It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
This is why I pirate games and have to test with the version I am playing with. From AppDB (regarding Warhammer 40K Dawn of War):

Dark Crusade (Demo): Garbage
Dark Crusade: 1.x: Platinum

Soulstorm (Demo): Platinum
SoulStorm: Silver

So if I tested the Dark Crusade demo in Wine, I wouldn't have brought it because it didn't work, even though the full version would (oh look, an actual lost sale).
If I tested the Soulstorm demo, it would have run perfectly.. but I would have issues with the full version.

If I could buy a game and return it for a full refund is it didn't work (regardless of the fact that my OS isn't *supported*) I'd do that instead. I don't have a right to the game or any entertainment but my piracy results in more sales.. like Robin Hoods theft resulted in better living conditions for the poor.

I am Neutral Good, others here are obviously Lawful Good. Perhaps we can take a step back and realise, we are all on the same side :)

EDIT: Also, if I explained this situation to a publisher and their response was "I'd rather you didn't pirate it, even if it means we lose all possible sales to you".. I'd blacklist them and no longer pirate or buy any of their games (seeing as I would no longer be able to test them).
Post edited October 28, 2010 by xyem
high rated
avatar
hedwards: I have to say that troll topic is trolling.

In order for it to be theft there has to be conversion involved. If there isn't conversion then it isn't theft. Doesn't mean that it's OK to do it, but it does mean that it isn't theft. Theft has no mens rea requirement attached to it because it is universally acknowledged as being wrong, and even a small child realizes that it's not OK to steal.

Copyright infringement is not the act of downloading materials. It is perfectly legal in the US to download whatever copyright materials you like, so long as you don't break the DRM on it yourself and aren't providing the materials to others.

Which makes me wonder why on Earth this topic hasn't been locked, given that it was by the OP's admission posted with inflammatory language on purpose.
Hi! Sorry to see yet another person that believes I'm a troll. Yes, my original post would be irritating to someone that pirates games and gives that reason, that was the point. However, I've studiously avoided directly attacking individuals.

I think we all can agree that any conversation where people begin to focus on each other as the problem instead of the issue at hand is one that should not continue.
high rated
Runehamster: In general you're posing the wrong question. When laws are broken in a widespread fashion it typically isn't due to people feeling justified in breaking the law (most justification offered is simply rationalization after the fact), but rather because people see no compelling reason to respect the laws in question. To understand why people are breaking certain laws you need to come to understand why people don't see a reason to respect those laws. Once you've come to understand this you'll be equipped to approach discussions such as this in a more constructive manner.
avatar
Runehamster: Hi! Sorry to see yet another person that believes I'm a troll. Yes, my original post would be irritating to someone that pirates games and gives that reason, that was the point. However, I've studiously avoided directly attacking individuals.
Start a topic as a troll, and people are probably going to think you're a troll by the end, too. I don't pirate games for that reason, and found it irritating because you were wasting time and have completely failed to provide anything more compelling than what you originally stated in the topic post. Because of that failure, no one has been given any reason to consider you anything other than a troll.
There's really no excuse for piracy to "try" games because games are not essential. Not sure if you want the game or not? Don't fucking buy it, problem solved. No one owes you a game, no one owes you a chance to play it. It's so easy to abuse that mentality as well, I can't tell you how many times I have read something like: "torrented this game to try it, played it through in one night from start to finish, took 8 hours, game was a piece of shit so I uninstalled it fuck them ha ha ha." If you beat the game you enjoyed the experience and need to pay for it asshole.

As long as you are supporting the industry and buying games new at or near full price I'm not going to jump your shit, I'm pretty easy going, but if you make a point to say you try before you buy and it's completely justified I'm going to call you on it, because it isn't. Games are wants, luxury items, not needs... there is no justification.
"You are not owed or entitled to try the game before you buy it".

Just looked it up and this may be the "Composition Fallacy" (http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/composition.html).

Some pirates have the "entitlement" attribute. It doesn't mean that all pirates do. I haven't seen anyone on the pro-try-before-you-buy-using-piracy "side" state or imply they are owed or entitled to the entire game, merely that they regard it as a reasonable course of action. Or did I miss something?

EDIT: By the way, StingingVelvet, I completely agree that those that complete the game are not just trying-before-they-are-buying (making it immaterial to the discussion) and should have purchased the game.
Post edited October 29, 2010 by xyem
avatar
StingingVelvet: As long as you are supporting the industry and buying games new at or near full price I'm not going to jump your shit, I'm pretty easy going, but if you make a point to say you try before you buy and it's completely justified I'm going to call you on it, because it isn't. Games are wants, luxury items, not needs... there is no justification.
The justification is simple - it's extremely hard to return a game you don't like, due to flaws in the market.
avatar
PhoenixWright: The justification is simple - it's extremely hard to return a game you don't like, due to flaws in the market.
That justifies nothing, you never had to buy the game in the first place. There is no injustice where there is no force.
avatar
PhoenixWright: The justification is simple - it's extremely hard to return a game you don't like, due to flaws in the market.
avatar
StingingVelvet: That justifies nothing, you never had to buy the game in the first place. There is no injustice where there is no force.
Malware that installs itself didn't force you to do anything while it stole your credit card details. And you weren't forced to pick that credit provider who does nothing while you are lumbered with a few thousand $currency of debt.

