit of an elitist decision-making process.

Windows and Mac are where they are because they are prepared to go all the way in "dumbing it down" for the everyday user.

Just to be clear, I'm routing for Linux, but on another level, I don't think those guys will manage to do what it takes to be #1 with the everyday consumer. On the server market with geeks at the helm, yes, but not on the desktop market with "I can't be bothered to learn this shit" types. And to a certain extend, they are right. Using their computer shouldn't be rocket science for everyday tasks.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by Magnitus
I do not think this is true.
In fact, Linux distributions can be more user-friendly than Windows or Mac OS.
For example, there are the software repositories. You can install trusted and tested packages from one place and install updates for all your applications with one click, instead of searching for anything in the wide fields of the Internet for downloading and installing and updating... with the risk to install an awful and useless toolbar if you do not pay attention.
Then there are viruses for Windows especially, you have to protect your system with third-party firewalls in order to feel safe, while there are none for Linux. This can be explained by the small market share Linux has, but also by the strict subdivision in normal users and administrators.
Plus, you can customize Linux in any way if you want to, which is a big bonus for me personally. Man, you cannot even hide the Windows Start Orb if you want to without third-party stuff!

Linux is successful in every area except the desktop, and that is because of the pre-installs. If Linux would be installed on every PC by default, the situation would change completely. Big companies would support the Linux Kernel in a way they support Windows now and people would easily learn Linux, since it is just different and not hard.

So, to use Linux is not rocket science at all, you do not have to use the Terminal these days (although it can make things happen even faster).

The situation is as it is though. People are used to operate on a Windows machine and this will not change in the foreseeable future. Linux has an image of being nerdy and difficult to learn, so it will remain a niche on the desktop.
But I am fine with that.

Since this whole post has nothing to do with the question, here are some links to useful information:

Linux Mint
VirtualBox
DistroWatch
How to Find the Perfect Linux Distribution for You
I've been using Linux Mint KDE edition as my main OS for almost a year now (installed on 4 systems) and my experience with it has been extremely positive. It's actually been a lot easier to use and adjust to than I was expecting (I had no prior experience with Linux, having only used DOS & Windows before) & has generally been about as easy to use as Windows; I've even got KDE set up much like I have Windows 7 so it feels very familiar.

I rarely need to reboot into Windows now - it's only necessary for any Windows games that I can't get to run in CrossOver. Everything else either has a native Linux version available, a native Linux alternative or runs fine in Wine/CrossOver... speaking of which, Wine/CrossOver performance and compatibility has improved quite significantly over the past year. I'm hoping that by the time support for Windows 7 ends I'll be able to just dump Windows completely.


avatar
Magnitus: Not really, Windows and Mac still get user-friendliness in a way Linux distros can't.
In my experience Mint is very user-friendly, almost as much as Windows even. That's not to say there aren't many improvements to be made, but it certainly does seem to be getting there.
... Windows 8 tablets ... main players ... Android is the third player here.
Windows 8 tablets one of the "main players"? And Android is the "third player"? Really?

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/12/04/android_tablets_to_outsell_laptops_by_2017_idc/ (scroll down to "Tablet OS Market Share, 2012 - 2017")