GameRager: Would you like being lumped in as a racist just because you might be a certain race known to hate alot of other races, or a suspicious individual because you fit the profile for criminals and other shady figures? Wouldn't that be important enough for you to get upset enough over it to want to correct those views about yourself and your morality/behaviors/life? Stereotyping isn't cool, regardless of the circumstances.....and it's worth fighting against IMO.
While I would prefer to have this discussion in a more detached way, I feel I have to respond to you personally given that you have taken personal offense.
To reiterate some points from my wall of text:
You say that you download games because the way you do it makes it more or less benign, or even beneficial, to the the developers in that they haven't lost sales, you have a right to try the games out and so on. This is where our views differ. The reason I label you a pirate is because in some sense, it doesn't even matter that you may not have cost the developer a sale. There are a multitude of other reasons which make the downloading of games wrong by itself, even without examining consequence.
I do not call you a pirate because you are a young white male commenting on an internet forum (or whatever) and therefore you are costing the developers money. I don't believe this.
I call you a pirate because you admit to downloading games illegally, even if you believe your reasons are wholesome. In my view there is not "good" and "bad" piracy.
This is not stereotyping, and I make a point of not indulging in profiling of this kind.
GoJays2025: Let me ask you though based on the above quote. Is it fine to go 65km/h on a 60km/h road if you're going to see a movie? It's not legal; you're doing it as a means for obtaining entertainment... yet, most people won't think this is unreasonable, would they?
This really isn't a good parallel. It isn't relevant whether you speed to get to a movie, so I won't examine the rationale behind the speed limits.
The better comparison would be sneaking into the cinema to watch the film without buying a ticket. This is something that everyone would agree is both unreasonable and wrong.
Any reasonable person, and any court, would paint this as theft. And yet - the cinema still has the film reel. You were just intercepting a few photons. The cinema didn't really *lose* anything.
Exactly the same applies to filming the movie and posting the cam footage online. But somehow, because it's risky and requires physical action, this is more wrong than the similarly victimless crime of video game piracy.