It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
GameRager: Your statement=Don't copy that floppy in a nutshell, and plz don't give me that bs that the industry would shrivel up because of piracy......it hasn't and never will.

Me? What I don't want is holier than thou people telling me how "bad" I am for doing what I do, or lumping all those like me in the same basket as being all bad apples. I don't need sermons, so I humbly ask you and RuneHamster to please stop trying to preach it to me because it's never worked and simply will never work with me or people like me.

By continuing to spout his anti-piracy/pro-law gobblygook, he's just coming off as arrogant to me on behalf on his position(regardless of his intent), and ignorant of the fact that I don't want to change and nothing short of jail or death will ever make me do so. :\
The fact that you don't like being lumped in with the bad apples is kind of immaterial.
I might revise my position if you give me a decent rebuttal other than "stop telling me not to copy floppy"

I agree, I was probably a bit over the top in my rhetoric. I didn't actually mean that the industry would collapse as a result of piracy, but I don't think it's healthy, and I think the core of the point stands.
avatar
Runehamster: In my humble opinion, breaking a law is wrong when done for one's own entertainment, regardless of how silly the law might or might not be.
avatar
GoJays2025: No it's fine, I don't think you were really attacking anyone on a personal level. I agree with some stuff you've said, but it's just a little pointless arguing over morals since people all have different beliefs.

Let me ask you though based on the above quote. Is it fine to go 65km/h on a 60km/h road if you're going to see a movie? It's not legal; you're doing it as a means for obtaining entertainment... yet, most people won't think this is unreasonable, would they?
No, they would not, is the simple answer. My personal opinion is probably apparent from my previous posts, so why beat a dead horse? (on a side note, there should really be an SPCUA - Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Undead Animals).

And GameRager, I would very much appreciate your reading my post a little way up this page. I think you have a misunderstanding of my motives and intentions.
high rated
avatar
Runehamster: Gentlemen, I didn't attack any of you personally. I don't have any personal stake in whether you pirate a game or not. I was pointing out an invalidity in the arguments I've heard for piracy. In my humble opinion, breaking a law is wrong when done for one's own entertainment, regardless of how silly the law might or might not be. I can see this opinion is not universal, and beyond the point of legality it is a matter of personal morals. You do not need to justify yourself to me, and I did not mean for any of you to take this personally. In regards to my being a troll, I have endeavored to speak reasonably and not attack anyone personally. If I failed in this, I crave the forgiveness of those I may have insulted.

On the other hand, threatening downreps for an opinion that, regardless of personal feelings, is entirely legal, is not particularly intimidating. I have been on GOG for a very long time, and I don't really take notice of reputation points myself.
avatar
RowdyRodimus: I hope you didn't take the Youtube video I posted as an attack on your stance. It's just that honestly as I said in the post, while reading your comments I heard that song playing in my head. (I think it has to do with seeing it so much in discussions like this on the Escapist lol)

Also, my last post wasn't about anyone in particular as it was just one of the ways it seems that companies could try to combat piracy. The sad thing is, we have to remind the developers and publishers that the best way to sell more product is to have a good product in the first place.

If you took my posts as an attack or criticism towards you, I apologize as that was not my intent at all.
Understood, and not at all. I spent three years on RuneScape, I have +10 to save against internet rage. I also recognize it, and you came off pretty much as quietly amused.
high rated
avatar
Runehamster: No, they would not, is the simple answer. My personal opinion is probably apparent from my previous posts, so why beat a dead horse? (on a side note, there should really be an SPCUA - Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Undead Animals).

And GameRager, I would very much appreciate your reading my post a little way up this page. I think you have a misunderstanding of my motives and intentions.
avatar
GameRager: I responded already in another thread(9.99 vs 5.99 I think) which should cover this so I won't reply again here beyond this reply. 0.o
I was referring to this:

Gentlemen, I didn't attack any of you personally. I don't have any personal stake in whether you pirate a game or not. I was pointing out an invalidity in the arguments I've heard for piracy. In my humble opinion, breaking a law is wrong when done for one's own entertainment, regardless of how silly the law might or might not be. I can see this opinion is not universal, and beyond the point of legality it is a matter of personal morals. You do not need to justify yourself to me, and I did not mean for any of you to take this personally. In regards to my being a troll, I have endeavored to speak reasonably and not attack anyone personally. If I failed in this, I crave the forgiveness of those I may have insulted.

