It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
I've been using Ubuntu for years, but can't speak of other distros as I've never really tried them.

Recently, I had to reinstall Ubuntu to a new hard drive as well as Windows 7 on another one (not dual booting), and I was surprised how fast it was to install Ubuntu and set everything up. On the other hand, it takes forever to install every update for Windows, it's incredibly slow.

I was dual-booting years ago but not anymore. I remember it was best to install Windows first and Linux after in order to have the start up menu correctly, but it may have changed now. If you don't start from scratch, I wonder how well it works to resize your Windows partition to create a new one.
avatar
Leucius:
You should really look at the DVD boot versions of Mint and Ubuntu as they will give you a good idea of what you are looking at moving into.
Then if you like what you have been using you could always install Virtual Box with the version of Linux you preferred and test it a while inside of your normal windows (the instructions are really easy to follow) before making your system a duel boot system. This will help you decide for what usage your system will become.

Will you be booting in Windows for gaming, work, pleasure, internet?
Will you be able to set up and play games in Linux, can you work in Libra Office, listen to your music and can you live using Firefox or its subsidiary browsers?


Urnoev has already supplied you with links.
avatar
Urnoev: Since this whole post has nothing to do with the question, here are some links to useful information:

Linux Mint
VirtualBox
DistroWatch
How to Find the Perfect Linux Distribution for You
avatar
Urnoev: For example, there are the software repositories.
Central, distro focussed software repositories are the core architectural mistake of the linux ecosystem and a pita for users. It takes away the user's freedom to install the software they want in the version they want. It mixes up system and apps, it plainly wrong an anachronism rooting back to unix. Read about the negative implications in this accepted ubunutu bug report, the opinion of kernel developer molnar or even this rant by debian founder ian murdock.

avatar
Urnoev: Linux is successful in every area except the desktop, and that is because of the pre-installs.
No, this meme was debunked with the failure of linux on the netbooks. Originally, netbooks were delivered with linux. But, as the return rates were so high with linux based one, all producers had to switch to XP whcih made the customers happy.

avatar
Urnoev: So, to use Linux is not rocket science at all, you do not have to use the Terminal these days (although it can make things happen even faster).
Wrong, the base design is built around the console, all the fun and power comes from the console. GUIs are just secondary sugar on top, added later. But that's also the reason for the inconsistent and permanentely breaking of UX: GUIs and non-developers are treated as secondary extensions of a base system mainly designed for developers. On MacOS it is vice versa: the GUI and UX for end-user is king. That there is additionally a shell available is of secondary importance.
Right, software repositories have a lot of disadvantages and they are certainly not the perfect solution, but I think the advantages are worth the disadvantages in this case, at least for me. I think we can agree there is a lot to improve in this area anyway.

Of course consumers do not want to learn use Linux on their netbook when they used Windows on their desktop for years. In order to make the Linux successful on the desktop it should have been pre-installed from the beginning. Obviously we cannot change this now, so I personally also do not think Linux can be successful on the desktop. And it does not have to.

Yes, the console is the key. But you do not have to use it. We are talking about a normal person, someone who wants to do some surfing, writing letters and listening to music. You do not need to use the Terminal for anything basic, the GUI does it well enough. And anyone who wants to do advanced stuff should not be afraid of the console anyway.

This conversation becomes more and more off topic, I suggest to write further messages per PM or create a new thread if anyone else is interested. But I made my point and honestly do not want to argue about this.
avatar
Urnoev: Of course consumers do not want to learn use Linux on their netbook when they used Windows on their desktop for years. In order to make the Linux successful on the desktop it should have been pre-installed from the beginning.
I would argue it is arrogance to expect the users to chance, why millions of users should drop their experience, their expertise? Because some geeks think it is fun to make everything different for the sake of being different without good reason?

