hedwards: I have to say that troll topic is trolling.
In order for it to be theft there has to be conversion involved. If there isn't conversion then it isn't theft. Doesn't mean that it's OK to do it, but it does mean that it isn't theft. Theft has no mens rea requirement attached to it because it is universally acknowledged as being wrong, and even a small child realizes that it's not OK to steal.
Copyright infringement is not the act of downloading materials. It is perfectly legal in the US to download whatever copyright materials you like, so long as you don't break the DRM on it yourself and aren't providing the materials to others.
Which makes me wonder why on Earth this topic hasn't been locked, given that it was by the OP's admission posted with inflammatory language on purpose.
Hi! Sorry to see yet another person that believes I'm a troll. Yes, my original post would be irritating to someone that pirates games and gives that reason, that was the point. However, I've studiously avoided directly attacking individuals.
I think we all can agree that any conversation where people begin to focus on each other as the problem instead of the issue at hand is one that should not continue.