On the other hand, threatening downreps for an opinion that, regardless of personal feelings, is entirely legal, is not particularly intimidating. I have been on GOG for a very long time, and I don't really take notice of reputation points myself.
avatar
GameRager: Would you like being lumped in as a racist just because you might be a certain race known to hate alot of other races, or a suspicious individual because you fit the profile for criminals and other shady figures? Wouldn't that be important enough for you to get upset enough over it to want to correct those views about yourself and your morality/behaviors/life? Stereotyping isn't cool, regardless of the circumstances.....and it's worth fighting against IMO.
While I would prefer to have this discussion in a more detached way, I feel I have to respond to you personally given that you have taken personal offense.
To reiterate some points from my wall of text:

You say that you download games because the way you do it makes it more or less benign, or even beneficial, to the the developers in that they haven't lost sales, you have a right to try the games out and so on. This is where our views differ. The reason I label you a pirate is because in some sense, it doesn't even matter that you may not have cost the developer a sale. There are a multitude of other reasons which make the downloading of games wrong by itself, even without examining consequence.

I do not call you a pirate because you are a young white male commenting on an internet forum (or whatever) and therefore you are costing the developers money. I don't believe this.
I call you a pirate because you admit to downloading games illegally, even if you believe your reasons are wholesome. In my view there is not "good" and "bad" piracy.

This is not stereotyping, and I make a point of not indulging in profiling of this kind.


avatar
GoJays2025: Let me ask you though based on the above quote. Is it fine to go 65km/h on a 60km/h road if you're going to see a movie? It's not legal; you're doing it as a means for obtaining entertainment... yet, most people won't think this is unreasonable, would they?
This really isn't a good parallel. It isn't relevant whether you speed to get to a movie, so I won't examine the rationale behind the speed limits.

The better comparison would be sneaking into the cinema to watch the film without buying a ticket. This is something that everyone would agree is both unreasonable and wrong.
Any reasonable person, and any court, would paint this as theft. And yet - the cinema still has the film reel. You were just intercepting a few photons. The cinema didn't really *lose* anything.

Exactly the same applies to filming the movie and posting the cam footage online. But somehow, because it's risky and requires physical action, this is more wrong than the similarly victimless crime of video game piracy.
avatar
GoJays2025: Let me ask you though based on the above quote. Is it fine to go 65km/h on a 60km/h road if you're going to see a movie? It's not legal; you're doing it as a means for obtaining entertainment... yet, most people won't think this is unreasonable, would they?
avatar
Tonjevic: This really isn't a good parallel. It isn't relevant whether you speed to get to a movie, so I won't examine the rationale behind the speed limits.
No, no. I wasn't using that example to parallel piracy to theft. It's because Runehamster said something about doing something illegal for entertainment is immoral. Just wanted to ask him about that.

Oh and it probably is 'more' wrong to film a movie in a theatre and supplying it on the internet. Just as you might look a drug dealer in a more negative light than somebody who buys and uses pot occasionally. By supplying it, you know your deed will be abused by many people, but by downloading at least you can make sure you're adhering to some kind of moral code.
Post edited October 28, 2010 by GoJays2025
@GameRager:

Hehe, I don't know why but I find something in your post amusing; I can't stop myself from smiling a bit.

Anyway, keep in mind that I'm not calling you a bad person. I don't hate people who download software. I just think there are different categories of piracy and none of them are justified.

In the same way, I would not call all people who were in the nazi party bad people, but I would say that their membership of the party was a reprehensible act, whatever their reasons were.

@GoJays:

Ah, I see what you meant. I thought the point Hamster was trying to make was that it might be valid to question the law if it withheld necessities like food, but not if it's something relatively flippant like entertainment.

I suppose the discussion that needs to be had is more one about where civil disobedience is justified.
Post edited October 28, 2010 by Tonjevic
avatar
GameRager: His words echo my own sentiments:

"Someone who is facing long-term unemployment and bankruptcy probably should not pay for my game. And, in that case, if stealing my game gives them a temporary reprieve from their misery (and there's a lot of misery out there right now), I'm cool with that. I'm happy to help. These are my fellow citizens, and I want to help out how I can."
The beauty of his argument is that, as the IP owner, he has the right to make that decision for his own products. It is NOT up to the consumer to decide, "Geez, man, times are really bad for me right now so I deserve to have this $29.99 game for free. Those people with jobs can pay for the game but it's okay for me to have it for free because I don't have $29.99 right now but I really want to play this game." If life sucks that bad then there are a kajillion truly free games out there that can assuage the misery.

