It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
Runehamster: And on a side note, my analogy was perfect. I am well aware that test driving a car does NOT give you access to the full thing - you can't discover road mileage, you can't see how long it takes you to get to Grandma's, you don't have time to realize that the seat gives you a backache. Stealing a car would permit you to do these things, but it doesn't change the fact that you just committed a felony.
avatar
GoJays2025: I'm not saying it's not a crime. Speeding is a crime, yet very seldom do you see somebody driving at or below the speed limit - in fact you may even be frustrated driving behind one of those people. What I just want to say is that just because it's illegal doesn't make somebody a monster for doing it.
I agree completely with this statement. My issue is with the flawed argument, not the person. I know many people who pirate regularly that I enjoy chatting with. I suppose the problem here is that the assumption is if I post criticizing piracy, a person takes that as a personal attack upon them. It is a disagreement with their standards of morality, yes - but that sort of thing happens everyday with religious differences, and I still get along very well with people of various religions. I just appreciate when people admit that they are committing an illegal act for personal gain, instead of trying to claim that they have a 'right' to entertainment.
avatar
Runehamster: Regardless of the physical impossibility of a digital message board producing a suction force, I can indeed see how my OP was inflammatory. I intended it to be so. There is no justification for committing an illegal act to gain access to someone else's intellectual properties. Your argument is invalid, because we aren't talking about food or oxygen or medication, we're talking about entertainment. Nobody ever fought and died to give you the right to have access to quality entertainment.
You are caught up in legalities, which I have no interest in talking about. Many, many people fought and died to give us the right to create artwork, which is an integral part of both our society and our economics. I'm so tired of hearing this "because you will die if you don't need it, PhoenixWright is automatically wrong. I have the power to invalidate arguments so that I don't have to respond to them meaningfully."
avatar
Runehamster: Regardless of the physical impossibility of a digital message board producing a suction force, I can indeed see how my OP was inflammatory. I intended it to be so. There is no justification for committing an illegal act to gain access to someone else's intellectual properties. Your argument is invalid, because we aren't talking about food or oxygen or medication, we're talking about entertainment. Nobody ever fought and died to give you the right to have access to quality entertainment.
avatar
PhoenixWright: You are caught up in legalities, which I have no interest in talking about. Many, many people fought and died to give us the right to create artwork, which is an integral part of both our society and our economics. I'm so tired of hearing this "because you will die if you don't need it, PhoenixWright is automatically wrong. I have the power to invalidate arguments so that I don't have to respond to them meaningfully."
Then you are saying laws are irrelevant if they are inconvenient and annoying? I'm sorry, I don't mean to come off as sarcastic, but the only argument you've offered is that you might buy something that you don't like or can't run if you don't pirate it first. I understand that you desire more transparency from game developers, but I honestly don't see how they can improve upon what they already do. They already offer demos (which in some cases are the full game, they're merely timed) for you to try, there are full system requirements listed on the websites of every game company I've ever visited, and you always have the internet to read up on games before you purchase them. Admittedly it takes time and energy to look up and find all these things, but just because you don't like laws that keep you from doing what you wish doesn't mean those laws don't apply to you. Yes, I am caught up in the legality of the matter, because that's all there is. Beyond that, you have the mental equivalent of might-makes-right, where the mere fact that a hacker can crack a game means that he has the 'right' to do so.
avatar
Runehamster: Then you are saying laws are irrelevant if they are inconvenient and annoying? I'm sorry, I don't mean to come off as sarcastic, but the only argument you've offered is that you might buy something that you don't like or can't run if you don't pirate it first.
Thanks for the actual response this time. Sarcastic? No, you've summarized my point beautifully, although you slipped "you might buy something that you don't like" into my mouth, when all I said is the "can't run" part. With the internet, it's absolutely possible to tell if you'll like a game or not (unless the game's terrible parts are not shown). But what is the problem with my argument?

You said, in the original post: Good news for pirates that pirate games to try them! Google!
I said: You may buy something you can't run (either because of your computer specs or because it's broken) if you don't pirate it first. Google can't exactly answer this question for you, as you have a unique configuration.