avatar
Urnoev: Obviously we cannot change this now, so I personally also do not think Linux can be successful on the desktop. And it does not have to.
It has to, it has the responsibility. If not all this "Free software for the people" by the GNU would be meaningless.
avatar
Urnoev: This conversation becomes more and more off topic, I suggest to write further messages per PM or create a new thread if anyone else is interested. But I made my point and honestly do not want to argue about this.
This discussion is spot on: the original question was "linux: preparing for the future". As linux failed for decades to provide a desktop future, I gave up my hope that it will ever do and came to conclusion the foundation must be foul... so better not mislead the OT into a false future hope, it is very questionable if linux in its current form provide any future on the desktop. Could be that Valve provide one... but I'm not sure if we will like the resulting ecosystem then.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by shaddim
avatar
jamyskis: Mint and Ubuntu are probably the ones you want to be looking at then.
I'm not too excited about Ubuntu anymore because frankly the company behind it, Canonical, just seems to want to be another Microsoft or Valve. Like http://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2013/10/ubuntu-wins-big-brother-austria-privacy-award or I recall some earlier argument where Canonical didn't want to co-operate with other distros and/or Linux Foundation (sorry I don't recall the actual details), even saying that they (Canonical) don't consider Ubuntu as "Linux", hence they can do whatever they want.

So for home use I prefer Mint, even if it is still based on Ubuntu (which is based on Debian etc. etc.). But if one does not care Canonical's power struggles, I guess Ubuntu is fine too.
avatar
Leucius: I'm looking for something that is easy to get into as a rookie Linux person, and something that my hardware will not have issues with.
I have overall had good experience running different Linux distros on different (mainly a bit older) PCs, so from my point of view the HW compatibility is usually good. But then I haven't really e.g. tried to run 3D games on Linux and such, not sure if there are some issues or quirks with them from distro to distro, but I am talking about generic desktop use (including also audio support). I think I needed to look a bit for some generic drivers to get basic 3D support for e.g. my ancient ATI X800 Pro graphics card in Mint.

I think if you want to check beforehand whether there are major HW compatibility issues, you could run e.g. a "live CD" session of a distro, without installing Linux yet. If that seems to run without major problems, your HW is apparently compatible. In fact, at least earlier many Linux distros were installed exactly like that, ie. you first booted with a live CD to a running Linux desktop (which gives you a confirmation that it runs fine on your PC), after which you initiate the actual Linux installation from that session.

I prefer Mint for home use over Ubuntu, for e.g. reasons I mentioned before (Canonical, the maker of Ubuntu, seems to have a bit of power hungry mentality nowadays, as if they see other Linux distros as their enemies or something; maybe I am exaggerating, but anyway). On the other hand, if you feel you'd like to possibly use Linux professionally (on your studies, or maybe even work, becoming a Linux administrator etc.), some distro closer to RedHat Linux might be a better idea because I think RHEL is the most widely used Linux distro in the corporate world. In that case I recommend e.g. CentOS, which is based in RedHat, kind of a free version of it. I've run also CentOS on my home PCs, not only Ubuntu or Mint. But if your interests are mainly for home use and gaming, I guess Ubuntu or Mint are a more safe (= widely used at home PCs) choice.

If you want to get a feeling for different Linux distros before deciding which to install, you can e.g. install the free VMWare Player on your Windows 7, and install as many different Linux distros in it as you want, side by side, without affecting your Win7 installation at all yet. You can get rid of those virtual Linux installations very easily (even by just uninstalling VMWare Player) without leaving a trace to your system, when you have finally decided which of them you want to install properly.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by timppu
I have a question. I've read that you need a swap partition when running Linux. Is that taken care of during the installation or is it something you have to do manually? And if it's the latter, how does one decide on the location and size of it?
avatar
HypersomniacLive: I have a question. I've read that you need a swap partition when running Linux. Is that taken care of during the installation or is it something you have to do manually? And if it's the latter, how does one decide on the location and size of it?
You don't technically need a swap partition* but it is strongly recommended. Most Linux install programs will create swap automatically if you let it take care of partitioning. If you do manual partitioning (perhaps because you want to dual boot with Windows) then you'd have to create it yourself. This should be easy enough to do within the install.