Oh, you left out the part where he said pirating games is wrong:

"Of Course, Piracy Is Almost Always Wrong

I think that the best way of evaluating the morality of an action is to ask, "What would happen if everyone who wanted to do it did it?" Littering and dumping toxic waste into rivers are wrong because, if everyone who wanted to do those things did them, our streets would be choked with refuse and our drinking water would be half benzene. And pirating PC games is wrong because, were it not for that minority of worthy souls who actually chip in, the industry that makes the games we love would descend into a shadow realm of tiny ad-supported Flash games and Farmville. Some people would be cool with that, but I'm looking forward to playing Starcraft 2, thanks."

I guess his words echo my sentiments, too.
avatar
HereForTheBeer: I think that the best way of evaluating the morality of an action is to ask, "What would happen if everyone who wanted to do it did it?"
I'm pretty sure everyone who wants to do it is doing it.

EDIT: Some questions to consider:

- Why should I pay someone an absurd amount of money for a game that hasn't been sold in years?
- Why should I pay for another copy of a game whose disc is broken? I bought the license...
- Why should I hope and pray that GOG offers the extremely old and obscure game that I want to play but which is caught in a disastrous situation between multiple publishing companies? Of course I'd buy it if it was ever to see the light of day again...
- Why should I not see if a game actually runs on my computer? Speak of system requirements all you'd like, but we all know they don't have the final word.
- Why should I not play a game because its download from the site I bought it from is no longer offered? Sub question - why should I no longer be able to play the games I purchased when Steam goes down?
Post edited October 28, 2010 by PhoenixWright
My problem with the whole "But there are demos..." argument is this:

Demos in this day and age are *very* lacking. I find I can't get a good taste of a PC game on most of the demos that are released. Shareware was the perfect "demo" for me. Doom, Wolfenstein, Blood, Duke 3D, Heretic etc all came with the first FULL episode of the game for you to decide if you liked it. That was usually about 8 (9 including secret levels) full levels of the game and a taste of the story for you to see if it grabs you. Current demos are a tidbit, sometimes completely taken out of context and potentially in a random chunk of the game. I haven't played a modern demo that sold me on a PC game in a very long time.

Plus as it's been stated before there have been situations where a demo is nicely polished and runs quite well, then the full product comes out and it's a buggy mess. It seems a lot of companies rely too much on the "Oh well, we can just patch it later" philosphy these days just to get a game out the door. Unless it's a game I know I'll like, I'd much rather know if it's going to be an unplayable mess and not worth my money ahead of time so I can either hold off buying til it's patched and fixed up, or avoid it completely.

I guess this is my rant since I'm just going to move to another thing stated as why piracy should be wrong: Reviews. Reviews are so damn subjective it's not even funny. I know plenty of games I enjoy that most people say are terrible and even more games that reviews praise as the greatest thing ever that I view as garbage. Just reading a review isn't going to sell me on a game, whether it be a professional reviewer or a common user. I'd much rather try the game out and decide *for myself* whether or not I'm going to enjoy the game.

As I've said in the Limewire closing topic, I don't pirate even half as much as I used to, but that's basically because I'm a fairly jaded with what comes out these days for the most part (not saying good things don't come out, they most certainly do), and GOG is giving me an outlet to where I can easily buy the older releases that I at one time pirated because I didn't want to pay what sellers consider "rare" and "collectible" pricetags for older games..
Post edited October 28, 2010 by CalamityRanger
high rated
I think the usefulness of this thread has come to end. There have been interesting posts on both sides, but I can see that posting a thread actually stating that piracy is wrong was foolish considering the current community on GoG. Again, to those I offended, please understand that if you took my comments to heart as personal attacks, this was not my intention - in other circumstances I'd probably think most of you are swell guys (or gals).