I am going to respond to other things you said, but what is wrong with the above? Don't you think the people with ATI cards would have been happier not buying NFS Shift on release when it was discovered that there were some big problems with it? And in this case, the law is exorcising the very "might-is-right" mentality that you mentioned, because those customers probably couldn't return the game unless they raised a bit of hell. Screw legality, if it's going to screw me. No, not be inconvenient, no, not be annoying, but actually take money from me for nothing in return.

Also, I don't think the legality of cracking games is completely defined, because I am legally allowed a backup copy that would need "illegal" activities to obtain. More "might-is-right" from the law, keeping me from exorcising my full rights upon my purchases. Again, not inconvenient, not annoying, but actually trying to remove one of my rights.

EDIT: See The Escapist's open letter for more complaints about games that don't work.
Post edited October 27, 2010 by PhoenixWright
high rated
Other peoples opinions can be wrong i have played games, seen movies that people have considered universally bad and i have found they weren't that bad (despite what people say i have kept Uwe Boll Movies, though the majority are crap, but it's not like he's only person who makes bad movies) and the stuff that everyone seems to really like i can find really boring. Reviews i have found tend to be better used as a guide as opposed to letting it stop from seeing a movie or playing a game.
Post edited October 27, 2010 by Master911
avatar
Master911: Other peoples opinions can be wrong i have played games, seen movies that people have considered universally bad and i have they weren't that bad and the stuff that everyone seems to really like i can find really boring. Reviews i have found tend to be better used as a guide as opposed to letting it stop from seeing a movie or playing a game
This is a good point, however a good review will state what features are in the game and what the reviewer finds good and bad, I knew I was going to like StarCraft II before it came out without ever playing it, because it was in a genre I like, in a series i like made by a company that generally makes solid games. I know I don't like Twilight without ever watching a film or reading a book in the series. Those are choices one as a consumer has to make.
avatar
Orryyrro: This is a good point, however a good review will state what features are in the game and what the reviewer finds good and bad, I knew I was going to like StarCraft II before it came out without ever playing it, because it was in a genre I like, in a series i like made by a company that generally makes solid games. I know I don't like Twilight without ever watching a film or reading a book in the series. Those are choices one as a consumer has to make.
You're just picking extremes here. The majority of products out today are in that middle ground, where you don't know if you'd like it or not. Can you honestly tell me you haven't bought ANYTHING that you later regretted, even after research? When you don't have a lot of disposable income every little purchase (and a $50 game would be a pretty big purchase in that case) needs to be made carefully.
Post edited October 27, 2010 by GoJays2025
avatar
Runehamster: Then you are saying laws are irrelevant if they are inconvenient and annoying? I'm sorry, I don't mean to come off as sarcastic, but the only argument you've offered is that you might buy something that you don't like or can't run if you don't pirate it first.
avatar
PhoenixWright: Thanks for the actual response this time. Sarcastic? No, you've summarized my point beautifully, although you slipped "you might buy something that you don't like" into my mouth, when all I said is the "can't run" part. With the internet, it's absolutely possible to tell if you'll like a game or not (unless the game's terrible parts are not shown). But what is the problem with my argument?

You said, in the original post: Good news for pirates that pirate games to try them! Google!
I said: You may buy something you can't run (either because of your computer specs or because it's broken) if you don't pirate it first. Google can't exactly answer this question for you, as you have a unique configuration.

I am going to respond to other things you said, but what is wrong with the above? Don't you think the people with ATI cards would have been happier not buying NFS Shift on release when it was discovered that there were some big problems with it? And in this case, the law is exorcising the very "might-is-right" mentality that you mentioned, because those customers probably couldn't return the game unless they raised a bit of hell. Screw legality, if it's going to screw me. No, not be inconvenient, no, not be annoying, but actually take money from me for nothing in return.

Also, I don't think the legality of cracking games is completely defined, because I am legally allowed a backup copy that would need "illegal" activities to obtain. More "might-is-right" from the law, keeping me from exorcising my full rights upon my purchases. Again, not inconvenient, not annoying, but actually trying to remove one of my rights.