Yet I get the feeling you would regard having to pay that as an injustice, despite that you were not forced to do anything :) After all, you don't *need* a credit card.
Post edited October 29, 2010 by xyem
high rated
avatar
StingingVelvet: That justifies nothing, you never had to buy the game in the first place. There is no injustice where there is no force.
avatar
GameRager: It's still deceptive marketing/salesmanship.....and in alot of other product fields you can get your money back, not so with most game stores and games.
Again, I don't think there's a justification for piracy, but this is a very reasonable point, Rager. The revision of return policies so software and movies are excluded is somewhat silly; I doubt that people purchasing, installing, cracking, and returning games was anywhere near as common as people just torrenting it. I just think there needs to be a very narrow window for returns.

On the other hand, I still haven't figured out why GameStop gives you a week to return a used game you're unsatisfied with. I would think some people would exploit that.
avatar
GameRager: It's still deceptive marketing/salesmanship.....and in alot of other product fields you can get your money back, not so with most game stores and games.
avatar
Runehamster: Again, I don't think there's a justification for piracy, but this is a very reasonable point, Rager. The revision of return policies so software and movies are excluded is somewhat silly; I doubt that people purchasing, installing, cracking, and returning games was anywhere near as common as people just torrenting it. I just think there needs to be a very narrow window for returns.

On the other hand, I still haven't figured out why GameStop gives you a week to return a used game you're unsatisfied with. I would think some people would exploit that.
The Spider Web Software guy will let you return a game after a year merely because you don't like him. He says he's never had anyone take advantage of it and that all his customers are awesome.

http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/08/being-nice-is-good-business.html

Actually most retail is built around a certain percentage of bad actors. They even have rude names for them at places such as Best Buy. It's built into the margin. Tons of people take unfair advantage of Costco's lax return policies as well. GameStop knows a certain number of people will screw them on this policy, they just account for it when they price the games.
high rated
avatar
Runehamster: Again, I don't think there's a justification for piracy, but this is a very reasonable point, Rager. The revision of return policies so software and movies are excluded is somewhat silly; I doubt that people purchasing, installing, cracking, and returning games was anywhere near as common as people just torrenting it. I just think there needs to be a very narrow window for returns.

On the other hand, I still haven't figured out why GameStop gives you a week to return a used game you're unsatisfied with. I would think some people would exploit that.
avatar
orcishgamer: The Spider Web Software guy will let you return a game after a year merely because you don't like him. He says he's never had anyone take advantage of it and that all his customers are awesome.

http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/08/being-nice-is-good-business.html

Actually most retail is built around a certain percentage of bad actors. They even have rude names for them at places such as Best Buy. It's built into the margin. Tons of people take unfair advantage of Costco's lax return policies as well. GameStop knows a certain number of people will screw them on this policy, they just account for it when they price the games.
...I must find this person's games and purchase them merely to show my support. The man has finally grasped what gamers want from developers. My biggest problem with developers is that they attach Draconian DRM that will only annoy the legal purchasers who don't wish to remove it because of the laws against it. >.<
Post edited October 29, 2010 by Runehamster
avatar
orcishgamer: The Spider Web Software guy will let you return a game after a year merely because you don't like him. He says he's never had anyone take advantage of it and that all his customers are awesome.

http://jeff-vogel.blogspot.com/2010/08/being-nice-is-good-business.html

Actually most retail is built around a certain percentage of bad actors. They even have rude names for them at places such as Best Buy. It's built into the margin. Tons of people take unfair advantage of Costco's lax return policies as well. GameStop knows a certain number of people will screw them on this policy, they just account for it when they price the games.
avatar
Runehamster: ...I must find this person's games and purchase them merely to show my support. The man has finally grasped what gamers want from developers. My biggest problem with developers is that they attach Draconian DRM that will only annoy the legal purchasers who don't wish to remove it because of the laws against it. >.<
http://www.spidweb.com/

He's been making them for 15 years and provides very long demos so you can try a ton of the game out (he does his own engines, so be warned some of his graphics are dated). Knock yourself out, I can say with nearly pure certainty that that guy loves nothing more than when people play and love his games.
high rated
avatar
orcishgamer: http://www.spidweb.com/

He's been making them for 15 years and provides very long demos so you can try a ton of the game out (he does his own engines, so be warned some of his graphics are dated). Knock yourself out, I can say with nearly pure certainty that that guy loves nothing more than when people play and love his games.
Thanks for the link! I'm glad to see something good coming out of this thread :D
avatar
Runehamster: ...I must find this person's games and purchase them merely to show my support. The man has finally grasped what gamers want from developers. My biggest problem with developers is that they attach Draconian DRM that will only annoy the legal purchasers who don't wish to remove it because of the laws against it. >.<
avatar
GameRager: SpiderWeb Software
Thanks!
Post edited October 29, 2010 by Runehamster
Lawful Good
I think that says it all, really. When I see something that is actually good then I support it. I don't just blindly support something just because it has the ability to exert a controlling influence.