The suggestion is to make the partition as big (or slightly bigger) than your RAM size, unless you have very low RAM in which case you may want to use up to twice as much.

The location doesn't really matter so long as it's on a hard drive that's always available. It preferably shouldn't be on an SSD because it could be written to a lot.


* instead of a partition you can use a swap file (harder to set up), or go without if you have loads and loads of RAM and don't need to hibernate.
avatar
ChrisSD: You don't technically need a swap partition* but it is strongly recommended. Most Linux install programs will create swap automatically if you let it take care of partitioning. If you do manual partitioning (perhaps because you want to dual boot with Windows) then you'd have to create it yourself. This should be easy enough to do within the install.

The suggestion is to make the partition as big (or slightly bigger) than your RAM size, unless you have very low RAM in which case you may want to use up to twice as much.

The location doesn't really matter so long as it's on a hard drive that's always available. It preferably shouldn't be on an SSD because it could be written to a lot.


* instead of a partition you can use a swap file (harder to set up), or go without if you have loads and loads of RAM and don't need to hibernate.
So, basically it's the equivalent of the Windows pagefile. And if you want to dual boot with Windows you need to create the partition manually. Did I get it right?

What if you do want to dual boot with Windows, but have left plenty of unallocated space on the HDD to fit both the Linux OS and the swap partition? Would the swap partition be taken care of during installation or would all unallocated space be used up by the Linux OS itself?

And how much is "loads and loads" of RAM in order to not keep a swap partition?
True, you should create a swap partition, I have 16GB RAM and still use 16GB swap.
It is really easy too and should be mentioned in any good tutorial for this kind of things.
avatar
HypersomniacLive: So, basically it's the equivalent of the Windows pagefile.
Yep.

avatar
HypersomniacLive: And if you want to dual boot with Windows you need to create the partition manually. Did I get it right?
On modern user friendly Linux distros (like Ubuntu and Mint) I think if it detects Windows then there is now an option to automatically and safely resize the Windows partition. I'm still a bit wary of this personally but I'm probably just being paranoid. Doing so will create a swap partition for you.

avatar
HypersomniacLive: What if you do want to dual boot with Windows, but have left plenty of unallocated space on the HDD to fit both the Linux OS and the swap partition? Would the swap partition be taken care of during installation or would all unallocated space be used up by the Linux OS itself?
Yep it will be taken care of for you. By default it's sized to match your RAM.
And how much is "loads and loads" of RAM in order to not keep a swap partition?
Erm... it depends on what you're doing. To be honest I'd always recommend having some swap just in case you run out of memory. For normal usage 32 gb is probably plenty (heck even 16), more than that would be loads and loads. However if you're editing large image files or movies with lots of tabs open in your browser, etc then it's possible you'd run out memory. In that case I think Linux will try to recover memory by closing programs or other files you have opened which is not a good situation to be in.

If you have a swap partition then it's no problem, it just dumps memory that's not being used into the swap partition (like the Windows swap file) and you can just carry on as if nothing had happened. And really hard drive space is quite cheap so you can usually spare a few gigs at least.
I have 8GB of RAM, don't have any swap space and it's yet to cause me any problems. I also have the pagefile disabled on my Windows install (have always had it disabled ever since I built this system a few years ago) and have had no problems there either.
Post edited December 24, 2013 by adamhm
avatar
ChrisSD: snip

On modern user friendly Linux distros (like Ubuntu and Mint) I think if it detects Windows then there is now an option to automatically and safely resize the Windows partition. I'm still a bit wary of this personally but I'm probably just being paranoid. Doing so will create a swap partition for you.

snip
Thanks for the reply.

Just one more thing, if you (or anyone else) know.
In case you leave enough unallocated space to be used for the Linux installation, would the distro still try to resize the Windows partition in order to do its automated thing (Linux install + swap partition)? Because if it does, it's stupid.

And yes, I'd never let anything "automatically" resize my Widows partition either.
Keep WINE in mind. The transition won't be easy and you'll be wanting an ethernet cable handy to get the first updates and packages.