EDIT: See The Escapist's open letter for more complaints about games that don't work.
You're right, the issue of 'liking' it was from another conversation. I do beg your pardon, I'm on day two of my cold-turkey caffeine diet. I'm afraid that the issue you speak of can be legally resolved by waiting until the game you want has been out for a little while - then you can easily discover with a quick Google search whether there are hardware incompatibilities. For instance, I have all the requirements I need to play the UFO series on GOG, but I found out with the version I purchased a year ago on Steam that my old ATI card is the only brand not supported. And that is not mentioned in official system requirements on most sale pages. This was my fault, however, since a quick google search would probably have found the answer. If I had bought the game when it first appeared, then no, I would not have known this. Regardless, it is still illegal to download pirated copies of a game to see if they'll run. I understand this can be resented, but it is better to pressure companies to put a testing device on their websites (similar to systemrequirementlab's) than it is to commit a crime for a piece of entertainment that can probably be exchanged for a different piece of entertainment without any real loss of amusement.

In regards to your second comment, about the legality of cracking games, this is one area where I would absolutely agree with you. It is unconscionable that those who have legally purchased games have to suffer with copy protection and DRM's. I despise it, hence why I buy physical copies of console games and handhelds, and GOG games. I refuse to break the laws they have in place, so I refuse to play their games. On the other hand, some will recall that many games used to be distributed as freeware or shareware, with extremely crude DRM in the form of a cd-key being used sometimes to prevent piracy. As piracy became more prevalent, the Draconian copy protection we see now became more common.

Finally, I recently was told of a service called 'Gamefly'. I am not at all trying to be sarcastic when I suggest this as another option; apparently it has a system similar to Netflix's, but with video games, and thus would be a splendid option for trying games to see if they will function on a system. And to preclude any argument here, yes, I acknowledge that they might not have the specific game you want, in which case my original post stands - the only legal way of checking is by spending time doing the research.
Post edited October 27, 2010 by Runehamster
Just because you should like a game doesn't mean you will. I should have like Halo, but I think it's a piece of crap that I regret buying. I should have like Bioshock, but I didn't, ect. Those are both games that, if you'll notice, people will go out of their way to praise and hold up high. Reviews won't cover everything.

Edit: About cracking games that you have legally bought, I am all for that too, especially in the case of Ubisoft's Permanant Online connection deal. Sadly, however, since I am a PC guy, Gamefly doesn't really help me. And as far as System Requirements Lab, which I love, they aren't always accurate either. My computer should be able to run Call of Duty 4, but even with everything turned down as low as they can go, I can get, if I'm lucky, 5 FPS.
Post edited October 27, 2010 by doccarnby
avatar
Orryyrro: This is a good point, however a good review will state what features are in the game and what the reviewer finds good and bad, I knew I was going to like StarCraft II before it came out without ever playing it, because it was in a genre I like, in a series i like made by a company that generally makes solid games. I know I don't like Twilight without ever watching a film or reading a book in the series. Those are choices one as a consumer has to make.
avatar
GoJays2025: You're just picking extremes here. The majority of products out today are in that middle ground, where you don't know if you'd like it or not. Can you honestly tell me you haven't bought ANYTHING that you later regretted, even after research? When you don't have a lot of disposable income every little purchase (and a $50 game would be a pretty big purchase in that case) needs to be made carefully.
Yes, I am picking extremes, but if it isn't in the almost-definite-like category I won't buy it until the price has been reduced, I've heard what others have said about it, and so on. The last time I was really burned with a purchase was probably around 6 years ago.
avatar
Runehamster: Seriously. My point is that more and more, I'm hearing this given as a reason. For a while it was 'I hate DRM' or 'I bought a legal copy too', and now it's 'I want to try it before I buy it'. I'm sorry, that isn't a right. That's like my jacking a 'cedes to see how it drives before I buy one. You'd say I was a crazy fool when I can testdrive it at the lot - that's what google is all about.
avatar
GameRager: STOP comparing physical theft)in this case GRAND THEFT FRIGGING AUTO FFS) to stealing intellectual property....do you even know or CARE about the differences or are you just strawmanning against our strawmanning to see which of our views sticks the best? :\