I would appreciate it if a moderator would lock this thread, please?
avatar
HereForTheBeer: I think that the best way of evaluating the morality of an action is to ask, "What would happen if everyone who wanted to do it did it?"
avatar
PhoenixWright: I'm pretty sure everyone who wants to do it is doing it.
I'm sure you're wrong on that, my nephew being an example.
EDIT: Some questions to consider:

- Why should I pay someone an absurd amount of money for a game that hasn't been sold in years?
Why should you arbitrarily decide that since you feel the price is too high then you should get it for free?
- Why should I pay for another copy of a game whose disc is broken? I bought the license...
Then you're not pirating since, as you say, you already bought the license. If you have actually encountered this problem, did you look for a resolution with the IP owner or did you go straight to a warez site?
- Why should I hope and pray that GOG offers the extremely old and obscure game that I want to play but which is caught in a disastrous situation between multiple publishing companies? Of course I'd buy it if it was ever to see the light of day again...
Why should you arbitrarily decide that since the game isn't available for sale, that you should instead get it for free?
- Why should I not see if a game actually runs on my computer? Speak of system requirements all you'd like, but we all know they don't have the final word.
Why should you not download and play the demo for free? You gotta take the time to download and install a file either way. May as well choose the legal version which nets the same results.
- Why should I not play a game because its download from the site I bought it from is no longer offered?
This is similar to the broken disk question. If you legally bought the program then you should retain the license rights unless the agreed-to license stipulates otherwise. In other words, this isn't piracy.
Sub question - why should I no longer be able to play the games I purchased when Steam goes down?
That is a question for Steam to answer. And Steam isn't the only source for games (though it MAY be the only option for some games). Obviously you know that this is a possibility with Steam, and you obviously accept that possibility when clicking the "Buy" button. If Steam is the sole source then you're facing two choices: accept the agreement and play the game, or don't accept it and don't play it.
avatar
PhoenixWright: - Why should I not see if a game actually runs on my computer? Speak of system requirements all you'd like, but we all know they don't have the final word.
avatar
HereForTheBeer: Why should you not download and play the demo for free? You gotta take the time to download and install a file either way. May as well choose the legal version which nets the same results.
I mostly agree with you on your points, but I just have to say please refer to CalamityRanger's post about demos. Also, another thing that wasn't mentioned there that applies to this specific case, demos are often based on games which are not officially completed. Due to this, there may be last minute changes that affect performance. Some demos also check system requirements differently than the full version (maybe due to the same reason), such that while a demo may not complain about your system specs, the full product will, or even vice versa.
I have to say that troll topic is trolling.

In order for it to be theft there has to be conversion involved. If there isn't conversion then it isn't theft. Doesn't mean that it's OK to do it, but it does mean that it isn't theft. Theft has no mens rea requirement attached to it because it is universally acknowledged as being wrong, and even a small child realizes that it's not OK to steal.

Copyright infringement is not the act of downloading materials. It is perfectly legal in the US to download whatever copyright materials you like, so long as you don't break the DRM on it yourself and aren't providing the materials to others.

Which makes me wonder why on Earth this topic hasn't been locked, given that it was by the OP's admission posted with inflammatory language on purpose.
avatar
HereForTheBeer: I'm sure you're wrong on that, my nephew being an example.
Sounds like he doesn't actually want to pirate, and has only considered it. The technology is available to anyone who wants to do it, so there is no excuse for not participating if you actually want to.

avatar
HereForTheBeer: Why should you arbitrarily decide that since you feel the price is too high then you should get it for free?
What I meant here is price gouging by third party sellers. If your question stands, my answer is that there's no reason for me to pay arbitrary prices that don't support those who produced the game. As a side note, I am very actively against these sorts of practices because they do their part to try and prevent the general public from experiencing whatever art is being discussed.

avatar
HereForTheBeer: Why should you arbitrarily decide that since the game isn't available for sale, that you should instead get it for free?
Because that way a piece of artwork is not lost forever. We've had enough of that through mass book burnings, and there's no reason to see it today, especially because that artwork will make it into the public domain some day. Piracy will preserve this material until it is legal to do so, unlike any other organization or service. Same with GOG executables when GOG is no longer, same with every other game that is available no longer through legal means.

avatar
HereForTheBeer: Why should you not download and play the demo for free? You gotta take the time to download and install a file either way. May as well choose the legal version which nets the same results.
We've already covered this in this topic, and this is the last time I'm saying it - many demos differ from the final product that you purchase, which makes you waste even more time and money than if you had tested the final product.
Post edited October 28, 2010 by PhoenixWright