1. Steal a car....and car owner doesn't have car anymore.
2. Copy something....owner still has original.

Guess I better not make a copy of a book from the library then on a photocopier cuz it's STEALING. :eek:

OH, and BTW, you seem to be just as intent to blindly berate piracy as we are to support it....and most of your info seems heavily biased and based on anti-piracy propaganda.
This is what I hear reading all of his posts lol http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWf_jbrpn4o
avatar
Runehamster: And on a side note, my analogy was perfect. I am well aware that test driving a car does NOT give you access to the full thing - you can't discover road mileage, you can't see how long it takes you to get to Grandma's, you don't have time to realize that the seat gives you a backache. Stealing a car would permit you to do these things, but it doesn't change the fact that you just committed a felony.
Okay, I know you're trying to make a point, but seriously, you need to get away from the whole physical property examples, they don't work.

Also, legality and morality don't always match. So be careful there. In fact some laws make no sense whatsoever. Some do but are flawed, how long have people been trying to legalize pot in the US? Lobbying for change, even by large numbers of people, doesn't always work. In fact, sometimes the situation just continues to deteriorate. And I like the pot example, because in the 20s the US threw a fit about alcohol being made illegal and guess what, it's legal again.

Also, I like Jeff Vogel's take on piracy. Btw, I don't pirate cause I can afford not to and I'm lazy, that doesn't mean there aren't people who aren't easting saltines for the last two weeks of every month. http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/07/sometimes-its-ok-to-steal-my-games.html
Post edited October 27, 2010 by orcishgamer
avatar
Runehamster: Seriously. My point is that more and more, I'm hearing this given as a reason. For a while it was 'I hate DRM' or 'I bought a legal copy too', and now it's 'I want to try it before I buy it'. I'm sorry, that isn't a right. That's like my jacking a 'cedes to see how it drives before I buy one. You'd say I was a crazy fool when I can testdrive it at the lot - that's what google is all about.
avatar
GameRager: STOP comparing physical theft)in this case GRAND THEFT FRIGGING AUTO FFS) to stealing intellectual property....do you even know or CARE about the differences or are you just strawmanning against our strawmanning to see which of our views sticks the best? :\

1. Steal a car....and car owner doesn't have car anymore.
2. Copy something....owner still has original.

Guess I better not make a copy of a book from the library then on a photocopier cuz it's STEALING. :eek:

OH, and BTW, you seem to be just as intent to blindly berate piracy as we are to support it....and most of your info seems heavily biased and based on anti-piracy propaganda.
Yes. Yes I am. You see, our difference of opinion lies not with the pirating itself, but with laws and legality. I see breaking the law as wrong, and you see the as a limitation on your capability to enjoy quality entertainment.

And your demand that I stop comparing digital theft to physical theft is rather odd. I'm not sure I see how it makes a difference. If you are arguing that physical theft is worse because you are depriving another purchaser of something, then why is it permissible to deprive a company of their money for making a game? And please do not answer that you would not have purchased the game anyway. I could very well say that I would not purchase a Lexus anyway, so stealing one from the car lot before they are shipped to a dealership is hurting only the company, and is permissible because I would not have purchased one anyway. I know your response will be that no, this is a physical object that had to be built, but games actually do require people and man-hours to complete, and these are resources that also cost money.

And yes, I intend to keep comparing car theft to video game theft because it amuses me and seems to have many parallels :D
avatar
Runehamster: I see breaking the law as wrong, and you see the as a limitation on your capability to enjoy quality entertainment.
Please tell me your entire argument doesn't hinge on "breaking the law == wrong". That is provably false. Laws, of themselves, carry no morality.
avatar
Runehamster: I see breaking the law as wrong, and you see the as a limitation on your capability to enjoy quality entertainment.
avatar
orcishgamer: Please tell me your entire argument doesn't hinge on "breaking the law == wrong". That is provably false. Laws, of themselves, carry no morality.
No, it doesn't. My argument hinges on the fact that games == entertainment but games =/= necessity. I would never presume to tell someone that killing to defend themselves or stealing food so their children could eat is wrong. But breaking a law to get something you enjoy is inherently amoral. Not necessarily immoral, but amoral.